Skip to main content

Here’s why TiVo’s founders just crashed and burned with Qplay

heres tivos founders just crashed burned qplay closed
Image used with permission by copyright holder
Innovating in TV is hard. It’s hard because the golden trove of programming that tech companies would really like to share is locked inside the primitive set-top boxes provided by service providers. And it’s hard because negotiating the rights is difficult and prohibitively expensive to virtually everyone but those pay TV companies.

But every once in a while, we see a revolution.

Michael Ramsay and Jim Barton created one with TiVo, a device that challenged the notion that we had to watch TV shows when they aired. And they hoped to do it again with Qplay, a device that challenged the notion that short-form videos had to be consumed one at a time, like snacks instead of meals.

Just six months after launching, Qplay has received its final cue.

Qplay streamed curated queues of short-form Internet video to your TV using a small, simple box controlled by an iPad app. For instance, you could tune into a Q about photography, late-night comedy or science, handpicked by someone else. But just six months after launching, Qplay has received its final cue. The service shut down on Friday, rendering the boxes paperweights. To its credit, the company offered refunds to those who paid the $50 for its device.

So what went wrong? The duo’s earlier venture TiVo has had its ups and downs, but it’s still here, and even continues to slug it out in retail 15 years after its debut. It’s a successful combination of hardware, software and service into something consumers want. Qplay hasn’t revealed much about what caused it to throw in the towel so early, but it’s easy to see where it tumbled in contrast to TiVo.

While TiVo’s hardware did the heavy lifting of amassing hours of programming and neatly filing it away on internal hard drives, the Qplay box was difficult to justify owning. Since the service was essentially controlled from an iPad app (and could be played back on an iPad display), Qplay could have implemented a number of ways to get its service back to the TV without its own box, like Apple’s AirPlay or Google Cast. Indeed, these days, more companies that have had TV playback devices in the past, including Sling Media and Seagate, are launching channels on Roku to close the streaming loop back to the TV.

Then there’s the question of the value of the service itself, which essentially tried to create themed channels (or “Qs” as the service called them) of a couple of hours from shorter videos around the Web, leaning heavily on YouTube. The curation made for an inexpensive way to compete against the Netflixes and Amazon Prime videos, which can shell out tens of millions of dollars to acquire and create movies and TV shows. The Qplay content was interesting. It didn’t measure up to House of Cards, but there was no subscription tied to it, either.

That said, a cadre of companies believe that the future of strung-together short videos looks bright, at least toward the mission of video discovery. 5by, named for an old military term signifying the best-quality signal, was purchased last year by social network StumbleUpon. It uses a Songza-like mood checker to serve up a queue of videos. The experience isn’t as polished as Qplay was, but the company hints it has a new app in the pipeline that will put a much greater emphasis on sharing. Citing the belief that HDMI ports are precious, it uses the Chromecast to send the video experience back to the TV.

That’s a path that Qplay might have pursued if it had the luxury of starting over.

Editors' Recommendations

Ross Rubin
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Ross Rubin is principal analyst at Reticle Research, an advisory firm focusing on consumer technologies, and the founder and…
This JBL waterproof Bluetooth speaker is 43% off right now
JBL Xtreme 2 on a beach.

Bring the party with you wherever you go with a portable Bluetooth speaker like the JBL Xtreme 2, which is currently on sale from Best Buy at 43% off. From its original price of $350, it's down to a more affordable $200 for savings of $150. We're not sure how much time is remaining for you to take advantage of this offer though, so if you're interested, you're going to have to proceed with the transaction as soon as possible. The bargain may be gone by tomorrow, so complete the purchase today if you can.

Why you should buy the JBL Xtreme 2 Bluetooth speaker
JBL is one of the best speaker brands with portable audio as its calling card, so it's not a surprise that there are multiple JBL devices in our roundup of the best Bluetooth speakers. The JBL Xtreme 2 isn't the latest version in its line -- the JBL Xtreme 4 has already been released -- but it's still a fantastic Bluetooth speaker by today's standards with powerful audio using your mobile device as the source. If you prefer a wired connection over Bluetooth, the JBL Xtreme 2 also offers auxiliary audio input.

Read more
Apple’s AirPods Pro earbuds are back at their cheapest-ever price
Apple AirPods Pro 2 inside their charging case, near iPhone 14.

The second-generation Apple AirPods Pro with USB-C are back down to their cheapest-ever price of $189 on Amazon, for savings of $60 on their sticker price of $249. If you don't own the wireless earbuds yet, or if you're thinking about upgrading from an older model, here's another chance at this discount. However, like with most AirPods deals, we don't think it will last long, so if you want to take advantage of the bargain, you're going to have to proceed with the purchase right away.

Why you should buy the Apple AirPods Pro 2 with USB-C
The Apple AirPods Pro 2 with USB-C are featured in our list of the best wireless earbuds as the top choice for Apple fans, partly because of how easy it is to pair them with an iPhone or iPad. Just open their charging case, hold it close to your device, and you're done after a few taps. The Apple AirPods Pro 2 also offer solid audio quality with the capability for wireless lossless audio and Apple's immersive Spatial Audio, so you'll enjoy your favorite music even more.

Read more
Sony WH-1000XM5 headphones are back at their Black Friday price
Sony WH-1000XM5 headphones seen in silver.

Here's a highly recommended offer from Crutchfield if you're on the lookout for headphone deals -- the Sony WH-1000XM5 for $328, which is what they were going for during last year's Black Friday. If you weren't able to buy them for this cheap for any reason, here's another chance at the $70 discount on their original price of $398. We're not sure how long stocks will last though, so if you want to buy these wireless headphones for a more affordable price, you're going to have to add them to your cart and check out as soon as possible.

Why you should buy the Sony WH-1000XM5 wireless headphones
There are multiple reasons why the Sony WH-1000XM5 reign supreme in our roundup of the best headphones, but it all begins with its impressive active noise cancellation that allows them to stand out among other wireless headphones. They're very comfortable to wear, so you'll be able to maximize their long battery life of up to 30 hours on a single charge with ANC activated and up to 40 hours without it, and they'll allow you to call up Amazon's Alexa or Google Assistant through voice commands.

Read more