An anonymous source “at a fund that buys stock from Facebook employees” told BusinessInsider that China wants to buy a considerable amount of Facebook. How much exactly? Enough “to matter.” Other rumors say that two independent wealth funds are trying to buy $1.2 billion worth of Facebook stock, and one of them also happens to be from China.
There’s been plenty of back and forth about whether or not this matters, what China’s motivations for the proposed investment are, and what the consequences for Facebook users could be. But it has become obvious that Facebook is at the very least interested in what to do with China. Mark Zuckerberg famously posed the question about whether you could connect the world without including its largest country, and there have been rumors about his company meeting with executives from Baidu, China’s largest search engine.
Given Facebook’s reach and magnitude and China’s tightly-wound censorship policies, there’s bound to be some discourse about a potential partnership. Here are some of the concerns the rumors are inspiring, as well as the reality of the speculated investment.
The concerns
Since Google’s well-documented struggles with China and the more recent alleged Gmail hacks, there has been some suspicion attached to the country and its Internet game, to say the least. Couple this with the apparent tension regarding the Facebook Revolutions and how they have even minimally affected the country, and you can guess how tightly controlled social media is there.
This has prompted some concern over the idea China that could own a considerable piece of Facebook. Given the Chinese governments’ concern about how influential social media can be, it could use this ownership to try and control its citizens. Would this affect US users? It seems unlikely. Earlier this year, we heard about the possibility of a Chinese version of Facebook, which would look and act like Facebook as we know it, but would be censored by the Chinese authorities. A warning would notify outside users that connecting with Facebook China users means their information and interactions also fall under the country’s censorship policy.
The reality
Are these concerns warranted? Not entirely. Hearing “Chinese censorship” attached to the idea of something so integrated to our digital lives as Facebook mostly just sounds scary. Thanks to the Gmail hacking-bit, there’s a sensitive trigger that goes off. But there are a few reasons it might not need to. First of all, since Facebook is still a private company, investors can only buy non-voting stock so affecting the site’s infrastructure would be tricky.
If you want to get extremely anxious about it, you could reason that Facebook is so desperate for China’s hoard of potential users that it would strike some compromise where it would collaborate with the country’s restrictions, possibly even allow it to check on any dissident information coming from outside China – but we’re pretty sure that sort of talk is being circulated by conspiracy theorists alone. Non-voting shareholders don’t have access to Facebook’s user database, and China would have to invest far more than it is rumored to if it wanted significant influence over Facebook once it files IPO.
The real problem for Facebook in all this wouldn’t be losing control, it would be avoiding a storm of negative publicity. Allowing China to invest and possibly creating a censored version of the site would undoubtedly cause privacy advocates to cry foul, and it could find itself in a situation reminiscent to Google’s own struggles with the country.
Why doesn’t Facebook just buy China?
GOOGLE+
I am not excited to offer anything to a country that censors its citizens outright and limits free speech in any way. If facebook does sell to china I will discontinue my account with over a 1000 contacts and find another media outlet. I am exploring Google + now.
They’re just trying to get back the billions they’ve loaned to us. Besides what better way to collect data on people throughout the world than by owning a slice of faceook. Or maybe just another, expensive, slap in the face towards google????
Gees, we’re already working for them! Haven’t you seen that chinese commercial???
It’s cool. I’m switching to Google+ any way.
Facebook MADE IN AMERICA… Let’t keep it that way
It looks like ti may be getting outsourced just like everything else.
I’d be more worried about Apple buying a piece of Facebook… then again, I’m not sure who censors more – Steve Jobs or China?
Apple would love to control your whole entire life from birth to grave. That’s what Jobs wanted.
Next story. China buying piece of the America. And and the one after that. China owns america.
Like the corner store and that house we’ve always wanted to buy I’m sure it was all CASH
It seems to me that we should be more concerned by the fact that foreign corporations (like, say, ones from China) can operate political action committees, ones that can help sway voter opinion during elections, without having to divulge their involvement. Since the Supreme Court case that decided this staggering allowance, "Citizens United," took place after the last election, we don't yet know what impact — if any — this will have on the American political process. But I can't see how that could be good.
In terms of Facebok, there is little stopping Chinese investors — people who are likely out to make money, not to discretely suppress political uprisings or tirades about a crappy episode of "Glee" — from buying at least some stock in Facebook. It's even possible that this is a precursor to Facebook's rumored entry into China, in one form or another.
The Obama administration is known to nurture the technological needs of people looking to free themselves of certain overbearing national leaders. So if this purchase is accurate and becomes stalled, there is likely far more at play than a good investment. This becomes a geopolitical event with stakes at the highest levels.
Why doesn’t Facebook just buy China?
so now they are trying to own 35 percent of american stocks and bonds . google and facebook…….something seems fishy