Skip to main content

Microsoft’s OneDrive debacle shows its cloud commitment is weaker than promised

An individual using a laptop that shows the logo for Microsoft OneDrive.
Pablo Calvog/Shutterstock
When Microsoft announced earlier this week that it would no longer be handing out unlimited cloud storage to Office 365 subscribers via its OneDrive service, those affected were obviously not enthused. Users who were previously unbounded by the all-you-can-eat buffet that was endless cloud storage will soon be limited to a less satisfying 1TB. Those latching on to the 100 and 200GB plans will see reduction to a dismal 50GB at the same monthly cost. Even free users will be affected, by a reduction from 15GB to a meager 5GB of complimentary storage. And that all goes without mentioning the 15GB camera roll feature, which is to be axed altogether.

You may not, at first glance, understand why this is frustrating. So we were duped — a company changed its mind a year later because it was losing money — what else is new?

But that’s not the whole story. No, unlimited storage was a backhanded gift to Microsoft’s loyal customers a little less than a year ago. Before that, the storage plans were exactly as they are now, limited. Microsoft is flip-flopping more than a career politician, but why? To put a dent in Google’s market share, of course!

A shot in the dark at Google Drive

Instead of focusing on improving the overall OneDrive experience for its loyal customers, Microsoft was more concerned with stealing customers from Google, its main rival in cloud storage, despite the inevitable repercussions. Microsoft explicitly called it a “productivity war,” one that would — if Microsoft had its way — leave Google bleeding and Microsoft drowning in revenue. Unfortunately, however, as the company soon realized, it was not prepared for the fight ahead.

That’s because, despite offering up “unlimited” cloud storage, the OneDrive team didn’t take into account the fact that many of its subscribers would actually take advantage of a backup capacity without limits. In turn, when Microsoft realized some of its users were uploading, say, 75-terabytes’ worth of pirated movie collections, its jabs at Google just weren’t worth the cost.

However, considering the average Office 365 subscriber only used about 5.5GB of their designated unlimited OneDrive storage, those uploading their colossal unauthorized film catalogs were clearly in the minority.

Microsoft didn’t want to afford unlimited storage

In an official statement on the OneDrive blog, Redmond claimed it was compromising on “extreme backup scenarios” in order to refocus on collaborative productivity solutions. First of all, that’s not true. Secondly, it’s a cop-out to be expected from a company preemptively trying to save its own hide. Like with any storage solution, OneDrive’s purpose should be versatile. It shouldn’t be reliant on one person’s specific needs. It can be collaborative and capacious at the same time.

OneDrive should be collaborative and capacious at the same time.

A few rogue users uploading a ton of data doesn’t call for measures as drastic as omitting the unlimited tier altogether. The term unlimited implies that there are, in fact, no limits, no bounds. Of course a few people are going to take advantage of that. Microsoft’s sales projections should have taken that into account before increasing its storage options last year.

Microsoft isn’t some unsuspecting San Francisco start-up. It’s a multi-billion dollar corporation, assuredly with a number of highly qualified market research specialists. As such, it should know that going back on its word could inflict more damage on the company than losing a couple thousand dollars from a few Internet file hoarders.

Smaller companies are doing unlimited — so Microsoft can too

Ever heard of CrashPlan or BackBlaze? Kudos to you if you have. Admittedly, I’ve been living under a rock, so when I stumbled across these handy services, I was astonished. For $5 a month, you can get unlimited cloud storage from either of these companies. They’re not shying away from productivity either, making use of technological clichés like “When the world is your office, CrashPlan is your personal backup assistant.”

Cliché, but effective.

windows-10-onedrive-cloud-storage
Greg Mombert/Digital Trends
Greg Mombert/Digital Trends

Despite securing coverage from major news outlets such as WSJ, NBC, etc., these companies are microscopic compared to Microsoft. Yet they can somehow afford to hand out unlimited storage at an even lower cost to their customers.

Obviously, they’re going to account for the select few who’ll back up every season of their favorite HBO programs, even if that equates to a few terabytes’ worth. But a cloud storage company proficient in sales is going to ignore the minority — no matter how rampant — in favor of the dominating customer base. Those who ignore the service for all but uploading a few gigabytes’ worth in documents. Those who help the company make a profit.

Borrowing Google’s market share

If nothing else is learned from all of this, Microsoft might finally discover that precautionary measures should be taken before launching monumental service changes. Instead of disregarding the consequences in favor of some healthy corporate competition, perhaps Redmond should take a step back at say, “Hey, if we advertise something as being unlimited, maybe we shouldn’t completely change the one thing people liked about our service just because it increases our operation expenses.”

Competition is good. If Microsoft wants to take down Google Drive, I say go for it. But don’t toy with your customers along the way. That’s not a permanent solution in the long-term goal of stealing market share. In fact, Microsoft didn’t steal Google’s market share at all. It simply borrowed it and swiftly decided to give it back. Unless, for some odd reason, you have a strong preference to use Microsoft Word over Google Docs, there’s little incentive to be a OneDrive subscriber anymore.

Microsoft has made a lot of progress lately. Windows 10 is great. The Surface Book is flying off store shelves. But perhaps its greatest theme, as of late, has been a supposed focus on a “cloud-first” future. That might be true if you’re an enterprise customer seeking cloud storage for a web platform, or for your thousands of employees. If you’re an individual, though, it seems Microsoft doesn’t care to be cloud-first at all.

Editors' Recommendations

Gabe Carey
Former Digital Trends Contributor
A freelancer for Digital Trends, Gabe Carey has been covering the intersection of video games and technology since he was 16…
PowerPoint is easier than ever with Microsoft’s new A.I. tools
microsoft powerpoint ai office 365 designer transformation

Microsoft is leaning in on the power of artificial intelligence to help Office 365 subscribers create beautiful PowerPoint slides. By dragging and dropping in your favorite images and the relevant text to a slide, PowerPoint Designer leverages A.I. to automatically suggest compelling themes, layouts, and designs for you to use. In addition, A.I. can be called upon to help presenters make big numbers in a slide more relatable, and artificial intelligence can also help coach you in becoming a better speaker. These new A.I. tools follow the recent addition of A.I.-based closed-captioning feature for PowerPoint.

"We noticed that people were spending too much time building presentations, too much time on slides, and they weren't having the impact that they wanted," Shawn Villaron, PowerPoint Partner Group Program Manager at Microsoft, said in a video briefing. "So we started with a hypothesis that we could actually do better -- we could use artificial intelligence to find ways to make it easier for people to make highly impactful, highly effective presentations."
Building smarter slides

Read more
M4 chip: here’s everything we know about Apple’s latest silicon
Official render of Apple's M4 chip.

Apple has just announced a new slate of iPads, including an updated iPad Pro. What has that got to do with the M4 chip? Quite a lot, as those iPad Pro tablets come equipped with the M4, shockingly enough. That gives us plenty of information on what the chip might be capable of -- and what it could be like when it finally arrives in the Mac.

But while Apple spilled the beans on the M4 in its iPad range, concrete details on how that chip will affect the Mac are few and far between. If you feel adrift without a compass and want to know what to expect, you’re in the right place. We’ve gathered up all the latest M4 chip rumors and known information in one place.
Price and release date

Read more
Here’s why M4 MacBooks were a no-show — and when they’re coming
A person holds a MacBook Air at Apple's Worldwide Developer's Conference (WWDC) in 2023.

Apple has just released a new iPad Pro with a shocking surprise -- it includes the M4 chip rather than making the more standard upgrade to the M3. It's the first time we've seen an iPad debut the latest M-series Apple Silicon rather than a Mac, which may leave us Mac fans wondering what's going on.

So, what's the deal? Don't worry -- M4 Macs are surely on the way, but these new iPad Pros have thrown in a wrench into the conventional timeline.
The missing M4 Macs

Read more