Best Buy, Samsung, Others Hit With GPL Lawsuit

By Geoff Duncan December 15, 2009

Samsung Luxia 8500 Series LED LCD HDTV — Image used with permission by copyright holder

The Freedom Law Center has filed suit against consumer electronics Best Buy, Samsung, Westinghouse, and eleven other consumer electronics companies for selling products containing BusyBox, a widely used Linux utility library that’s available for use under the GNU General Public License (GPL) version 2. BusyBox has a long, solid history for providing functionality to consumer electronics and other devices using embedded Linux operating systems, and under the terms of the GPL anyone can use, modify, and distribute BusyBox for free as long as they distribute the source code to customers, with any of their changes. The Software Freedom Law Center alleges that more than 20 products from these 14 manufacturers have failed to meet their obligations under the GPL: they’re including BusyBox, but they arent’ abiding my the minimal requirements of the GPL to distribute source code.

“We try very hard to resolve these types of issues privately with companies, as we always prefer cooperation,” said SFLC counsel Aaron Williamson, in a statement. “We brought this suit as a last resort after each of these defendants ignored us or failed to meaningfully respond to our requests that they release the source code”.

The new suit isn’t the first time major companies have been taken to court for rolling BusyBox into their products without distributing source code: previous defendants include Monsoon, Xterasys, Cisco, and Verizon. All those cases have been settled, with the companies agreeing to distribute source code.

The 14 companies named in the lawsuit are Best Buy, Samsung, Westinghouse, JVC, Western Digital, Bosch, Phoebe Micro, Humax, Comtrend, Dobbs-Stanford, Versa Technology, Zyxel, Astac, and GCI Technologies. Nearly 20 products are alleged to contain BusyBox in violation of the GPL license, including Best Buy’s Insignia Blu-ray DVD Player, Westinghouse’s 52-inch LCD TV, and Samsung HDTVs.

Editors' Recommendations

Topics

Samsung

Former Digital Trends Contributor

Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…

Computing

Here’s everything to consider when buying a CPU in 2024

AMD Ryzen 9 3900x pins.

Searching for a new CPU in 2024 presents you with excellent options for powerful processors, budget chips that punch well above their weight, and some incredibly efficient options that are perfect for small builds. That's what makes the modern CPU landscape so exciting: You don't just need to buy the best processor you can afford.

The right CPU for you is one that can do everything you need right now, and do it well, while also providing some future-proofing, and ideally, a clear upgrade path for the future. Here's how to buy a CPU in 2024.
CPU specs, explained

Computing

This Samsung 27-inch QHD gaming monitor is almost 50% off

Samsung's 2023 Odyssey Neo G7 sitting on a table.

Complete your PC gaming setup with the 27-inch Samsung Odyssey G6 curved gaming monitor, which is available from Walmart with a $333 discount that nearly halves its original price of $700 to only $367. This is one of the most attractive monitor deals that we've seen recently due to all of the features that you'll be getting for this affordable price. You're going to have to act fast though -- the offer may expire at any moment, so you're going to want to complete your purchase before that happens.

Why you should buy the 27-inch Samsung Odyssey G6 curved gaming monitor
The Samsung Odyssey G6 curved gaming monitor is an excellent display for the best PC games. The gaming monitor offers QHD resolution so that you'll enjoy sharp details and vivid colors while you're playing, while the 1000R curvature matches the curve of your eye and fills your peripheral vision for a more comfortable viewing experience. This is important when you have the habit of playing video games for several hours at a time. The Samsung Odyssey G6 curved gaming monitor also supports the Samsung Gaming Hub, which will let you access various cloud gaming services in one place.

Computing

7 best Chromebooks for 2024: the best for every budget

Chromebooks might have a hard time competing with Windows laptops and MacBooks, but that doesn't mean they don't have their place. We've reviewed hundreds of laptops over the years, testing for important qualities like performance, battery life, and display quality — and we've found that Chromebooks consistently excel at performance and reliability.

You can find Chromebooks from Google, HP, Lenovo, Acer, and many other branss, and we've dug through them to put together this roundup of the best Chromebooks on the market. They're incredibly accessible devices, and for the right person, a Chromebook can be the best laptop in terms of value.