Skip to main content

Popular Android anti-virus app found to be a scam, gets booted from Play Store (update)

google kicks out scam app play store virus shield
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Updated on 4-22-14 by Williams Pelegrin: Google is sending out emails to those who downloaded the app, saying that not only will they get refunds, but they will be given an additional $5 Play Store credit. The post below has been edited to reflect this.

Google has removed the highly-rated Virus Shield for Android from its Play Store after it was revealed that the app is a scam. According to Android Police, Virus Shield, which once occupied the top spot in the Play Store’s paid apps charts, is “a complete and total scam.”

“We don’t mean in the slightly skeevy way that some anti-virus and general security software overstates danger and its own necessity. We mean it’s literally a fake security app: the only thing that it does is change from an ‘X’ image to a ‘check image after a single tap.’ That’s all,” Android Police’s report read. As added proof, the website has put the app’s Java code on display via Github

The app, which had a $4 price tag and a 4.7-star rating, was downloaded more than 10,000 times during its two week stint in the Play Store. The app claimed that it “protects you and your personal information from harmful viruses, malware, and spyware.” It also promised to “improve the speed of your phone with one click.” 

Virus Shield’s developer, Deviant Solutions, did not leave much of a trace. However, the developer’s email address, Jesse_Carter@live.com, turned up as a banned account at Sythe.org, a website for exchanging virtual goods such as World of Warcraft gold and Runescape items. The user, “InceptionDeviant,” was banned for scamming people out of game items. 

The scam has highlighted Google’s shortcomings when it comes to the vetting of apps in its online marketplace. Not only was Deviant Solutions able to sell a worthless app, it was also able to cloak itself in anonymity. Google had recently updated its Google Play Developer Program Policy in an effort to protect users. However, the changes mostly addressed shady advertising and affiliate schemes and had no guidelines regarding the effectiveness of apps.

In response to the scam, Google is sending out emails to those affected. Because the app made false claims, thus violation the Play Store policy, Google is issuing refunds to those who purchased the app. In addition to the refund, Google is handing out an additional $5 Play Store credit.

Editors' Recommendations

Christian Brazil Bautista
Christian Brazil Bautista is an experienced journalist who has been writing about technology and music for the past decade…
Google opens up Play Store payments in South Korea in response to legislation
Google Play Store.

Google is finally letting developers in South Korea implement third-party payment solutions in their apps in response to new legislation. Going forward, users will be able to select between Google Play billing and an alternate option of the developer's choice, the company explained.

The move comes after the South Korean Telecommunications Business Act was amended to keep companies from forcing mandatory use of their own in-app purchases systems. The primary reason the in-app purchasing system has been targeted is that developers have had to pay a mandatory 30% fee, cutting into profitability for small businesses. Google's adaptation will still require developers to show the Play Store billing system, but they'll now be able to use potentially cheaper third parties. Google will share further details and guidelines around implementation in the coming weeks.

Read more
Google drops developer fees in the Play Store to as low as 10%
Google Play Store.

Google today announced new moves to make selling on the Play Store more attractive to developers. Currently, the company charges 30% for all subscription sales, then drops it to 15% after a year. Starting in 2022, developers will now be charged 15% on payments from the first day, while Google also moves to reduce fees for apps registered under the Play Media Experience Program to 10%.

"Digital subscriptions have become one of the fastest-growing models for developers, but we know that subscription businesses face specific challenges in customer acquisition and retention. We’ve worked with our partners in dating, fitness, education and other sectors to understand the nuances of their businesses," Google's Sameer Samat, vice president of product management, explained in an announcement. "Our current service fee drops from 30% to 15% after 12 months of a recurring subscription. But we’ve heard that customer churn makes it challenging for subscription businesses to benefit from that reduced rate. So, we’re simplifying things to ensure they can."

Read more
Apple and Google are going to need to open up their app stores in South Korea
The Apple logo is displayed at the Apple Store June 17, 2015 on Fifth Avenue in New York City

Apple and Google will now be mandated to allow for alternate payment systems for apps in the App Store and Play Store, respectively, at least in South Korea. The move comes as part of an amendment to the Telecommunications Business Act that bars companies from forcing third-party developers to use their in-app payment systems for in-app purchases. It will also require app store operators to speedily approve apps and prevent them from deleting apps from the stores without a reasonable explanation, the Wall Street Journal reports.

Apple and Google's app store practices have come under scrutiny over the past few years. In addition to rules around what content may or may not be admitted, developers have increasingly expressed ire about the standardized 30% commission required for each in-app transaction. This comes as a result of both companies mandating the use of their respective billing systems, with exceptions being made to select types of apps (food delivery services, for example.)

Read more