The iPad’s color and motion capabilities have created a groundswell of interest around the so-called “living magazine.” But is putting print in motion a flash forward, or a flash in the pan?

If ever the print industry needed a knight in shining armor to reverse the world’s growing preference for blogs, online news and YouTube, it’s now. And if any device can don the armor and play the part, it’s Apple’s iPad.

While e-readers like Amazon’s Kindle gave spark to a sputtering print industry by closely replicating the book experience, Apple’s iPad promises to turbocharge it. Wired’s iPad demo depicts words that change before the eye with the virtual press of a button, cars that spin with a swipe, pages that slide across the screen like they’re on roller skates. VIVmag’s cinematic motion magazine feature drops text into a moving, three-dimensional film noir world that zips viewers between blocks of text through windows and walls, as if rooms were pages. A virtual copy of Sports Illustrated lets readers rearrange stories into the order they want, hear the roar of a stadium during a game, and drag players on their fantasy teams around on a whim.

Welcome to the next-generation magazine. But does any of this technology actually make magazines any better? Will animation, embedded video and mini games really save publishers, or we failing to see a gimmick dressed as a savior?

Go here to check out more videos on digital magazines.

Print Comes to Life

Before dismissing the “motion magazine” on hype alone, it’s worth exploring some of the amazing things they actually can pull off – and potentially could in the future.

L.A.-based photographer Alexx Henry has been at the forefront of the motion magazine craze, camera in hand, since the very beginning. The man who both Outdoor magazine’s first motion cover, and VIVMag’s provocative Sex Fears featurette, sees devices like the iPad opening a whole new door for storytelling.

“The iPad is all about potential. It enables a digital magazine to create new content and create motion content, to really break out of the boundaries they’ve been stuck in for so long.”

“The thing that I think is really exciting about the digital magazine experience is that it’s a combination of the curated experience – a journey that someone is going to take you on – and an experience that you can take yourself on,” Henry says. “It’s like somebody’s laying out a series of paths for you to go down. You can start down the path and you can continue down their path, or you can jump around and sort of have your own experience.”

The linear bundle of pages that used to land in your magazine every month has come unbound. You can not only explore stories in any order you want – as you may have already by flipping pages – but focus on what matters to you. Make the pictures you want to see, bigger. Explore a map of a place a writer is describing. Spin a table of statistics into a chart with the press of a button, or watch numbers from an article updated in real time.

“The iPad is all about potential,” Henry says. “It enables a digital magazine to create new content and create motion content, to really break out of the boundaries they’ve been stuck in for so long.”

But didn’t the Web break those boundaries ten years ago?

Sure.

But try bringing a laptop to the beach. While HTML allowed creative types to break the rules of print, and applications like Flash allowed Web developers to push even further with richer, animated content, that was just software, still bound to the rigid restraints of a computer. To dismiss the iPad as a platform for motion magazines because computers can already do it is akin to dismissing the Kindle because computers with monochrome monitors could display readable text 30 years ago. Amazon has already sold over 3 million Kindles. Clearly, the package makes a difference.

Showing 8 comments

  1. pablommmmm at 2:00pm 24th March 2010 VIVmag is giving away a dozen iPads to celebrate its availability on iPad. Check it out here:

    http://idek.net/1Cir
  2. Phil at 7:21pm 23rd March 2010 The VivMag animation looks annoying. I don't think I'd be able to sit through one every time I read a magazine, considering that I skip DVD intro titles and avoid YouTube videos more than a few minutes. There's just so much more information waiting to be consumed online, it seems such a waste of time to look at a carpet turn to grass. I'm sure a lot of you feel the same way.
  3. Greg Mombert at 12:39pm 22nd March 2010 I wasn't too excited about iPad type devices before, but after seeing these digital magazine demos I now see the appeal of owning one of these tablet/eReader devices. Reading on the web is not always a pleasure with the limited formatting options so it's nice to see that we won't be losing magazine style layouts with the transition to digital versions.
  4. Ian Bell at 10:45am 22nd March 2010 Thanks for sharing. Can you answer my question below? What type of model will these ads use?

    Also, another thing no one has brought up is the addition of incremental readers. With a magazine you have extra readers who read the magazine because its given to them, left in Dr. offices etc. But that will likely not work if it's tablet based, so an extra value is missing from the equation. How will this affect readership numbers etc? Will it be used as leverage for advertisers to say "hey, you do not have as many readers, so I am not paying as much"? Ad costs will go up because of the creative, but will ad rates go up as well to compensate?
  5. lucy b at 10:00am 22nd March 2010 VIVmag demo looks pretty incredible. Also saw that they're giving away 12 ipads http://idek.net/1Cir
  6. Ian Bell at 9:51am 22nd March 2010 Advertising models have not really been discussed much when it comes to digital magazines. Will the models be CPM based like on the web, or more subscription based like in traditional print? My guess is the latter since people will need to subscribe to the magazine.

    BUT, what if blogs and other cheaper media outlets decide to offer their content on digital tablets for free, then I could see advertising changing to a CPM based model.

    So what is traditional media doing to prevent new media from ruining their holy grail?
  7. bbtfactory at 7:00am 22nd March 2010 Take a look at the work being done for the advertising opportunities in this new category http://bit.ly/d5fL9s
  8. mlongo at 6:29am 22nd March 2010 There are, generally, 3 very distinct ways of doing digital magazines being considered right now. While Viv Magazine's first go at it is incredible and really impressive, it would seem to require a large increase in the production cost of the magazines which I'm not so sure would be a good idea at a time when consumers expect digital goods to be less expensive than their real world counterparts.

    I believe there might be a better solution for the industry in a middle ground. I've recently written a post with a quick discussion of the 3 general patterns I see emerging for the future of digital magazines:
    http://ipadwatcher.com/2010/03/19/3-visions-on-...

    I don't really think it is a matter of one way of doing it being better than the other. I think it comes down to what will provide a good experience to the readers, while being financially viable for the publisher.
Close Suggestion Apple Begins Accepting iPad Apps in Preparation for Launch
View Article