Skip to main content

Even if you don’t buy an Apple Watch, it’s shaping the smartwatch you will buy

apple watch redefine the smartwatch space effect on
Image used with permission by copyright holder
We’ve seen this scenario played out several times already: Apple does its own unique Apple-y spin on an existing product space, the naysayers loudly point out that the company didn’t actually “invent”anything original and then everyone kind of forgets that anything existed before it.

Of course, the company faces stiffer competition now than it did out of the gate with the iPhone and iPad. Much of the competition has grown savvier in the intervening years. Companies like Motorola, Samsung, and Sony have proven that they’re capable of competing with Apple on Apple’s own terms: making products that are both beautiful and easy to use. They’ve also got a head start in terms of availability (though as we’ve seen in the past, that doesn’t always make a hell of a lot of difference).

Until now, most companies have been throwing things against the wall, hoping for a winner.

Most importantly, they’ve got a unified front in the form of Google. The Android ecosystem may have had a relatively slow ramp-up time, but as pretty much any recent survey of the mobile landscape will tell you, Android’s currently got the lead (though mileage varies by outlet, naturally) in the market share department. Android Wear is shaping up to be a semi-unified assault on the wearables space, with intriguing offers from a number of the top smartphone manufacturers.

What is lacking is a clear, concise vision of the ideal smartwatch. The space has been around in some form or other for decades, but so far has failed to capture the public’s imagination. Smartwatches were seen as little more than overpriced novelties for early adopters with money to burn.

Related: 6 wearable gadgets that were ahead of their time

Until now, most companies have been throwing things against the wall, hoping for a winner. We’ve seen tiny fitness bands and giant smartwatches, E-Ink displays, built-in cellular data, and oddly-placed cameras. Sony seems to come out with a new smartwatch every few months or so and Samsung is taking the same approach that it regularly employs on the smartphone and tablet fronts: creating what appears to be specifically tailored models for every man, woman, and child in the free world.

Pebble Smartwatch Pebblis
Despite its early success, the Pebble smartwatch has hardly become mainstream. Image used with permission by copyright holder

The closest we’ve seen to a real breakout in the smartwatch space is Pebble —and that company’s successes are hardly mainstream. Sure, the plucky little hardware startup shattered pretty much every Kickstarter record on the books, but it still has a long way to go before it can claim millions in sales and enter the big leagues.

When Apple arrived on the smartwatch scene, it brought one of Pebble’s strongest features, albeit on a global scale: a clear and concise idea of what a smartwatch should look like and what it should do. These are both questions that no other company has been able to present a convincing answer.

Related: How IFA reshaped the landscape for wearable tech

To Apple’s credit, the company has clearly deliberated on the watch issue for some time, and it wasn’t ready for the big unveil until it had convincing answers – and even then, the Apple Watch won’t come out until early 2015. With that deliberation, Apple lost both the opportunity to present the first version and, perhaps to the chagrin of less patient investors, an entire holiday shopping season to sell it.

The Apple Watch doesn’t present the single clear killer app answer, but it does present a killer feature set.

But overnight, the Apple Watch announcement shifted the conversation from “would anyone wear that” to “which color finish should I get?” Prior to the announcement on Sept. 9th, the strongest commitment I’d heard from non-techies was along the lines of “I guess I’d wear the Pebble Steel.” It’s a gadget category facelift the likes of which we haven’t seen since the iPhone disrupted the world of BlackBerrys and Palm Pilots.

And while the argument can surely be made that looks are overrated in a number of gadget categories, it’s hard to deny that such shallow concerns are all the more central when it comes to an object that is as much a fashion accessory as it is a productivity tool. Unlike that smartphone, you can’t just shove your smartwatch back in your pocket when you’re done with it.

Until now, the base features of a smartwatch haven’t been defined, a side effect of both the lack of a clear frontrunner and the general inability for companies to answer the ever important “why do I need this?” question. The Apple Watch doesn’t present the single clear killer app answer, but it does present a killer feature set, including robust fitness tracking, mobile payments and a suite of well-designed productivity apps.

Like it or not, it’s the feature set by which the competition —present and future —will be judged. Again, overnight the conversation has changed from “Samsung’s smartwatch” to “Samsung’s Apple Watch competitor.”

This isn’t necessarily all bad news for the competition. While Apple has unquestionably released the smartwatch to beat, it’s also singlehandedly legitimized the space for plenty of casual consumers. What last week was a strange and geeky pursuit on the fringes of the tech world for many had suddenly become a serious consideration.

That consideration doesn’t necessarily result in the purchase of an Apple Watch. Many consumers suddenly interested in wearable computers may find that a Samsung or Sony device ultimately better suits their needs, due to Android compatibility, a specific feature set or just the fact that those companies actually have products you can go out and buy right this moment.

And that, ultimately, is the power of Apple: the ability to have a large-scale impact on a space, even before it’s managed to bring a product to market.

Editors' Recommendations

Brian Heater
Brian Heater has worked at number of tech pubs, including Engadget, PCMag and Laptop. His writing has appeared in Spin…
The best smartwatches in 2024: our 13 favorites
The Apple Watch Series 8 and Galaxy Watch 5.

Smartwatches put important notifications from our phones on our wrists, track our health and fitness, and some can even stream music and make calls. The world's best-known technology brands make them, but a smartwatch is also a fashion statement, and some of the biggest names in watchmaking are on board, giving you a massive amount of choice when it comes time to buy one. Which one is the best?

For most people, we think the Apple Watch Series 9 is the best smartwatch, but only if you own an iPhone. We know there are just as many Android phone fans out there, and since the Apple Watch only works with an iPhone, you'll want the Samsung Galaxy Watch 6.

Read more
Don’t buy a Galaxy S24 Ultra or iPhone 15 Pro Max. Do this instead
Samsung Galaxy S23 FE Mint Green color along with a Samsung notebook and a cermaic bowl with lemons.

“Do I need all that?” That’s the question on the mind of shoppers before they splurge a now-standard $1,000 asking price for a top-tier phone in 2024. Ideally, that dilemma should be there. The likes of Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra and Apple’s iPhone 15 Pro Max have won laurels for a handful of standout features they offer. But you might not need those standout features at all.

I’ve been on that road, and more frequently than I have the temerity to admit. For some reason, regret comes as part of the $1,200 flagship parcel. That's unless your phone is a part of your creative or work process, or you just don’t care and only want the latest and greatest for the vanity of it. A segment like that certainly exists, but that affluent user base doesn’t dictate the journey of a product.

Read more
Samsung Galaxy S24 vs. iPhone 15: don’t buy the wrong one
Renders of the Galaxy S24 and iPhone 15 next to each other.

The Samsung Galaxy S24 is the newest flagship phone on the market, joining its stablemates, the Galaxy S24 Plus and Galaxy S24 Ultra in Samsung's latest range. While not obvious from the outside, the Galaxy S24 has had some hefty upgrades — including a new, more powerful processor, an improved and larger display, and Samsung's all-new Galaxy AI. With prices starting at $800, the Samsung Galaxy S24 is a strong choice if you're looking for a great flagship smartphone that doesn't cost four figures.

But it's not alone in this space. Apple's iPhone 15 also starts from $800 and has a strong processor, a great camera, battery life, and the polished iOS 17. Both devices have a lot to love, and you may be unsure which of these two suits you better.  That's why we've compared the Samsung Galaxy S24 and Apple iPhone 15, pitting the two head to head, explaining the differences, and letting you know which is better.
Samsung Galaxy S24 vs. iPhone 15: specs

Read more