Microsoft Sued Over Scratched Xbox Discs

The "red ring of death" may not be the only problem with the Xbox 360. One man alleges the console can actually scratch games discs, rendering them unusable.

Apparently, Microsoft’s extension of the Xbox 360’s warranty has opened all sorts of doors to further scrutinize the console. One man who claims the Xbox 360 scratched his game discs is chasing Microsoft for $5 million, and calling for a class-action lawsuit against the company.

Jorge Brouwer filed his suit in a Florida federal court on Monday, alleging that the consoles are “negligently designed and manufactured,” according to the International Herald Tribune. Brouwer claims that his Gears of War and Madden NFL 07 discs were both scratched by the unit, but Microsoft still wanted $20 apiece to replace them.

Microsoft denied that the Xbox 360 could scratch discs. “Out of the millions of Xbox consoles in use, Microsoft has not received any widespread reports of Xbox 360s scratching discs,” said Jack Evans, Microsoft spokesperson, in a statement.

The best support for Brouwer’s case may come from a Dutch TV show that supposedly documented the damage a 360 can do to discs. Brouwer’s lawyer, Jeffrey Ostrow, found the reference on Wikipedia.

[via International Herald Tribune]

Showing 2 comments

  1. Jody at 9:15pm 19th July 2007 Or...don't be a retard and stop moving your 360 when the power is on you F-knob, sheesh ppl are stupid. Like I'd pick up and move my pc while its running a DVD either. IDIOTS....sorry, I hate stupid ppl
  2. jeff at 11:33am 12th July 2007 I see a few problems here. First, if you hire a lawyer and he decides you have a case based on something he saw on Wikipedia, you might want to reconsider your council. 2nd, Just like the guy that sued the dry cleaners for 60 million...and the judge threw it out because it was ridicilous, I think the same could happen here. So 2 of your disks are jacked up and your out $100.00? Ok, that's worth 5 million. NOT.
Close Suggestion Sony Unveils Redesigned PSP
View Article