Skip to main content

Federal court demands Samsung give Apple access to upcoming products

apple v samsungLast month Apple filed a lawsuit accusing Samsung of copying its iPhone and iPad design, most specifically with its Galaxy lineup. Samsung responded with a countersuit, claiming it was Apple and its iPhone and iPad that infringed on various patents, and that the company must stop doing so as well as compensate Samsung.

Samsung lost, and now it appears that it will be required to pony up to Apple for future products. A court document filed May 18 reveals that federal judge Lucy Koh has given the company 30 days to hand over the Galaxy S II, Galaxy Tab 8.9, Galaxy Tab 10.1 (all three of which are unreleased), Infuse 4G, and DROID Charge to Apple so that the Cupertino giant can decide if it wants an early injunction. Koh also said that since Samsung has begun advertising these products, it cannot argue that giving Apple access to them is unacceptable. She also quoted a Samsung executive who earlier this year said, “We will have to improve the parts [of the Galaxy Tab 10.1] that are inadequate. Apple made it [the iPad 2] very thin” as a reason that Apple may be justified in believing its competitor is imitating its own devices.

Koh did attempt to stay neutral however. “Although the Court expresses no opinion on the merits of Apple’s claims, the Court notes that Apple has produced images of Samsung products and other evidence that provide a reasonable basis for Apple’s belief that Samsung’s new products are designed to mimic Apple’s products.

The court document says that this access will give Apple time to “take early action to stop the allegedly infringing activity before Samsung’s new products become established in the marketplace.” It also says the court agrees that Apple deserves “limited expedited discovery” – something Apple had not requested, but authorities granted.

It isn’t only the devices themselves that Samsung is being accused of copycatting: The packaging is also being called into question and called “directly relevant to Apple’s trademark, trade dress, and design claims” which can create “consumer confusion.” But the court doesn’t want to appear one-sided, and goes on to acknowledge these actions will seriously aid Apple, and that it understands Samsung’s concerns about “the sensitive nature of the information sought.” Because of this, the court will not require a Samsung executive to testify, despite Apple’s request. It also will not ask Samsung to produce “documents relating to any copying of design elements, or attempts to design around Apple’s intellectual property relating to, the iPhone 4, iPad, and iPad 2,” calling this request “broad and somewhat vague” on Apple’s part.

While it’s keeping any concrete, insider company information out of Apple’s hands, granting the company access to arguably its most able competitor’s forthcoming devices is a huge coup for Apple. Suppose that Apple is unable to find any evidence that Samsung has been using its’ innovations as a blueprint – which is a big, big “suppose.” Given the accusations and evidence Apple has produced thus far, we’re certain it will. But if not, the company is being given even the slightest of slight edges over Samsung by getting the first look at its newest technology, although Apple’s legal team will be denied access to the devices.

It’s an interesting complication for the two companies, who have a business relationship: Apple could potentially spend $7.8 billion on components from the manufacturer.

Editors' Recommendations

Molly McHugh
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Before coming to Digital Trends, Molly worked as a freelance writer, occasional photographer, and general technical lackey…
Camera shootout: Can Huawei’s P40 Pro Plus beat Apple, Samsung, and Google?
huawei p40 pro plus vs apple iphone 11 samsung galaxy s20 ultra google pixel 4 camera shootout

The Huawei P40 Pro Plus is the most technically advanced camera phone Huawei has produced yet, and has an even more capable zoom lens system than the P40 Pro, which aced a recent test against the Samsung Galaxy S20 Ultra. Now that the P40 Pro Plus is on the scene, we have given it an even harder test.

Here, it takes on the current best camera phone you can buy, the Apple iPhone 11 Pro, along with its nemesis the Samsung Galaxy S20 Ultra, and the always superb Google Pixel 4. This is as tough as camera phone tests get. Here’s how the newcomer performs against the stiffest competition we could find.
The cameras
Before we get to the photos, here are the camera specs for each contender.

Read more
Best Buy discounts iPad 10.2 and Samsung Galaxy Tab S5e for Father’s Day
amazon sale savings on apple watch laptops tvs more ipad 10 2 inch hero

Not sure what to give dear ol' dad on Father’s Day? How about a tablet? A tablet's screen is bigger than a phone's so he'll enjoy watching his favorite sports matches, movies, and shows a lot more. The best ones are also equipped with incredibly powerful processors so he can use it as his primary work device. Two of the best tablets right now are on sale at Best Buy for up to $80 off. Order the Apple iPad 10.2 and Samsung Galaxy Tab S5e today and you can be sure they will arrive before the big day.

iPad 10.2
— $250, was $330

Read more
5 tablet deals you can’t afford to miss this Memorial Day
iPad Pro 2020 Screen.

Get your hands on a shiny new tablet and score discounts with this year’s huge Memorial Day sales. Best Buy and Amazon currently have the prices of the highly-rated Apple iPad 10.2 and new iPad Pro, Samsung Galaxy Tab S6 and Tab A, and Microsoft Surface Pro 7 slashed for up to a whopping $230 off. Whether you need a tablet for work, reading, or multimedia consumption, look no further.

Samsung Galaxy Tab A 10.1
– $200, was $230

Read more