Skip to main content

Apple loses more ground in patent case against Samsung, as key patent is invalidated

apple patent invalid samsung case shutterstock 218533267
Hadrian / Shutterstock.com
Apple’s patent case against Samsung suffered yet another blow in August, as the United States Patent and Trademark Office declared that one of the company’s patents is invalid. The decision will likely further decrease the amount Samsung will pay Apple in damages, after an appeals court reduced the amount from $1 billion in May.

The patent in question, D618677, covers the surface design of the iPhone 3G. Apple patented the design in November 2008, but argued that D618677 relied on some of its previous patents and that protection for it should be backdated to January 5, 2007, according to the Verge. Extending protection of the patent to early 2007 gave Apple more time to go after competitors with similar designs, but the Patent and Trademark Office decided that protection should only extend to the November 2008 filing date.

The decision means that competitors like Samsung, who released phone designs similar to the iPhone between January of 2007 and November of 2008 are off the hook for violating that particular patent.

Other tech companies have weighed in with favorable statements on Samsung’s behalf. In a legal brief filed last month, Google, Facebook, and other tech companies argued that, “If allowed to stand,” the court’s decision “will lead to absurd results and have a devastating impact on companies who spend billions of dollars annually on research and development for complex technologies and their components.”

Even though Apple’s iPhone 3G design patent has been thrown out of the case, Samsung will probably still have to pay a sizable amount for other patent infringements against Apple. In May, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit found that Samsung had violated a number of Apple design patents that covered touch commands like tap-to-zoom and bounce-back scrolling. The appeals court reversed a lower court’s decision that Samsung had infringed an Apple patent for “trade dress” — the outer appearance and feel of the phone.

An upcoming third trial will determine the amount that Samsung will be forced to pay Apple, but the invalidation of D618677 is likely to decrease the amount even more.

Editors' Recommendations

Kate Conger
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Kate is a freelance writer who covers digital security. She has also written about police misconduct, nail polish, DARPA…
The top 7 bestselling phones of 2023 were all … you guessed it
Close-up view of titanium frame on iPhone 15 Pro Max.

Seven of the top 10 bestselling handsets in 2023 were iPhones, according to data from research firm Counterpoint.

This marks the first time in Counterpoint’s tracking of such data that Apple’s handset has dominated the chart to this extent.

Read more
Apple Sports app looks to rule live scores and stats on iOS
The Apple Sports app on an iPhone.

As if what it's done with MLS Season Pass wasn't proof enough that Apple is serious about sports, today we have another example. Enter Apple Sports, a new app for iPhone that aims to be the only app you'll need for live sports scores, real-time stats, and more.

Apple Sports is available today in the U.S., Canada, and the U.K. Inside it you'll find the likes of MLS, NBA, college basketball, Premier League, Bundesliga, LaLiga, Liga MX, Ligue 1, and Serie A — and that's just for starters. We're still in the offseason for sports like Major League Baseball, the NFL and college football, and the National Women's Soccer League and WNBA, but you'll see them all in Apple Sports once games begin.

Read more
Why I ditched my iPhone 15 Pro for the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra
Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra and iPhone 15 Pro in hand.

This is not another “lifelong iPhone user tries Android” story. I use and review all kinds of phones, and I prefer the flexibility of Android. That said, I’ve been on the iPhone 15 Pro since its launch — for two reasons. First, I had been getting the iPhone 14 Pro Max-level battery life on it. Second, I like the stability of social media apps like Instagram and X (formerly Twitter). But the experience has been downgrading for a while now.

Samsung's "AI phone," the Galaxy S24 Ultra, tackles these two issues and gives me some extra features that I didn’t think would be important for me. It’s been a surprisingly fun experience. Here’s why I shifted to the Galaxy S24 Ultra from the iPhone 15 Pro and decided to stay on it. And no, it has nothing to do with AI.
Updates have ruined the iPhone 15 Pro

Read more