Skip to main content

First lawsuit against PlayStation filed as users report credit card fraud

sony-psn-playstation-networkIt was bound to happen: Sony is being sued for the security breach of its PSN network and subsequent loss of user data, including credit card information. California-based Rothken Law Firm has filed suit on behalf of Alabama PSN subscriber Kristopher Johns as well as all other users hit by the fallout. The firm specializes in class action, civil litigation, and high technology law.

“This action is brought on behalf of plaintiff individually, as representative of the common or general interest and as class representatives for all other similarly situated nationwide against Sony to redress the defendant’s breach of warranty, negligent data security, violations of consumers’ rights of privacy, failure to protect those rights, and failure and on-going refusal to timely inform consumers of unauthorized third party access to their credit card account and other nonpublic and private financial information,” the lawsuit states. It also addresses users’ inability to access the network they were paying for and seeks undisclosed monetary damages, but does specify that the paintiff(s) expect some sort of redress for “defective” PlayStation consoles and PSN and Qriocity services, as well as all legal fees and credit report monitoring covered.

While the lawsuit accuses Sony of generally lax security measures, it largely takes issue with the company’s inability to keep users in the loop. It argues that Sony was well aware of the hack’s consequences but failed to inform subscribers, which did not allow them “to make an informed decision as to whether to change credit card number, close exposed accounts, check their credit reports, or take other mitigating actions.”

Sony’s PSN and Qriocity services were first hit by the outage April 17, and Sony admitted later that week that it was due to “external forces.” Only yesterday, April 26, did it admit user data has been stolen, including credit card information. PlayStation users are feeling the effects: Ars Technica reports that various readers have fallen victim to credit card theft because of the massive security breach, which some are saying is of unforeseen proportions.

It is undeniably clear that Sony is at fault here and that millions of subscribers deserve at least some sort of compensation, but analyst Michael Pachter says it could be hard to prove. Speaking with IndustryGamers, Pachter says “It’s really hard to show damages. How much does it cost you to have your identity stolen? Especially if you can’t prove that it was used for any purpose whatsoever? Pain and suffering? Not appropriate for a class action [lawsuit], so the amount of the settlement would be very small, if anything at all.”

Editors' Recommendations

Molly McHugh
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Before coming to Digital Trends, Molly worked as a freelance writer, occasional photographer, and general technical lackey…
Sony forms PlayStation Mobile Division alongside Savage Game Studios acquisition
Savage game studios splash screen.

Sony is expanding into mobile gaming by acquiring mobile developer Savage Game Studios. As part of the move, Sony announced that it has established the PlayStation Mobile Division.

Sony has been slowly dipping its toes outside its normal comfort zone of console exclusives in recent years, primarily by porting its first-party titles to PC. The success of these titles has been such that the company even acquired a dedicated PC port studio, Nixxes Software, to push this initiative. While there have been a select few Sony games on mobile, such as the oft-forgotten Uncharted: Fortune Hunter, the company has otherwise been absent on the platform.

Read more
References to a PlayStation PC launcher discovered in Marvel’s Spider-Man
Spider-Man punches a man in Spider-Man Remastered.

Sony may be stepping up its commitment to PC gaming. Eagle-eyed fans have discovered references to a PlayStation PC launcher in the recently ported Marvel's Spider-Man Remastered.

Video Game Chronicle reported on Tuesday that it discovered references to a PlayStation PC launcher within the game's files. This could hint toward Sony planning to create its own PC launcher for its games. VGC also discovered and verified other files with names such as "PSNAccountLinked" and "PSNLinkingEntitlements." While Marvel's Spider-Man Remastered and other PC ports like God of War can't be linked to PSN, the files found in the former game may suggest that players could be able to link their PC and PSN accounts in the future.

Read more
How to cancel PlayStation Plus
A person holds up a PS5 controller.

Sony's PlayStation Plus subscription service has evolved over the years, initially beginning as a way to get new games each month, then giving access to online multiplayer. Now, the service has built upon both of those features, functioning like Xbox Game Pass Ultimate and offering a lengthy catalog of games for a monthly fee. It still gives you new games each month and enables online play just as before, but now, the PS Now pillar has been folded into PS Plus to make things more streamlined.
But what if you no longer want to be a member?

Read more