people staring 2

Apple stamps down hard on an artist who set up security cameras in their New York apple stores. Secret Service were called in to slap him with a computer fraud charge. Crook or gutsy artist?

A project by electronic artist Kyle McDonald gained him a computer fraud investigation and an audience with four U.S. Secret Servicemen in suits this Thursday morning. McDonald had apparently created a program which automatically took pictures of customers shopping at Apple stores in New York, and he did it without anyone knowing. Once Apple found out though, it seems like they weren’t too happy with him.

The project captured people staring into computer screens while shopping at two New York Apple store locations. Three days in June marked the extent of McDonald’s documentation of these people shopping. Each night the 25-year-old had to go back in and reinstall the programs since the stores wiped their computers daily. He then took these photos and uploaded them to a Tumblr blog called People Staring at Computers.

“We have this expression on our face [when we use computers] that basically says that we’re not interacting with anybody, we’re interacting with the machine,” the Brooklyn artist said according to an exclusive with Mashable. “Even if there are a lot of people in the room at the Apple Store, you’re not interacting with them.”

people staring at computers

McDonald eventually set up an exhibition at the Apple stores, and customers saw photos of themselves and others staring back from the computer screens. In the video posted below, the artist says that people hit the “escape” button upon seeing a picture of themselves.

At one point, close to 100 Apple store computers rang McDonald’s servers every minute. All that traffic was eventually traced back to the Tumblr site by an Apple technician in Cupertino—Apple monitors all the traffic in its stores. Subsequently, Secret Service agents paid the artist a visit with a warrant for computer fraud and confiscated two computers as well as flash drives and an iPod.

McDonald protests, claiming that before he began his project he obtained permission from the Apple security guards to take photos inside the store. He also asked customers if he could take photos of them as well, though those customers probably thought by camera. McDonald says that had these people told him no he would have stopped, and said he would take their photos down if any asked. He even refrained from posting the code for his program online to keep it from being used for evil. Is he crook or is he just a gutsy artist?

Showing 8 comments

  1. Benjamin Kubilus at 5:11am 1st October 2011 I just want to correct my embarassing typo of writing "no" where I meant "know".
  2. Bruce at 2:31pm 9th July 2011 am i the only one who thinks that this is what art should be, it make you look at the world in a different perspective. So many people have ideas but don't act on them. I don't how I could be offended by this if his intentions were benevolent and not malicious.
  3. Benjamin Kubilus at 5:57pm 8th July 2011 At first, I thought he was a jerk. But, after reading the article, I would say gutsy artist - if he really did let people no and obtain their permission. Having first given permission, from whatever angle they thought it might be, I would think they would still understand that things like, say, picking their nose, might be photographed. So, if people really did know they were being pictured, and they really did have a way of knowing where to see the pics, and they really could ask for them to be taken down, I think he's an okay guy.
  4. Ian Bell at 9:20am 8th July 2011 He scammed people. Taking pictures from a digital camera is different than with a laptop. He also installed a program on Apple's systems without their permission. Simple as that.
  5. sepepper at 4:49am 8th July 2011 Very ironic in one respect, seeing that the government can tap into ANYONE's networked computer in search of their latest boogeyman, and turn on ANYONE's built-in or attached camera system, without a warrant, courtesy of the unconstitutional Patriot Act.
  6. Matt Gentner at 7:47am 8th July 2011 um yeah Apple doan play
  7. wyrz at 11:21pm 7th July 2011 Guess what the answer will be for every future photographer who asks to take pictures inside an Apple Store. NO! This is why we can't take pictures of nice things, people.
  8. Dan Gaul at 10:27pm 7th July 2011 Gutsy artist I say, but he should have known better.
Close Suggestion Overnights planned for Apple stores July 13; Lion release and MacBook Air refresh likely
View Article