Microsoft sues Motorola…again

By Geoff Duncan November 10, 2010

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Microsoft has filed a new lawsuit against Motorola, claiming the technology giant is charging Microsoft “excessive and discriminatory” fees to license technology Microsoft uses to implement both 802.11 Wi-Fi networking and H.264 video compression technology. Microsoft says the fees violate Motorola’s legal commitments to organizations that manage these technology standards.

The suit alleges that Motorola is seeking license fees based on the retail prices of Microsoft products using the technologies—that would include Windows 7, Windows Phone 7, and Xbox 360 game consoles—rather than license fees based on the prices of the individual component hardware and software related to implementing the specific features related to Motorola technology. Microsoft argues that both Wi-Fi and H.264 video encoding are secondary features of its products, rather than primary features, and therefore Motorola’s licensing fee demands are unreasonable.

Microsoft also notes that as a member of both the International Telecommunications Union (ITU) and the IEEE, Motorola is obligated to provide “reasonable and non-discriminatory” licensing for its patents that are included in the Wi-Fi and H.264 standards. Microsoft is asking the court to force Motorola to offer licenses on what Microsoft considers reasonable terms, as well as award it damages to make up for losses incurred from what it sees as overcharging.

Motorola has not commented on the suit, saying only that the companies have not been able to reach an agreement on licensing terms.

The suit was filed in a federal court in Seattle, and is the second Microsoft has filed against Motorola in recent weeks. Last month, Microsoft sued Motorola, claiming its Android smartphones infringe on nine Microsoft patents.

Editors' Recommendations

Topics

Former Digital Trends Contributor

Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…

Gaming

Your Xbox Live Gold subscription will turn into Xbox Game Pass Core this September

Microsoft finally made the decision to move on from its monthly online-access subscription service Xbox Live Gold. On September 14, Xbox Live Gold will transform into Xbox Game Pass Core, with current Gold subscribers automatically gaining a Game Pass Core subscription.

An Xbox Live subscription tied to online play has existed in some form since Xbox Live launched in 2002, but Xbox Live Gold as we now know it truly came into form in July 2013 when Microsoft started the Games with Gold program that gave subscribers free games each month in addition to that online access. Although Microsoft rolled back some online restrictions in 2021, Games with Gold continues to this day. That will all end when Game Pass Core launches.

Gaming

Microsoft beat the FTC. Here’s what the controversial court ruling means for Xbox

You’ve probably heard that the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) lost its case against Microsoft after an exciting and revelatory trial. On Tuesday, Judge Jacqueline Scott Corley denied FTC's motion for a preliminary injunction to block Microsoft’s acquisition of Activision Blizzard before its potential completion by July 18. Ultimately, Corley did not believe that Microsoft owning Call of Duty would “substantially lessen competition” in the game industry. It was major win for Microsoft after months of regulatory hoops and roadblocks, but the FTC quickly moved to appeal the decision. This all raises an important question: What’s next?

Over the next week, Microsoft, Activision Blizzard, and the FTC will determine the fate of the gaming companies involved in this acquisition and set a precedent for the future of the game industry. On top of that, Microsoft still has to deal with the next moves made by the U.K.'s Competition and Markets Authority (CMA), which wants to block the acquisition due to its impact on cloud gaming. Following the release of Judge Corley’s Preliminary Injunction Opinion, I spoke to two analysts and a lawyer with knowledge of the video game industry to better understand what lies ahead for Microsoft and Activision, the FTC, and the CMA. The battle isn't quite over yet, even if the end is finally on the horizon.
What’s next for Microsoft and Activision Blizzard
Currently, Microsoft and Activision are in a solid position, as a Judge has ruled that Microsoft is unlikely to pull Call of Duty from PlayStation or lessen competition in the game console, cloud gaming, or game subscription markets by acquiring Activision Blizzard. There’s a temporary restraining order in place until July 14, which the FTC hopes to successfully appeal during. As soon as that order is up, though, Microsoft and Activision Blizzard have until July 18 to complete the acquisition.

Gaming

Microsoft wins FTC case, removing Xbox’s biggest Activision Blizzard acquisition hurdle

Characters shooting in Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2.

Following a multi-week court case, Microsoft has won its battle with the Federal Trade Commission regarding its proposed Activision Blizzard acquisition. The ruling is a major win for Microsoft's troubled deal, clearing the biggest hurdle it faced.

Last January, Microsoft announced its intention to acquire Activision Blizzard for $69 billion. The blockbuster announcement immediately raised antitrust concerns, which resulted in the FTC filing a legal challenge in December 2022. Microsoft has not been able to proceed with the acquisition since then, as its faced similar scrutiny in the U.K.