Skip to main content

Blurring the Line Between Netbook and Notebook

This week, Lenovo launched its S12 netbook with an Nvidia Ion graphics processor as an option. Though I haven’t had a chance to play with one yet, I’ve just completed two weeks using the Acer Revo Aspire, which is a similar configuration in a mini desktop. Combining the two, I have a pretty good sense of just how blurred the lines between netbooks and notebooks are becoming, and whether you could live on one of these hybrid products.

The Lenovo S12 Size Matters

Netbooks usually have 10-inch or smaller screens, which relegates most of them to relatively light use. This means e-mail, short documents, picture viewing and some light video viewing. You could up the graphics, but the screen is so small, you’d have to go to an external monitor to get the benefit.

The 12-inch screen has, for some time, been the smallest useful size for a notebook. The Lenovo S12 is a netbook with a 12-inch screen, which means, if it has the power, it can function as a full notebook. It’s also thin, sexy, fully loaded , has over four hours of battery life (in realistic usage scenarios, not maximum), and comes in just under $500. Like most of the laptops in its class, it also has no optical drive, which helps both battery life and keeps that very thin look.

Performance: Lovin’ Windows 7

The Acer Revo Aspire came with Windows Vista loaded, and Acer changed the base configuration shortly after I received my system to add more memory. Vista is too slow on this generation of system, which is likely why the Lenovo Notebook ships with Windows XP. The single-core Atom processor appears to be where the system bottlenecks. It is capable of playing Blu-Ray movies (though you don’t want much running in the background), and the game performance is up to things like World of Warcraft, but not high-resolution first person shooters.

Acer Revo Aspire Putting the release candidate for Windows 7 on the Revo made a huge difference. If you don’t mind running pre-release software, or doing a clean install of the final release of Windows 7 once it ships, this class of system loves Windows 7, and once it cache’s your applications, you can go in and out of sleep very quickly. If you do need to reboot, with a single core processor, you don’t see the huge boot time improvement you get on a multi-core system, but Windows 7 is leaner and noticeably faster than Windows Vista.

If you don’t want to move to either Windows 7 or Vista any time soon, this is likely the last run of systems that ship with XP, so you can move at your leisure.

Before we move on: If you do put Windows 7 on one of these, pick up a USB ReadyBoost-compliant 2GB flash drive. You’ll see a noticeable jump in performance if you use it in a system configured like the Lenovo is with 1GB of memory.

Wrapping Up

There is this idea that you can’t live on netbooks and nettops, and without something like an Nvidia Ion and at least a 12-inch screen, that idea is likely valid. However, once you add Ion, suddenly you get the promise of something that is small, sexy, low-power and widely usable. In a market looking for value, second PCs, PCs for kids, and low-cost PCs to replace aging hulks, these hybrid netbooks and nettops fill a unique and valuable void. You can get something fun, cool to use, and you won’t go broke doing it.

When Apple put Nvidia graphics across its entire line, it showcased how important graphics performance is (and in the case of the MacBook Air, made it usable). With Ion, you can get nearly the same thing at under 30 percent of the price, and that, my friends, is a really good deal. With a 12-inch screen and Ion GPU, this new Lenovo isn’t a netbook. Lenovo is setting its sights on Apple with a very portable, low-cost notebook, and one of the best values in the segment.

Editors' Recommendations

Rob Enderle
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Rob is President and Principal Analyst of the Enderle Group, a forward-looking emerging technology advisory firm. Before…
Between AMD’s Ryzen 7 7800X3D and Ryzen 9 7950X3D, there’s no contest
AMD Ryzen 7 7800X3D sitting on a motherboard.

It's no secret that AMD's 3D V-Cache CPUs top the list of the best gaming processors, but the new Ryzen 7 7800X3D puts AMD shoppers in a precarious position. As you can read in our Ryzen 7 7800X3D review, it tops the charts in gaming performance even if it takes a backseat in productivity power. Is that gap enough to justify spending more on the Ryzen 9 7950X3D?

Even with around $300 separating the Ryzen 7 7800X3D and Ryzen 9 7950X3D, the performance gap between them is much closer than their prices would suggest. I threw them both on my test bench to see if spending up is worth it, and there's a clear answer -- the Ryzen 7 7800X3D is the CPU to buy.
Two different tiers

Read more
CES 2023 is a turning point for the dilemma between TVs and gaming monitors
The Samsung Odyssey OLED 49 in a blue-tinted room.

The past few years have seen a convergence between TVs and gaming monitors, and CES 2023 is starting to see the two display types diverge once again. After all, the LG OLED Flex is a TV that looks like a monitor while the Samsung Ark is a monitor that looks a lot like a TV. This year, we're starting to see the lines between TVs and monitors more clearly.

It's not as clean-cut. Some monitors look like TVs and vice versa, but it seems the world of gaming monitors is exploring more exotic form factors and connectivity standards, while TVs are driving toward higher refresh rates, better panel technologies, and larger sizes.
Exotic form factors

Read more
The ThinkPad X1 laptop line embraces recycled magnesium and aluminum
The logo on the palm rests of the ThinkPad X1 Carbon Gen 9.

Lenovo has introduced some modest updates to its high-end ThinkPad X1 line in their latest generations, with a focus on integrating more sustainable materials into these devices.

These updated laptops include the ThinkPad X1 Carbon Gen 11, X1 Yoga Gen 8, and X1 Nano Gen 3. None of them are getting major redesigns, but Lenovo is putting a big emphasis on upgrading them in terms of sustainability.

Read more