Skip to main content

Guardians of the Middle-earth preview: One ring, but infinite choices

As early as Wednesday, players will get the chance to return to Middle-earth in Monolith’s digitally distributed multiplayer online battle arena (MOBA) game, Guardians of Middle-earth. So what does that all mean? We had the chance to sit down with producer Bob Roberts and senior producer Ruth Tomandl from Monolith, and discussed what to expect from our next outing in the land of the hobbits.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

The first thing to know is that the game is built around the fighting mechanic rather than the story, which may irk some Tolkien purists but opens up it up to a lot of interesting possibilities. Sure, realistically Gollum probably wouldn’t be able to slow down a mace-wielding Sauron for longer than it would take to pick the remains of the creature from the Dark Lord’s gore-covered weapon, but the game gives you that option, and does so in a way that is consistent within its own logic, if not the logic of the source material.

The game is also built on the back of the films, both old and upcoming, as well as the original novels of The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings, but not the larger Tolkien world. It’s a shame that legal disputes and property rights have pushed the additional Silmarillion material outside the realm of the adaptations in all mediums, but it does breed a consistency to the concept art and style that ties all the offerings together with the most recognizable form of the property at the moment. It also doesn’t hurt that the game is heading to homes less than two weeks before the release of The Hobbit threatens to reignite the craze that went along with the previous Peter Jackson trilogy, and it features characters from the upcoming first film of the new Hobbit trilogy.

But while t Monolith vetted their material through Peter Jackson’s Wingnut Films, the team was left to their own devices and given the freedom to expand the game in the direction it felt best served its goals.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

“It’s totally just a Middle-earth game, really. We’ve been working with part of the lore that we pulled from the appendix of the books and from all kids of different places,” Roberts said. “So while the visual style and feel is very consistent with Peter Jackson’s The Hobbit film vision, it’s really more broadly a Middle-earth game. There’s definitely going to be characters in here that you’re not going to see in films that we have worked on independently, although there are some you’ll definitely see in the film too,”

Tomandl went on to suggest that roughly one-third of the characters in the game will be taken from the films, one-third will be taken directly from the books, and the remaining third will be a mix of obscure characters and imagination from Monolith, fleshed out specifically for this game. All of these original characters can be found buried deep within the source material, but they may be built around someone that was little more than a fleeting mention from another character in the book, giving Monolith room to create while still holding true to the series.

Unlike many other games of the same style, Guardians was created specifically for a console experience and not PC. The idea behind this was simply that the development decided to focus on the controls using a traditional console controller in order to give that platform the best possible experience. There are currently no plans to bring the game to PC. Besides, the PC market has plenty of MOBA titles, while the console market has only a few by comparison.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

In the game you take control of one character, or guardian, out of 22 options each split between an “evil” and “good” orientation, and each with their own style and method. Sauron, for example, is more of a tank character, slow and powerful, but not very maneuverable, while Legolas will be a faster, ranged character, with more maneuverability but less defense.

When you first begin, you will only have access to a small number of these 22 guardians, and more will unlocked via the in game’s currency that you earn and use. Unlike many other games in the genre, however, Guardians will not feature micro-transactions, nor are there any plans to ask for cash in order to unlock aspects of the game.

Regardless of your alignment between good or evil, your character is defined by one of five classes: Defender, Enchanter, Striker, Tactician, and Warrior. The game features 5-on-5 competitions, and the best way to succeed is to balance out your team with a combination of classes and styles.

The class you choose will be defined by stats, allowing you to select a player that best suits what you want to do, and they all fall into molds familiar to any longtime gamer. The enchanter (a magician class) has low health and high damage, the warrior is balanced, the striker is a tank, and so forth.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

The guardians each have a basic attack mapped to the right trigger/shoulder button, as well as four unique, upgradeable abilities mapped to the face buttons. Guardians also have four commands that can range from healing to lightning strikes, mapped to the left trigger/shoulder. All characters also carry with them up to seven gems and/or relics, stat augmentation items that unlock as you play.

There isn’t anything that should be too foreign to the average gamer, but the amount of customization means that every online game should be the same. You won’t be able to fundamentally alter one class to make them more like another, but within each class the options are significant, and experimenting with four other players loaded out in their own way should create a new experience every game.

And that level of variety will change constantly, as the game is designed to be played online with a full complement of human teammates and opponents. There is an option to play the game as a single player populated with AI teammates and opponents, but that isn’t what it was designed for. The method of distribution slightly changed the development process for the better as well. Since the game is being released as a digital download only, it ensure that those who purchase the it will already have an online connection. Each time you connect, you will download data that helps to pair you with real life players who are balanced by your rankings, hopefully ensuring a better game every time.

“The biggest thing it [developing for digital distribution] did for me was create a sense of relief that everyone will be connected and download our patches and balance data every time they log on,” Roberts said. “So they’ll have the most up to date version, so that’s kind of a relief.”

Guardians of Middle-earth will be released on Wednesday, December 4. Check out our full review later this week for all the details.

Editors' Recommendations

Ryan Fleming
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Ryan Fleming is the Gaming and Cinema Editor for Digital Trends. He joined the DT staff in 2009 after spending time covering…
The most common PSVR 2 problems and how to fix them
A PSVR2 headset on a sky-blue background.

The hype around PSVR 2 has largely died off just a year after its launch, though there's no denying it’s a cool piece of tech. Making big strides from the original PSVR, the latest headset from Sony offers better graphics, improved tracking capabilities, and introduced the world to the sleek new Sense controllers, which make it easier than ever to interact with your virtual world.

But, like all new pieces of tech, PSVR 2 isn't without its issues. From faulty Sense controllers to blurry images, here's a look at the most common PSVR 2 issues and how to fix them. Many of these steps will also work with PSVR, though note the menu navigation might be slightly different.
Your Sense controller isn't working properly

Read more
Weekend deal: Save $350 on this Alienware gaming PC with RTX 4070
Alienware Aurora R16 sitting on a desk.

The Alienware brand is Dell’s dive into the gaming world, and Dell is coming up big today when it comes to gaming PC deals. The super popular Alienware Aurora R16 gaming desktop with some serious specs is currently discounted at Dell. It’s marked down from $2,050 to $1,700 and amounts to $350 in savings. This is one of the better Alienware deals you’ll find today and we don’t know how long it will last, so click over to Dell to claim the savings while yo can.

Why you should buy the Alienware Aurora R16 gaming desktop
There are a lot of great options when trying to ensure you’re getting one of the best gaming PCs, and with Alienware you know you’ll be getting something you can take seriously. The Alienware Aurora R16 is a gaming desktop that offers ultimate expansion and customization options, and it’s where a lot of gamers turn when they’re looking to take on the best PC games. As built for this deal the Aurora R16 has 32GB of RAM and an Intel i9 processor with 24 cores. This is a lot of power even by gaming standards, and the powerful NVIDIA GeForce RTX 4070 graphics card with 12GB of its own RAM is part of the package as well.

Read more
TopSpin 2K25 serves up a fun, but safe tennis simulation revival
Serena Williams plays Tennis in TopSpin 2K25.

The first video game console I ever owned was an original Xbox that came bundled with two games: NCAA Football 2005 and Top Spin. My appreciation for both Madden and tennis games can be traced back to those being two of my first-ever console gaming experiences.

That’s why I was very excited to hear that Mafia 3 developer Hanger 13 and publisher 2K were bringing the Top Spin tennis series back with TopSpin 2K25 after a 13-year dormancy. Unfortunately, I'm disappointed with how underwhelming the overall product is. Even though it’s the series’ grand return after over a decade, it feels like an extremely iterative sequel to Top Spin 4. It’s certainly approachable, thanks to great tutorials and new meter systems to help players learn proper timing, but TopSpin 2K25's light content offering doesn't make for the strongest opening serve.
Top Spin returns
Developer Hanger 13 hasn’t been coy about the fact that it used 2011's Top Spin 4 as the base to build TopSpin 2K25. Top Spin 4 is a fantastic tennis game that people still play to this day, as it perfected the series’ timing-based gameplay. This isn’t like Mario Tennis Aces, where a special ability can shoot you across the court and hit timing doesn’t matter. TopSpin 2K25 is a true simulation, so learning proper positioning on the court, when to release a button to swing your racket, and how to aim your shot properly are all critical to success.

Read more