The iPad finally has some competition. After dominating the tablet market since its inception, the iPad’s one-year anniversary will bring major competition, including RIM’s BlackBerry PlayBook, Motorola’s Xoom, and Dell’s Streak 7. We lined them all up to see whether any of them will ultimately manage to topple the reigning champ.
That said, the iPad actually has a bit of an artificial disadvantage in this comparison, because it’s old and up for replacement soon, while the others are brand new. It will largely be the iPad 2 that will be competing with the other tablets on the list, so I’ll try to add what I think will be in the iPad 2 as we go through the comparison to provide more balance. I’ve had the Dell Streak 7 for several days, and have an iPad in house, but have not used the Playbook or Xoom so will be working off of known stats entirely for these devices.
We’re going to look at screen size, network performance, processor performance, whether they can be tethered, DLNA support, operating system, number of apps, Flash support, cameras and quality, sensors, max storage, portability and battery life. This is in no particular order.
Screen size
The Streak 7 and Playbook both have 7-inch screens, bringing them more in line with the original Kindle form factor. Due to weight, this is better for books and for women who want to be able to put one in a purse. For men, you could put it in a coat pocket, but it clearly wouldn’t be as portable as the Streak 5, and Dell has a line that will include a 10-inch product later in the year. Dell’s advantage over the other players, at least initially, will be one of choice, and they maintain a consistent user experience across the line. Ideally, you might buy several and pick the one that most fit what you wanted to do, but at initial prices, I doubt there will be many who can afford to try this.
Seven-inch and smaller screens are better for use that is closer to a radio, video player or e-reader. Ten-inch screens are better for Web surfing, note taking, light productivity, and viewing digital pictures. You’re more likely to carry a 7-inch tablet as a supplement to a laptop, and a 10-inch tablet on its own. It depends what you want to do, kind of like comparing a sports car and an SUV.
Network performance
These things live off the Web, and the faster the better. All but the iPad are 4G devices, but I’m expecting the iPad 2 to close this gap by adding 4G. Initially the Streak 7, Xoom, and Playbook will have an advantage here, but they will likely lose it before the year is half over.
Processor performance
The only product that doesn’t have a new dual-core processor is the iPad, and both the Xoom and the Streak 7 have Tegra 2 chips, which deliver strong graphics. Multiple cores provide better multi-tasking performance. Historically, the primary benefit of that is the ability to use anti-malware products (the Streak 7 ships with one) without bringing down system performance critically. This last point is becoming more important as hackers focus more and more on these emerging platforms.
How does the Samsung Galaxy Tap compare to these four tablets. I just purchased a Galaxy, but don't like the 2 year contract agreement from Sprint.
The Samsung Galaxy Tab is actually a pretty solid tab. I have one and like it quite a bit although I may be stepping up to a Xoom in the next few months. Anwyays, you can check out some nice side by side comparisons on the Galaxy as well as others on http://www.tabletpccomparison.com . Hope this helps..
Update: the playbook is rumoured to have a compass now, according to a guy from sprint who was at ces. Also, playbook might get android support, which would make the playbook a considerably more attractive option.
Cuppla things. Under "tethering" in this article, the iPhone is referred to as being currently on Sprint. A correction ought to follow soon. Secondly, regarding iPad's fixed storage, this year's Macworld showed external storage units of up to 1TB now on the market. Not sure if these are compatible with the other devices. Three, at the Daily launch, in NYC, News Corps.' Rupert Murdoch almost casually threw in his company's research that the iPad would have overwhelming tablet market share for 2011 and 2012. Suggesting it will take that long for iPad 2 competitors to get their act together. He's putting his money where his mouth is.
Looks like they fixed the Sprint and tethering issue. Dumb mistake…
Well you mention Wireless networks but you fail to mention the ability to buy WiFi only products, I for one only have interest in WiFi only, I can download what I want at home, work, and various hot spots, if I'm buying one for my kids, I'm only going to buy the wifi models. Between home, work, and my Boingo account my iPod touch pretty much does everything I'd want a tablet to do, minus the small screen.
I would tend to agree. I would not pay extra for a cellphone service plan just for a tablet. Wi-Fi works for me.
Did you even read his rationale for it? He's saying a tablet that would fit in a purse would be more practical for women, which, hell, sounds pretty reasonable to me. I could understand you getting bent out of shape if he said women couldn't handle a larger tablet or something, but he's making a practical and objective observation.
Hey Rob,
Why are you comparing a one-year old 2010 iPad to 2011 competitors that =have not even come out for sale to the public yet???
Not exactly a level comparison (understatement).
Shouldn't you be comparing these as yet unreleased iPad competitors to the iPad 2 which will be available for sale at about the same time?
Either use the rumored specs for the iPad 2, or compare the 2010 version iPad to other one year old iPad competitors… oh wait, there aren't any other than the Samsung tablet (which isn't even a year old yet).
It is expected that the iPad 2, with full specifications, will be introduced this month. You apparently couldn't wait a couple of weeks to do a fair comparison so that you could rush out this totally unbalanced comparison before the iPad 2 is announced.
I thought it was helpful. I have a current gen iPad and its good to know how it compares to the upcoming tablets. Makes me wonder if I should upgrade or not – and he answered that.
He addressed your first concern in the second paragraph, and did exactly what you said about mixing in rumored iPad 2 specs (see the section about cameras, for instance). Open your eyes before you bitch.
Yes, well all know that some of the rumored specs for iPad 2 are mentioned. But that's not the point!
The question asked was why compare the soon to be defunct first version iPad at all with competitors that are not yet available, and will only be out at about the same time as iPad 2 (regardless of tossing in some rumors about what the next generation iPad might have)?
We can be fairly certain that the iPad 2 (or whatever it will be called when it goes on sale) will be announced this month. So why rush out and do this inequitable comparison just before the new version is introduced?
It's just a matter of days before the introduction of iPad 2 (scuttlebutt is that it will be as soon as next week http://www.geek.com/articles/gadgets/is-iPad-2-th…. So why the urgency to do this comparison with the original iPad right now?
If you were shopping for a tech gadget for yourself, would you think it would be a good idea to compare one company's year old product with another company's as-yet unreleased product?… especially if you knew that the first company would have a newer and more advanced version out for sale at about the same time as the other company's unreleased product?
Not very likely.
The Dell Streak is currently available. Plus analysts (Like Rob Enderle) have the Playbook and Xoom already, so he is writing from hands-on experience.
It's a known fact that almost every other tech company in the world will "pre-announce" their products up to a year in advance of releasing an actual product.
Look at HP and many other tech companies who showed early prototypes and mockups of tablets more than a year ago at CES in January 2010, before the first iPad was officially shown. Most of these prototypes and mockup have not been released as real purchasable products, and many have even been cancelled all together.
Also, these other tech companies will often provide early prototypes to tech reviewers months before the actual product goes on sale, such as the Playbook and Xoom models you mentioned.
But Apple doesn't do any of these early promotional things. And they have made it clear why they don't do it.
Apple does not "preview" incomplete prototypes and concepts. They don't promote vaporware, and they don't allow non-final versions of products to be reviewed.
You may not like this fact, but many people (myself included) prefer to see and learn about real ready-for-purchase products rather than pipe dreams and early versions.
For Apple their "secrecy" about new products is their protection against other companies stealing ideas that they spent time and money on innovating.
In 2007 Apple surprised everyone with the iPhone. Now, just about every smartphone in the world looks and acts like an iPhone-clone. Throw a bunch of smartphones on a table with the iPhone, and standing back it would be difficult to choose Apple's product. Even most of the UI elements, and multi-touch have been copied by others.
Last year after the iPad was introduced, other manufacturers who displayed tablet concepts at CES 2010 went back to the drawing board and have since made their product look and act like the iPad (how many Windows tablets do you see being sold successfully today? ;-)
So when you refer to the Playbook and Xoom that Rob Enderle has touched, it does not negate the fact that the actual marketable versions of these products will go on sale to the public at about the same time that the iPad 2 is available for purchase.
And when Apple does announce the iPad 2 it will not be an early version, but a real final-version of a saleable product.
Which is why Rob speculated on the iPad 2 and ranked the iPad #3-4 overall.
I'm a little lost on your post… the Xoom and Streak are due this Month.. February…. iPad2 is due out in July… that's 5months from now…
We know the specs of all of these models…iPad2 I just pure Speculation on Specs…
If the Tablets, with Known release dates, Known Specs, known pictures and videos of them working, what's the problem with comparing hem o the current iPad since they are in the same class…