Skip to main content

Egyptian court bans YouTube over anti-Islam film

youtubeThe fallout of last year’s controversial video “The Innocence of Muslims” continues; Egypt has banned YouTube as a result of the ongoing outrage the anti-Islam film has provoked.

The ban, which is temporary and expected to last 30 days, was ordered by Judge Hassouna Tawfiq after a lawsuit claimed the video posed a threat to Egyptian national security. In his decision, Tawfiq said that YouTube had “insisted on broadcasting the film insulting Islam and the Prophet, [in the process] disrespecting the beliefs of millions of Egyptians and disregarding the anger of all Muslims.”

The court’s decision requires Egypt’s National Telecommunications Regulatory Authority to shut down access to the site for a thirty day period, although neither the NTRA nor Google believe an official order has been sent to that effect yet. The ruling is open to appeal, and some believe that it may not even be enforced depending on circumstance.

The ruling has been hailed as a step back in censorship within the country, with many pointing to a 2007 decision by an Egyptian court to block 49 separate human rights websites that were vetoed by an administrative court. Amr Gharbeia, civil liberties director for the Egyptian Institute for Personal Rights told the Guardian that the new ruling “is certainly a backwards step compared to what the court ruled [in 2007],” going on to suggest that public reaction to the ban may mean that many Egyptians “lose respect for the the rule of law.”

Gharbeia hasn’t lost faith in the system, however. He suggests that the ruling may not necessarily be representative of the Egyptian legal system as a whole, but instead invokes the traditionally-American idea of the “activist Judge”: “It’s very possible that the judge is acting on his own will and conviction and really wants to protect the people of Egypt from something [he considers] evil,” he said. In that case, the possibility of another court either reversing or vetoing the decision altogether remains quite possible.

If the court were to order the NTRA to enforce the law, it remains unclear how successful the ban would end up being. Not only is thirty days a relatively short ban in the grand scheme of things, but there are a variety of workarounds to such a block on a particular website (Consider, in a similar situation, that 63.5 million users from China joined Facebook in 2012, despite the country’s ban on the site since 2009). Those who want to access YouTube during the enforced break will be able to do so, and those who aren’t quite so determined just have to wait a month for its return. Viewed in that light, does the ruling have any purpose beyond sabre-rattling?

Editors' Recommendations

Topics
Graeme McMillan
Former Digital Trends Contributor
A transplant from the west coast of Scotland to the west coast of America, Graeme is a freelance writer with a taste for pop…
These are the 10 most disliked videos on YouTube
YouTube Photo

When it comes to YouTube and the rankings of its most popular videos, you’ll most likely think of it in terms of how many views or likes a given video receives. But just because a YouTube video happens to have a ton of views or millions of likes, that doesn’t necessarily mean it’s protected from receiving dislikes. In fact, some of the most popular and well-known viral videos on YouTube also carry staggering numbers of dislikes as well.

If you’ve ever been curious to know which videos have received the most dislikes, here’s your chance to find out. Here are the current 10 most disliked videos on YouTube.
10. Can this video get 1 million dislikes? -- PewDiePie (5.14 million dislikes)
Can this video get 1 million dislikes?

Read more
How to upload a video to YouTube
Woman sitting on the floor working at her laptop.

As one of the most popular video streaming platforms online, if you want to have your vlog, comedy sketch, or music video seen by someone, getting it on YouTube is a must. Those new to the streaming scene may be wondering how to upload a video to YouTube. Here's how in just four easy steps.

Note: For this guide, we will assume that you've already made your YouTube/Google account. While those starting from scratch will need to do so, there are many elements involved in setup and customization that aren't covered by this guide.
Step 1: Sign in to your account

Read more
The funniest YouTube videos of all time

Humor is very personal, but some things are just universally funny. We're sure that you have your favorite YouTube videos for turning a frown upside down, but these are ours. Some of them are insanely popular, while others have dropped beneath the radar, but all of them are sure to bring on the giggles.

Note: While all of the below videos are found on YouTube and meet YouTube's accepted standards for content, some of them do contain adult language, and so they may not be considered safe for work.
Buzz and the dandelions
Buzz and the Dandelions

Read more