
We spent a day on the town with Clear Wireless as our Internet lifeline, to see how it measures up.
We’ve huddled under awnings on the sidewalk in the rain to tap weak Wi-Fi signals, slipped into hotels as “guests,” and paid big bucks from cell carriers for a wireless modem, all to get our mobile Internet fix. And every option seems to suck in its own way. Whether you’re being hounded by an impatient barista and force fed soft jazz, or waiting 20 seconds for every page to load from a 3G modem, neither comes close to matching the silky-smooth connection and freedom you have at home. Why can’t you just get broadband speeds everywhere?
If you believe the marketing of Clear Wireless, you can. So when the WiMax pioneer rolled into Digital Trends’ home town of Portland, Oregon, plastering up ads on benches, knocking on doors and preaching the greatness of WiMax in radio commercials, we had to put it to the test.
Bar graphs, coverage maps and hypothetical maximum download speeds are great, but we decided to run Clear through the ringer the same way most consumers will: By using it around town. After picking up a new USB WiMax modem from Clear, we tossed a trusty ThinkPad in a backpack and hit the streets… with an AT&T 3G card along for a little competition. Here’s what we found out.

Setup
Before we ventured out on a sunny summer afternoon to hit the streets, grab some grub, and get our wireless surf on, we had to get the Clear modem up and running back at Digital Trends HQ. Fortunately, it’s a simple affair. Pop the CD in, install the drivers, click in the modem and hit “Connect” from the software menu. But you read ¬¬correctly, there’s a CD involved. Unlike our AT&T USBConnect Mercury, which acts as a thumb drive storing its own drivers, the Clear modem needed a physical disc. No big deal the first time around – before it’s lost in a drawer somewhere – but for future installs on new PCs and letting friends borrow it, built-in drivers would have been a major plus to make the modem a truly self-sufficient device.
Size-wise, the Motorola WiMax modem looks about like what you would expect from pictures. It’s basically an oversized thumb drive about as long as your ring finger. Clear includes a Belkin flex USB adapter with it, which makes it easier to fit in cluttered USB ports and adjust for signal. As an added plus, it also alleviates fears of snapping the modem off in your USB drive with one misplaced blow, a cringe-worthy event we always pictured with such a long stick hanging out.

By the Numbers
We’ve pledged to keep the stats to a minimum here, but before seeing what the modem can do, it’s worth investigating what the tech can do on paper. Like all “maximum speed” claims, these are all purely hypothetical, and you could rarely or never expect to actually reach them in real life. But they should reflect on more typical scenarios, in proportion.
A typical broadband cable connection, like one from Comcast here in Portland, might claim to offer download speeds of 15 Mbps and uploads up to 3 Mbps. Clear’s WiMax network is capable of 6 Mbps down and 1 Mbps up. The AT&T card, by contrast, can pull 1.7 Mbps down and 1.2 Mbps up.
To put that in perspective, those figures are all in megabits per second, which need to be divided by eights to get the more typical megabytes per second you might be more familiar with. You can also shove the decimal point over three spaces if you want kilobytes per second, which you’re probably used to seeing when you download things.

U.S. Bancorp Tower
Glass and Altitude
Naturally, we began our adventure on Digital Trends’ perch on the 10th floor of the U.S. Bancorp Tower in downtown Portland. Depending how close we got to the window, we pulled a respectable seven to nine out of 10 bars. With this signal, we hit 2.0 Mbps down and 0.6 Mbps up from the Seattle server in SpeakEasy’s Speed Test, which we used as a constant benchmark in this test. That kind of speed was more than enough for everything from casual surfing to streaming 720p video from YouTube. First impression: This thing is fast. Even South Park episodes, which typically tax our connection to the max, streaming fluidly with zero interruption. Though not quite as robust as the 10 Mbps down and 8 Mbps up we got from our landline office connection, the difference between the two was hardly noticeable in most real-life use applications. Unless you’re yanking down movies on BitTorrent, you won’t notice the difference.
But of course, we had to try. And the results blew us away. Though Clear was slow to gather steam on a torrent file, we checked back in about 20 minutes and found it pulling up to 350 kbps on an extremely popular (but legal) file. Downloading high-quality movies from thin air? Believe it. The best we were able to manage with the AT&T modem was about 26 Kbps, and even with full signal, certain stream media formats like South Park’s were unwatchable.
Move away from the window, though, and things change. We started an episode of The Simpsons on a netbook through Hulu, then strolled into the hallway and around the perimeter of the floor with the video still streaming. Adding two walls between us and the outside put a major damper on signal, which dropped as low as zero bars in some spots, also causing the video to sputter when we stayed too long.
At this point, we also noticed that adjusting the antenna could make an enormous difference in signal. In some situations, turning it from vertical to horizontal literally cut the signal in half, from eight bars to four. While it was nice to think we could improve signal with some fiddling when it really got bad, having to think about antenna position also throws a potential kink into ease of use, if you have to do it much.
















Showing 83 comments
RSSI can connect at 5.8mbps down and 0.98mbps up during the day but at night when most people are on it. I usually average between 1-2mbps.
Clear would get a better review if they are able to overcome these situations with peak internet usage congestions.
I'm done with SBC/AT&T as they've dissappointed me one too many times with price hikes/speed decreases/additional speed tiers/high initial installation fees. Comcast is way too expensive if you don't bundle the internet package with something else. Verizon isn't available in my area and the same for RCN. Tethering is being cracked down with data caps, although Sprint 4g or T-Mobile's new HSPA+ 3G sounds good if you didn't have to plug your phone in all the time.
Using the Motorola Series M modem, living on the 3rd (top) floor of my apartment building across the street from Clackamas Town Center Mall, I am getting average 3-4 MBps down, and up to 3 MBps up during non-peak hours (tested on speakeasy.net during a rainstorm), and 1-3 MBps down and up to 3 MBps up during peak times during the same day/rain storm.
This is more than enough to run PS3 and Xbox 360, stream Youtube videos, and surf Facebook without lag!
I was skeptical at first, but now am confident I made the right decision going with the $40/month plan of "unlimited home" which gives me up to 4 MBps download speed.
I also did not buy this modem, I am leasing it. Based on the representative's advice, Adam said that when Clear comes out with a new modem, which they tend to do every year or so, I will be able to swap out my "old" modem for the "brand spanking new one" without charge. Personally I don't really see a disadvantage to purchasing the modem outright, but at least this way if the modem give me problems, I can get a new one easily - but it's your choice on this issue, either way you're saving about $40 if you buy it outright, or "losing" $40 if you lease this specific modem the entire 2 years.
I did notice the Clear documentation say this modem's default password is "Clear123" which it's not, I had to call the 800 number and the woman told me it's "motorola"
Clear's guide says to get the best reception, place the modem in the window, where the Clear logo is the receiver, so make sure not to block that part of the modem. I am getting full 5 bars, Windows Network and Sharing center (I'm on Vista) says my connection is 100 MBps, but "network utilization" is averaging 3.2 MBps.
Even though I lease the modem, the monthly bill is less than Comcast's - I was not able to verify my address with Verizon's FIOS, but oh well, I doubt it's a $45/month service!
So one more thing, this modem does come with an ethernet cord, but I don't know if it's cat5 or what. Maybe switching it with a cat6 cord may help increase my throughput a bit? I don't know.
Oh,and when I've downloaded HD videos, it does tend to slow to about 2 MBps download speed, this was tested during a stormy day into the early morning the next day. Both on iTunes and on Xbox 360 marketplace, HD video tended to take a bit too long to download for my liking, but for $45/mo wireless broadband, it's a minor issue for me.
I'm glad at the least, there is an alternative to Comcast's strangle hold on the Portland metro area, not that I've had very bad service, but rather that we now have a few honest options for broadband service!
Thank you DigitalTrends and your commenters who helped me make this decision, I APPRECIATE IT! :-)
"By checking this box, I acknowledge that I have read and agree to be bound by, the following provisions
By providing this telephone number (whether wired or wireless) as part of our established business relationship, and regardless of whether this number is listed on the federal Do-Not-Call-Registry, you consent to being contacted by Clearwire (and/or its designated agents) at this number, for any purpose (including sales, marketing, and promotional offers) and by any means, including autodialed or prerecorded voice calls and text messages. You specifically acknowledge that you may incur, and will be sole responsibility for, charges relating to these incoming calls or messages."
Read this carefully! It means that you pay whenever Clear decides that they want to call you with advertising.
I know of no reputable company that would ever include a clause that they could harass and CHARGE YOU for doing it.
I'm here in Atanta, just started a $40 month-to-month contract with clear. The modem showed up, plugged it in and have been getting full bars. I've watched streaming movies on netflix with no problem. I can see how online gamers might want faster speeds but it seems good enough for streaming high quality video so I'm happy, delivery was fast. We'll see how it goes from here.
here is my convo with a tech rep for clear.
Hello james. Please wait while we find a CLEAR specialist to help you.
Your question was: contract cancellation fees
All agents are currently busy. Please stand by.
An agent will be with you in a moment. Thank you for your patience.
There are 18 people ahead of you in the line.
The next available Agent will be with you in a moment.
All agents are currently busy. Please stand by.
There are 13 people ahead of you in the line.
An agent will be with you in a moment. Thank you for your patience.
The next available Agent will be with you in a moment.
There are 11 people ahead of you in the line.
All agents are currently busy. Please stand by.
An agent will be with you in a moment. Thank you for your patience.
There are 6 people ahead of you in the line.
The next available Agent will be with you in a moment.
All agents are currently busy. Please stand by.
There are 4 people ahead of you in the line.
An agent will be with you in a moment. Thank you for your patience.
The next available Agent will be with you in a moment.
There are 3 people ahead of you in the line.
All agents are currently busy. Please stand by.
You have been connected to Gary Jones.
Gary Jones: Hi James! I'll be happy to help you today!
james: i am curious about early cancellation fees upon internet service
Gary Jones: I apologize James, I do not have access to information pertaining to early termination fees.
May I ask why you are considering canceling your services?
james: The modem only show 3 lights for connectivity never anymore than that. I have connection blackouts. Ive even walked outside my place to check and it doesn't happen. ive had it since december and just really need to figure something out im paying 52 dollars for slow internet something isnt right lol.
afterwards he asked for my info i logged out. they have screwed me already why give them a warning im going to cancel. log on to their chat and ask question. either they lie to you or thier tech support isnt very familiar with the product.
Very very bad deal
But remember, they do have (and honor) a 7-day refund.
Clear is onto something absolutely brilliant, and while it won't work for everyone, it's worth seeing if it works for you.
Short version - do not get it.
I dont understand why companies cant be transparent and open with customers, why they are looking to trap us into long term contracts and penalize us. Nice revenue stream for them I guess. I am already stuck with a 2 year contract with Dish that I regret so am not going to do the same with Clear.
Has any one had experience with this?
Service is spotty. You'd think that since I live 1 block from the clear store the service in my neighborhood would be great, but it's not. They definitely mis-represent their service areas. In the 3 months I've had it, I've completely lost service 5-6 times, each time for a day or two. When I call they say I should "move to the other side of my apartment" or "try to sit by the window" until they get someone out to reset the tower. It's cheaper than all the other providers so I guess you get what you pay for.
Jon
www.PhiladelphiaClearInternet.com
Thanks for defending me!
As far as the service, I actually got 4 bars when I opened the window (cold here in Dallas). I actually got a dwld speed of 4.23 and an upld of .47; I was amazed. I can now upload pictures to my FB page in a few minutes rather than timing out. No, the service isn't wonderful, but it is good. Hopefully in the future it will get better and you will have the service you want. Don't let it annoy you. Man will always beat the machine.
Clear has, I think, created quite a high quality network for Portland in less than 12 months. I suspect that over time, it will get much better as well. All we have to look forward to from the cellcos is a slow and painful rollout of 4G/LTE in what 3 years...
http://www.acreativedesktop.com/clear-high-spee...
http://clearwiresucks.com/blog/