Almost a year ago, RealNetworks burst forth with a PR campaign promoting RealDVD, a software tool the company touted would enable consumers to make legal backup copies of their DVDs and use them on computers or portable devices without requiring the origianl disc. Of course, as soon as RealDVD hit the strees the MPAA and major movie distributors filed suit against RealNetworks, quickly winning an injunction barring the sale of RealDVD until the legal issues could be worked out. Yesterday, in a 58-page ruling, Judge Marilyn Patel let the temporary injunction on RealDVD sales stand, barring RealNetworks from selling RealDVD until the product’s legal issues are resolved at a full trial.
Tag Archive: RealDVD
RealDVD Injunction Stands For Now
U.S. District Judge Marilyn Patel has ruled that a court injunction barring the sale of RealNetworks‘ RealDVD DVD-copying software will stand for at least another month until she has an opportunity to ramp up on the details of the licensing arrangement, how the software functions, and copyright issues involved in the case.
Judge Patel indicated after the hearing that the case raises serious issues of licensing and the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) and she wasn’t satisfied at first hearing that RealDVD was not in violation. As such, she is letting the current injunction blocking the sale of RealDVD stand, and indicated she is next available for a hearing on November 17.
Judge Halts Sales of RealDVD
Less than a week after it went on sale, a court has issued an order temporarily requiring RealNetworks to suspend distribution of its DVD-copying product RealDVD. The action comes in response to a lawsuit brought against RealNetworks by the MPAA, alleging RealDVD enables users to bypass the Content Scramble System (CSS) used to protect DVDs from unlicensed copying. RealNetworks maintains that making a copy for personal use is permissible under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, and points to Kaleidescape’s successful victory over the MPAA in a case where Kaleidescape hardware enabled users to copy DVDs into a personal library.
MPAA, Real Networks Sue Over Real DVD
RealNetworks‘ RealDVD DVD-copying software is officially on sale, and its debut has been marked by a salvo of lawsuits: RealNetworks has sued the MPAA over “threats” made against it by the major movie studios, and the MPAA has sued RealNetworks (PDF) alleging RealDVD violates the Digital Millenium Copyright Act by bypassing copy protection built into DVDs.
“RealNetworks’ RealDVD should be called StealDVD,” said MPAA general counsel and executive VP Greg Goeckner, in a statement. “RealNetworks knows its product violates the law and undermines the hard-won trust that has been growing between America’s movie makers and the technology community.”
RealDVD Promises Legal DVD Copying
RealNetworks is looking to get into the DVD copying business—only they hope to do it legally—with their new RealDVD application. RealDVD enables users to copy a standard DVD to a computer or portable storage device and watch them later without requiring the original physical disc. How can this be legal? RealDVD wraps the copy in digital rights management software (DRM) that restricts the copy to being played on the machine that performed the copy, and up to five machines authorized by a user using RealDVD.





