Skip to main content

Consumer Reports still believes in the accuracy of the Fitbit

FitBit Surge
Bill Roberson/Digital Trends
The public may not be on Fitbit’s side, but Consumer Reports sure is. Following a class-action lawsuit filed against the health tracker by consumer plaintiffs in California, Colorado, and Wisconsin, the well-regarded outlet retested the devices in their labs, and determined, “Both the Fitbit Charge HR and Fitbit Surge passed our tests handily, accurately recording heart rates at everything from a leisurely walk up to a fast run.” This, of course, is a far cry from the experiences everyday users have noted, with many accusing Fitbit of providing faulty heart rate data, particularly during more intense exercise.

Fitbit has already disputed these claims, stating that the company “strongly disagrees with the statements made in the complaint,” and further noting that its heart rate technology, known as PurePulse, “provides better overall heart rate tracking than cardio machines at the gym.” Even so, the wearables company further reminded users that its devices are not replacements for medical devices, nor are they intended to be employed as scientific monitors.

According to the lawsuit, certain models of the Fitbit provided vastly inaccurate information when subjects engaged in strenuous exercise. “We went and had a board-certified cardiologist put some folks through different levels of exercise and test the different models,” said Jonathan Selbin, the lead partner for the plaintiffs’ law firm. “And, sure enough, particularly at high intensity levels, they are wildly inaccurate,” to the tune of 24.34 beats per minute (bpm). In extreme cases, the Fitbit data differed by 75 bpm.

But this simply was not the case when Consumer Reports ran its own parallel test. Both a male and female volunteer ran on a treadmill with a Polar H7 (a monitor with well-proven accuracy) strapped to their chests. They also each wore the Fitbit Charge HR and Fitbit Surge, one right on the wrist, and the other a few inches higher.

“For our new test, we recorded our subjects’ heart rates at four levels of intensity: at rest, a walking pace (110 bpm), a jogging pace (130 bpm), and a running pace (150 bpm),” Patrick Austin of Consumer Reports writes. “All tests were conducted twice. A total of 64 heart rate measurements were recorded.”

Ultimately, the outlet determined, “The new testing confirmed our earlier results: Both the Charge HR and Surge were very accurate when compared to the reference Polar H7 ECG monitor. During nearly every trial, the variance between the chest strap and the Fitbit devices amounted to no more than three heartbeats per minute.”

There was, however, one notable exception, and it had to do with where the Fitbit was worn. When the female volunteer wore the Charge HR on her wrist and began the more strenuous portion of the test, the Fitbit was indeed off by a wider margin. “During one run, when the chest strap read 150 bpm, the Fitbit Charge HR read 144 bpm,” Austin said. “During the second run, the device read only 139 bpm.”

That said, this was no longer an issue when the Charge was worn on her forearm, and the Fitbit Surge showed itself to be fairly consistent regardless of where it was on the body.

So there you have it, friends. According to a lab test of two individuals, the Fitbit seems perfectly fine. But if you’re having issues, maybe try moving your device up a few inches, and then see where things stand.

Editors' Recommendations

Lulu Chang
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Fascinated by the effects of technology on human interaction, Lulu believes that if her parents can use your new app…
Have a Fitbit? You’ll soon be forced to link a Google account
The Fitbit Inspire 3 in use.

After purchasing Fitbit in 2019, Google is moving to mandate the use of Google accounts on new Fitbit devices. The company shared the news on a help page, adding that it would be winding down Fitbit account functionality by 2025. While Google is pushing its own brand of upcoming smartwatches, there's still substantial interest in Fitbit's well-known products.

"After we launch Google accounts on Fitbit in 2023, some uses of Fitbit will require a Google account, including to sign up for Fitbit or activate newly released Fitbit devices and features," Fitbit said "If you have a Fitbit account, after the launch of Google accounts on Fitbit, you'll have the option to move Fitbit to your Google account or to continue to use your existing Fitbit devices and services with your Fitbit account for as long as it's supported. Support of Fitbit accounts will continue until at least early 2025."

Read more
Fitbit Versa 4 vs. Fitbit Sense 2: Which new Fitbit wins?
Lifestyle photo of the Fitbit Versa 4 and Fitbit Sense 2.

Fitbit is back with two new health-focused smartwatches, the Fitbit Versa 4 and the Fitbit Sense 2. Both watches are well-designed tools with health-tracking features, superseding the Fitbit Versa 3 and the original Sense.

While Google purchased Fitbit in the interim between both releases, these still use the company's proprietary Fitbit OS in lieu of Wear OS 3. For that, you'll need to get the Pixel Watch, the Samsung Galaxy Watch 5, or the Montblanc Summit 3. Instead, these releases from Fitbit iterate and refine what made their previous models so good. The good batteries and handsome designs remain, accompanied by changes to heft and feel and minor software tweaks here and there. With so much overlap, there's a question to be raised about which of the two is the better fit for your wrist and wallet, so which is better for you? We found out.
Specs

Read more
The Fitbit Versa 4 and Sense 2 are coming soon, and without Wear OS
Lifestyle photo of the Fitbit Versa 4 and Fitbit Sense 2.

Fitbit's lineup of smartwatches and fitness trackers is getting larger just in time for the holiday season, with the company announcing the Fitbit Versa 4, Fitbit Sense 2, and Fitbit Inspire 3. The Versa and Sense continue Fitbit's smartwatch focus, while the Inspire remains one of the go-to choices for anyone who wants to eschew too many smart features for a sleeker design and smaller price. And they're likely to be among the best Fitbit wearables you can buy this year.

Right off the bat, none of these wearables are significant new additions to Fitbit's portfolio. They're all very similar to their predecessors, but with a few minor tweaks here and there to make them better than before. And, no, none of the new smartwatches are running Wear OS. Fitbit has made some intriguing hardware and software upgrades across the board, but this latest launch is clearly focused on evolution rather than revolution.
Fitbit Versa 4

Read more