Skip to main content

Humans don’t trust autonomous parking systems, study says

BMW i3 autonomous parking
Image used with permission by copyright holder
Self-driving cars may get a lot of attention, but the first frontier of autonomy may very well be parking. Autonomous parking systems are quickly proliferating and getting more sophisticated, meaning one of the most tedious aspects of driving could be one of the first cars can manage entirely by themselves.

If humans let them, that is. A new survey from AAA (via Autoblog) found that autonomous parking systems generally perform better than humans, but that humans still don’t trust them. That’s partially down to distrust of machines in general, but humans’ inflated sense of their own abilities was a major factor as well, researchers found.

Compared to human drivers who parked manually with the aid of a backup camera, autonomous systems experienced 81 percent fewer curb strikes and used 47 percent fewer maneuvers. The robots also parked 37 percent closer to the curb, and did it 10 percent faster.

The cars tested included a 2015 Lincoln MKC, 2015 Mercedes-Benz ML400 4Matic, 2015 Cadillac CTS Vsport, 2015 BMW i3, and a 2015 Jeep Cherokee Limited. They were selected to encompass a broad range of suppliers, hardware, and system designs. While most of the vehicles in this sample group are luxury models, self-parking capabilities are also trickling down to more mainstream models.

But while this technology may be available and working as advertised, that doesn’t mean consumers want to use it. Carmakers are piling on connectivity features, electronic driver aids, and semi-autonomous systems, but a recent J.D. Power survey found that 20 percent of car owners have never used almost half the technology features in their cars.

When it comes to autonomous parking, that may be at least partially because drivers don’t think they need the help. In the AAA study, 86 percent of men and 71 percent of women felt confident in their own parking abilities. At the same time, 72 percent of both men and women said they distrust autonomous parking systems. A recent survey from eDriving also found that 85 percent of drivers consider themselves “fairly good” or “very good” drivers.

Warranted or not, drivers’ confidence in their own abilities will make it more difficult for manufacturers and tech advocates to sell the public on a more automated future. AAA plans to conduct additional studies focusing on features like blind-spot monitoring and automatic braking. How will people react to those?

Editors' Recommendations

Stephen Edelstein
Stephen is a freelance automotive journalist covering all things cars. He likes anything with four wheels, from classic cars…
Cruise autonomous vehicle drives over woman just after she was hit by another car
A Cruise autonomous car.

An autonomous vehicle (AV) operated by Cruise ran over a pedestrian in San Francisco on Monday night just after she’d been hit by another car, the San Francisco Chronicle reported.

According to witnesses, the force of the initial impact knocked the woman into the path of the Cruise robotaxi, leaving her pinned under one of its wheels. The driver in the other car reportedly fled the scene.

Read more
Cruise says it’s nearing approval for mass production of futuristic robotaxi
Interior of Cruise's Origin vehicle.

Robotaxi company Cruise is “just days away” from getting regulatory approval that would pave the way for mass production of its purpose-built driverless vehicle, CEO Kyle Vogt said on Thursday in comments reported by the Detroit Free Press.

General Motors-backed Cruise unveiled the vehicle -- called Origin -- in early 2020, presenting the kind of driverless car that we all dreamed of when R&D in the sector kicked off years ago; a vehicle without a steering wheel and without pedals. A vehicle with passenger seats only.

Read more
Don’t let these hidden EV fees catch you off guard (or deter you)
The front three-quarter view of a 2022 Rivian against a rocky backdrop.

EV manufacturers have long claimed that while electric cars often cost more upfront, they’ll save you money in the long run thanks to the lower cost of maintenance and the fact that electricity is cheaper than gas. While it's true that EVs are cheaper over the life of a car, a number of factors can affect how long it will take to recoup the upfront investment. You've probably considered the cost of charging at home and at public charging stations, but here's one factor catching EV buyers off guard: state registration fees.

Depending on where you live, you could pay hundreds of dollars more to register your car than drivers of gasoline cars do. Here's why that's happening, how much it's costing EV drivers, and whether you should be concerned.
Why are states imposing EV taxes?
There are some good reasons why electric car registration fees are higher than those for gas cars. In most states, there’s a gas tax that’s usually at least 20 cents per gallon, and sometimes much more. California, for instance, charges 58 cents per gallon. That tax usually goes to things like road upkeep.

Read more