Let’s get one thing straight. The Dell Streak, due to be available from O2 in the U.K. and likely from AT&T in the U.S. sometime soon, is not an Android tablet PC, despite the company’s self-declaration of same, and is not a competitor to the iPad or an iPad killer.
I got my hands on a pre-production Streak prototype, and Dell’s more conventional Aero Android phone, for around a half-hour yesterday.
And now that I’ve held it and played with it, I can tell you the Streak is not a tablet, it’s just a really large cellphone. A nice cellphone, but still a cellphone.
Why isn’t the Streak a tablet? As Supreme Court Justice Potter Stewart once described his legal definition of pornography, I know it when I see it. Streak has a 5-inch 800 x 480 pixel screen, and that’s not large enough to be defined as a “PC,” tablet or otherwise. It walks like an Android cellphone and it talks, literally, like an Android cellphone. Ergo, it’s a cellphone.
Streak Features & Design
The Dell Streak is designed to be held in portrait mode – when you hold the Streak in its OS default landscape view, like a tablet, the now-familiar Android Home, Menu and Back buttons are stacked vertically on the side, unlike a tablet. When held in landscape, the Streak’s volume and on/off switch are on the top left perimeter, requiring an untablet-like reach-around to get to these oft-used controls.
As noted, Dell futzed with Android to produce its own home screen, which has a customizable row of frequently-used apps. The Streak even has cellphone specs. It runs Android 1.6 and, even though Dell designed its own customizable home screen, Android has never run anything other than a cellphone (unlike iPhone OS, which is a derivative of Apple’s desktop Mac OS).
The Streak has a 5 MP camera – a tablet is too clunky to be used as a camera – with dual LED flash. Even though it’s a quarter the size of the iPad, Streak still is a bit large for anyone used to a pocket-sized point-and-shoot digital camera. Its front-facing VGA camera (video chatting “coming soon”), positioned to be used in portrait mode like a cellphone rather than in landscape like a netbook/notebook camera. I could not tell from the press prose or specs if the Streak has a video recorder.
Streak also has only a non-tablet-like 512 MB of user accessible memory (there’s 2 GB dedicated to app storage), relying instead on a cellphone-like DIY microSD slot for store your data.
On a productivity level, there are thus far no Android word processing or presentation creation apps of any note (there are a couple of spreadsheet apps, but are you going to create a spreadsheet on a five-inch screen?), which means the Streak can’t really replace a netbook. But even if the Streak had word processing capabilities, there’s no room on even its 5-inch screen to type with two hands, much less touch type as you can on an iPad (or, at least attempt to touch type). This makes the Streak totally impractical as a prose creation device for anything beyond email and texting, and makes it a cellphone, not a tablet.
Externally, Streak’s display is protected by a sheet of tough Corning Gorilla Glass. At the event, the Dell rep pounded the screen with a pen top, and I mean pounded, producing not a hint of damage. Unfortunately, the rest of the Streak is made of lightweight plastic, so caveat klutzes.
At 3.1 inches wide, the Streak will fit, barely, in a shirt breast pocket, but only in sub-cargo pants pockets, not in side slit or back pockets. But at 6 inches high it could tip out of said pockets and, even at a surprisingly light 7.6 ounces (which, quite frankly, makes Streak feel a bit insubstantial), it’ll sag your blouse.
Phone Functionality
Don’t get me wrong: I actually liked the Streak – as a cellphone. Its 5-inch screen makes a great viewfinder for the 5 MP camera and camcorder, if it has one, and is the perfect compromise size for mobile Web surfing. Its touch scroll is nearly iPhone smooth and offers multi-touch for pinch-and-zooming.
For social networking, Twitter and Facebook are built-in with home screen update bubbles, and of course you get the usual Android email functions.
And, finally, the 5-inch screen creates a wonderfully large phone touch dialpad, although one-handed thumb dialing is difficult.
With 7.2 Mbps 3G connectivity, mobile Web pages loaded in a speedy 3-4 seconds.
The specs did not indicate what processor is powering the Streak, but other sources say it’s the 1 GHz Snapdragon chip cropping up on most new phones and tablets. But I still found the Streak slightly sluggish – but the test model I played with was a pre-production prototype, so benefit of the doubt and all that.
Battery Life
Streak’s got a hefty 1530 mAh battery, which likely accounts for most of its weight, but we’ll have to wait for a more formal review to determine real life battery life.
Sweet, Ian. I’m waiting for the aero so let me know what u think.
A mans hand is much larger than a 12 year old girl's hand. Their phones don't have to be the same size. If you are a 14 year old boy being cool means wearing baggy pants that you hold up with one hand. If you are an adult you want something that works for your tasks. The larger Dell phone may not be cool but it is more web functional than anything else to date and that should appeal to the business world, men and women.
I'm excited with this smartphones. Dell now comes out with its new technology. They're not falling behind. :D
Poor argument bro. Just because something is based on Linux, doesn't mean it's not a standalone OS in it's own right. You gonna argue that Mac OSX is not really Apple's because its based on another kernel?
? Yeah I am not understanding why android is treated like its something 100% new. Android is build on Linux and Linux has run on a lot more different platforms then anything Apple has made. So to say Android has never run on anything but phones would mean that its a 100% new OS and it's not.
Yeah I don't think this will be going into anyone's pocket. It's still way too large.
Did you really try to put it in your back pocket? In the USA normal men's pants pockets are about 4.5 inches wide. The Streak is 3.15 inches wide (80mm.) http://www.detechnews.com/dell-streak-ultra-por…It will easily fit. To me the idea size for a phone is the one with the largest screen that can still fit in a back pocket. It's all about the screen size, every extra square centimeter of screen adds exponentially to the browsing experience and device usability. But it has to fit in a back pocket. I will not carry around a 'tablet' everywhere I go in my hand. Even if I would I would not want to carry two devices (a phone and a tablet). The genius of the Streak is that it is the right size. It's not really genius, I can't believe with all the new smartphones coming out that nobody is making them large enough. In fact a phone with a 6 inch screen should still fit comfortably in my back pocket of my normal pants and that is the size I wish was out there.
Yeah, this device isn't a 'cellphone' or a 'tablet'. It is an inbetween device best described as a MID (a mobile internet device). Designed for those people who don't need or want to carry around a giant 10″ screen but find browsing the internet on a 3″ screen too difficult.Me? I'll be buying one as soon as I can get to an o2 shop in the UK. Hopefully next week!
Check amazon and answer your own question
The heavy kool-aid goggles worn when writing this article makes it a difficult read.
The iPad home button can be on the left or right side when in landscape mode, depending which way you turn it. The iPad would be used more often in portrait mode since it's roughly the dimensions of a piece of paper. Most documents and websites are formatted that way, plus that's the way it connects to the keyboard dock and regular dock. The iPad is running the same OS as the current iPhone, iPhone OS 3, which is derived from Mac OS X, despite what you say. The iPod OS is what iPods used before the iPod touch. It's not just about the hardware either. Smartphone innards are similar to tablets and netbooks but the software and the external hardware interfaces are crafted for a certain market segment. What the article is saying is that the screen size and user interface of the hardware is that of a large smartphone. It's not what people would want in a tablet. Use a real tablet/iPad for a while and you'll see what he means.
Oh wow, I never thought about it that way before.http://www.total-anonymity.tk
Why is it now shipping w/ latest Android 2.2?
The problem is that every other site keeps calling it a tablet.And Archos? Dude, really? Who buys those…..sad.
God. How many times do you have to say you don't think it's a tablet?Pull that rod out. Annoying! … and yes, Archos … and a bunch of non famous tablets are out now and using Android.