A newly published Microsoft patent shows the Redmond, Washington-based computing giant may soon have the ability to monitor Xbox users through their Kinect hands-free controller. The system would allow content providers, like movie studios or record companies, new ways to monetize their goods. Only problem: The technology sounds like something straight out of 1984.
Microsoft’s patent, entitled “Content Distribution Regulation by Viewing User,” was first filed in April of 2011, and was published by the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) on November 1 of this year. The patent describes a “content presentation system and method allowing content providers to regulate the presentation of content on a per-user-view basis.”
So what, exactly, does that mean? Well, according to the patent, that means content providers will be able to offer content licenses to customers based not only on time (i.e. “this rental lasts 24 hours”) but also on the number of people watching a movie, for example, or listening to a song or album. Microsoft’s system would then use the Kinect’s camera to actually see how many people are in the room. If it’s more than the amount allowed by the purchased license, the entertainment will stop, and the system (probably Xbox Live) will demand that the customer upgrade to a new license that allows for more viewers.
Or, in the words of the patent itself: “The users consuming the content on a display device are monitored so that if the number of user-views licensed is exceeded, remedial action may be taken.” Furthermore, Microsoft’s technology may enable individuals to be “specifically identified and the amount of their consumption of the content tracked relative to their specific use.”
A note on copyright law: Right now, U.S. copyright law contains a provision known as “Public Performance” that gives copyright holders the right to when their protected intellectual property is performed or shown in public. So, what does “public” mean in this case? The law says “public” is a “place open to the public or at a place where a substantial number of persons outside of a normal circle of a family and its social acquaintances are gathered.”
The tendency might be to assume that Microsoft’s patent is there to give copyright holders a better way to police public performances of their movies and music – and that certainly seems like a no-brainer application of the technology. But that is not really what Microsoft is proposing here – this is some other beast entirely.
What Microsoft’s enabling with this patent is the exact opposite of public performance monitoring. Indeed, it seeks to monitor what are obviously private performances, which are not prohibited by copyright law. Not only that, but it greatly strengthens copyright holders’ power over users by allowing them to block their legally obtained content if, say, someone else walks in the room.
The benefits for Microsoft and content providers goes far beyond protecting copyright; it allows them to establish entirely new pricing for content. Only one person watching this movie? That’ll be $2. There’s 10 of you? Well, you’re going to have to cough up $15. And you’d better hope nobody shows up late to the party.
For consumers who are already disgusted with the disintegration of ownership in the 21st century, technology like that which Microsoft describes in this patent is clearly a giant leap in the wrong direction. We can only hope this is one of those ideas that dies in the prototype phase, and doesn’t become an industry norm.
And to think, these are the same companies that want to dissuade people from pirating their content. Here’s a hint: This won’t help.

Anybody that thinks this is cool or okay or like a few have mentioned, they just want to see if you’re playing the game in the nude, you’re idiots. Yeah, I know they have been spying on us using our cell phones and other devices and methods for a long time, but it doesn’t make it okay. You’re a fool if you think it’s okay for them to do that.
Listen, most people have forgotten or never learned the truth about who the boss is supposed to be. It is ‘We the People’ that are supposed to be the boss of the government. We are supposed to be in control. And this is the plan, to misinform the younger generation about the true history of our country and teach them to be ‘SHEEPLE’ that they can control, no questions asked. It must be working considering some of the comments on this post.
Nope, it is for this reason that I will not ever own any of these products that brag on themselves about having this kind of technology. Like the OnStar system on most GM vehicles, it can be used to track you and eventually be used to let law enforcement know when you might be speeding and send you a ticket in the mail if you were. That is on the way and this why I prefer owning older vehicles, no OnStar.
Some companies will start paying if they haven’t already, to use the OnStar service to spy on you to see where you drive to shop among other things so they can find ways to better market their products to you. Do you think I’m crazy? Do the research, it is coming to a home, vehicle or store near you.
One more bit of information. Microchips have been tested in clothing. They are probably still testing them if not using them outright right now. The stores that supposedly use them want to tract where you live and where you go so they can find better ways to market to you. This is not a si-fi fantasy either. It is a reality, google it.
This is just a little food for thought for the ones that want to be informed.
If that’s the case, consider my Kinect sold.
considering kinect can barely recognise two people properly I wouldn’t be getting too worried just yet
I just bought the Kinect and this is what I find out? Not cool.
Illuminati ..
Odd.. My original post vanished.
“So, to combat this problem, all you have to do is point your kinect at your life sized photo of bill gates doing the lambada, and you’ll be fine”
DO. NOT. WANT.
Read your user agreement and you won’t get surprised….. SMH
When you agree to that 1000 pages of legalize, you have waved your right to not be monitored.
I think it was on page 437, section 67, paragraph 5.
M icrosoft K inect Ultra
Just another reason you should have bought a ps3…..
Playstation Eye can do the same thing.
Or smoking weed, or touching yourself, or something you don’t want anyone else to see… microsoft shouldn’t do that
Put a towel over it- Keeps the dust off and the govt out.
Bye byr Kinect sales
I warned folks of this from the beginning. And Kinect is not the only way, all TVs (i.e., Samsung) with motion activated controls operate on cameras in the cloud. Buying your slavery is cheap.
If you are weird and proud of it then you should and like StayWeird Please and thank you(:
I don’t care I’m still gonna party
BIG BROTHER IS WATCHING YOU.
They just want to see if your playing games naked… LOL
It’s cool, they were already doing it
lol invasion of privacy to its greatest extent. I hope this is true so I can sue and take some of that bill gates money.
Nothing is illegal unless ur a citizen. Corporations and govt can legally spy on you, even kill u, no reason, warrant or repercussions.
I like this but if it starts to watch me I will not be happy I dont want people spying on me . And Amanda I do the same thing .
Kinect isnt worth it then, selling on cl today
Henry, that video is from the onion.
F
Kiss your left hand…say your crushes name…close your hand… Say a week day…say your name…open your hand… If you post this on 15 comments then your crush will say that they like you and ask you out on the weekday you chose
Fuck tht shit big money corporations. Smh killuminati.
I’ve heard ppl can do this with laptop/comp cameras, I keep mine covered at all times
Is that even possible/legal?
Wtf ever that’s illegal.
So, you put a towel over it when you’re not using it. It’s a Kinect, not a Dalek.
Bullshit
*fapfapfap in living room*
wait they’re dooing wut now?
No one else say anything about the constitution, they have been violating that for decades now…
#creeperstatus!!
So I can’t murder people in my living room anymore ?
I got something for them to watch!
lol yeah sure…
I can see this becoming industry standard. There’s a flow of money.
lmao if you not doing shit wrong then why worry also unplug the power source when not using it
Fapfap no more on the couch
Time to get rid of kinect
that god i dont have a 360
that cant be legal
i dont pay for xbox live i never have it connected to the internet so suck my balls microsoft
they can do that with phones and computers. Flame.32 virus
You know the Goverment has been doing that with your Tv and listing to you on your phone and email as well face book check this link out, but one thing you can be assure of now you are not alone !
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3sThcwmx3rs&sns=fb
If they spied on me, they would get a scary site..
First the iPhone and other “smartphones” with an in unremovable battery are a listening device even when turned off. Now Big Brother wants to watch you!?
I never play them, they are boring. If they want to watch me in my home, they’re welcome to. I hope they enjoy my lame piano playing and my sometimes offensive language. Also, I talk to my cats.
i dont believe it…… technology being used to fuck us? goddamn it….. i wish i enjoyed being fucked, id go back to prison
games consoles are crap , who needs em,
oh all the fapping.
I see a market for kinect-covers….
say what???? Sounds like a Balmer idea to me.
Oh, or put a post it note on the lens, lol.
Big brother wants to see us fap
Guess I’ll have to stop the new masterbation techniques while eating Cheetos and watching Cortana in Halo.
4th amendment. Hasn’t anyone heard of it?
;@!!!! NOT COOL
only if my XBOX is on… other than that it feels as though its an invasion of privacy!!
and I’m constantly flipping microsoft the bird, so what, I had a little fun with my gamer score and it got reset, whoop dee doo lol
Tape the camera or unplugg when you are not using it. MS must give usrs the option or a warningg that they are doing this. Violation of of right to privacy.
thats messed up
Bad idea. It can actually detect human lovemaking …
well i don’t own a Kinect but i do have laptop, iPad etc…. My life is not that interesting they must get very bored
1984… Orwell is here now and living large.
man heggs naw…truth is, they’ve been using sonar via wall outles for years to spy on us…nothing new big bro been watching
Post it note or turn it to the wall.
Just tape the cam…
and I’m constantly flipping microsoft the bird, so what, I had a little fun with my gamer score and it got reset, whoop dee doo lol
Uh, NOT COOL!
actually more like my friend from the UK had fun with my score but oh well
Sheeeeeeit!!
If you, have a Sony or Samsung flat screen t. v.; or a laptop or tablet p.c. with a built in camera… Surprise! You’ve been on “Candid Camera” for TWO YEARS!
I call bullshit.
already got it
That’s not cool and an invasion of privacy. What is your Xbox is in your bedroom?….just saying
http://youtu.be/twx98NhRB84
Make you want to put up a poster of Bin Laden in a cave looking like he is playing xbox. That would be interesting to the person spying on this kinect.
Eewwww!!!
not surprised
completely illegal.
This is truly scary…
doesn’t surprise me a bit… this will never be in my home.. I like my Xbox don’t need a Kinect!
If I had one, I’d totally play naked if this does happens. LOL Totally think it’s fake though.
And this is why I don’t buy Xbox…..2nd Bill Gates doesn’t run Microsoft anymore…3rd RUN!
& here we are worried about a president !
Kinect is ghetto
AAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHH OMG! EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEK! Everybody put your clothes back on!
f xbox
Another reason i’m glad I don’t own a IPAD (or any pad), Xcrap, or a cell or smart phone. And every four hours erase all the cookies and history on the PC. Paranoid, obviously not enough it seems
Hell no! They better not! That’s an invasion of privacy!!
& here we are worried about a president !
Fake, why would bill gates put his company in that situation,
You do realize that bill gates hasn’t run microsoft in.. what, a decade now?
big brother is watching…
Sucks but I face down the kinect after every use so at least I minimize the chances, perhaps.
just unplug it
It will get to the point where we can’t disconnect to watch a movie.
Luckily mine isn’t hooked up so they cant see shit!
Phones already do that with looking to see if you’re still looking at the screen. Best bet is to disconnect each time.
Well just because they have a patent for this doesn’t mean that they will actually use it. But they could. I am guessing that they way they “see” you is the same way the Kinect determines how many people will actually be playing a game – by outlining your silhouette on the screen. I don’t think they will actually be able to see you the same way a video camera could.
Well this is no surprise… Microsoft has a long history of monitoring and tracking it’s users… Why not with Kinect?
This is asinine for so many reasons. Certainly not encouraging me to replace that last dead X-box.
How well would this thing be able to distinguish people? If I have a poster or cardboard cut out in the room, will that count as another person? What about my suit of Stormtrooper armor? What about at Halloween when everyone is wearing costumes, sometimes of very elaborate nature?
Finally, what if I put a box or something infront of the Kinect so it can’t see me?