Skip to main content

Auction winner gets to keep her moon rock bag after court battle with NASA

Gathering Moon Rock (Apollo 11)
It seems that Nancy Carlson of Inverness, Illinois spent $995 to buy a small, rather innocuous looking “lunar sample return bag” at an auction held by the U.S. Marshals Service. No problem there, right? Go shopping, place the winning bid, pay the amount, have a nice day. Ah, but there’s more to the story than meets the eye.

Houston, we do indeed have a problem.

According to the website collectSPACE.com, the bag came to be at the auction after it was “forfeited along with other artifacts found in the home of Max Ary, a former curator convicted in 2006 of stealing and selling space artifacts that belonged to the Cosmosphere space museum in Hutchinson, Kansas.” Ary spent two years in prison and was fined $132,000.

The story on collectSPACE also notes that the bag’s history “was only discovered after Carlson sent the artifact to NASA to be tested for the presence of moon dust.” NASA checked it out and concluded that there was lunar evidence present. The space agency seized the item and gave the Department of Justice a call. In the now-resolved court case, the government maintained that due to a mix-up, the lunar sample bag was not properly identified as coming from the historic Apollo 11 flight.

Had it been marked correctly, the lunar sample bag wouldn’t have ended up on an auction block. However, in his ruling this week, Judge J. Thomas Marten said Carlson was “a good faith purchaser, in a sale conducted according to law.” Basically, she bought what was made available to her at a legally conducted auction.

KMBC News notes that Carlson knew the bag came from a moon flight — she just didn’t know it came from the one that first put men on the moon. She now has the title to the bag but must file a motion in the U.S. District Court for Texas to get it back from the NASA Johnson Space Center in Houston.

Editors' Recommendations

Brinke Guthrie
Brinke’s favorite toys include his Samsung Galaxy Tab S, Toshiba Chromebook 2, Motorola Moto G4, and two Kindles. A…
NASA’s restored Mission Control lets you relive the historic 1969 moon landing
nasas restored mission control lets you relive the 1969 moon landing

Historic Mission Control

When Neil Armstrong became the first human in history to set foot on the moon in July 1969, team members back at Mission Control allowed themselves a brief pat on the back in a tense operation that still had to bring the astronauts safely back home.

Read more
Remember the summer of 1969? NASA wants to hear memories of the moon landing
apollo lunar samples study psd astronaut harrison schmitt 1

Share Your Apollo Story with NASA

Do you remember the Apollo mission? Or do you have family members or friends with memories of the Apollo era? Then you can contribute your stories to a new NASA project.

Read more
This AI cloned my voice using just three minutes of audio
acapela group voice cloning ad

There's a scene in Mission Impossible 3 that you might recall. In it, our hero Ethan Hunt (Tom Cruise) tackles the movie's villain, holds him at gunpoint, and forces him to read a bizarre series of sentences aloud.

"The pleasure of Busby's company is what I most enjoy," he reluctantly reads. "He put a tack on Miss Yancy's chair, and she called him a horrible boy. At the end of the month, he was flinging two kittens across the width of the room ..."

Read more