Judge dismisses Apple-Motorola cases with prejudice

international trade commission determines apple is violating motorola patent applemotorola

U.S. federal judge Richard Posner of the Northern District of Illinois on Friday dismissed Apple’s and Motorola’s smartphone lawsuits against each other, finding neither party had presented an adequate case. The dismissal doesn’t mark the end of legal wrangling between Apple and Motorola (and its new corporate parent, Google), but does represent a setback for Apple’s legal battle against Android—and a blow to Motorola’s efforts to charge Apple extra for licenses to patents available under FRAND terms.

All Things D has posted the complete text of the ruling (PDF).

Judge Posner had clearly been nonplussed by both Apple and Motorola’s claims for a while: he’d previously narrowed Apple’s claims that Motorola infringed on four Apple patents down to just one, characterized the case as “silly,” and early this month cancelled the case’s trial date and tentatively concluded that the case would have to be dismissed. However, he acceded to a request from Apple for one last chance to convince him the case should proceed—and in his final dismissal thoroughly chastised Apple for failing to present compelling evidence of damage. Posner also characterized a report from Apple’s damages expert as “demonstrably inadequate.”

“Apple attempts what I told its legal team at a pretrial conference I would not let it do in the liability trials then envisaged: turn the case into an Apple versus Motorola popularity contest,” Judge Posner wrote. “Apple is complaining that Motorola’s phones as a whole ripped off the iPhone as a whole. But Motorola’s desire to sell products that compete with the iPhone is a separate harm—and a perfectly legal one—from any harm caused by patent infringement.”

However, Posner didn’t let Motorola off the hook either. Motorola had been seeking an injunction on Apple for failing to license a Motorola patents related to UMTS mobile technology available under FRAND (fair, reasonable, and non-discriminatory) terms. Except Apple didn’t refuse to license the patent from Motorola, it merely refused to pay more than Motorola would charge to anyone else. Motorola been frequently criticized for leveraging its standards-essential patents in its legal battles, and Judge Posner made it very clear the strategy held no water with him.

“I don’t see how, given FRAND, I would be justified in enjoining Apple from infringing the ‘898 [patent] unless Apple refuses to pay a royalty that meets the FRAND requirement,” Posner wrote. “By committing to license its patents on FRAND terms, Motorola committed to license the ‘898 to anyone willing to pay a FRAND royalty and thus implicitly acknowledged that a royalty is adequate compensation for a license to use that patent.”

Judge Posner’s dismissal could have ramifications for other cases where Motorola is trying to leverage its standards-essential patents—such as its ongoing litigation against Microsoft, where it is demanding a 2.25 percent royalty on every Xbox sold. Posner’s is effectively an endorsement of the the position advocated by Apple, Microsoft, Cisco, and others that regulatory agencies should not grant product injunctions in patent disputes over standard-essential patents.

Apple and Motorola’s next confrontation should be at the U.S. International Trade Commission; Apple already lost the first round of that fight, but the complaint is due to be heard by the ITC’s full panel. The companies are also going after each other in a number of international venues.

Photography

Oppo Reno 10x Zoom vs. Huawei P30 Pro camera shootout: Zooming in on the action

When Huawei introduced its zoom lens on the P30 Pro, it opened up a whole new world of photographic opportunity on a smartphone. Now, Oppo's challenging it with the Reno 10x Zoom, so we've found out which is best.
Mobile

The Galaxy Note 10 might not be equipped with Qualcomm's most powerful processor

The Samsung Galaxy S10 range isn't exactly old, but Samsung is already working on the next big release. Details about the Samsung Galaxy Note 10 are making their way online, and we've gathered them all for you.
Product Review

You don't need a gaming phone, but the Red Magic 3 will make you want one

Gaming phones have arrived, and Nubia has pulled a tempting example from its top hat in the shape of the impressive Red Magic 3. A huge display, speedy performance, and more make this a dream phone for gaming.
Mobile

It's still worth boarding this fleet of old flagship phones if you want to save

Do you really need to blow your savings to get the latest smartphone, or is it worth looking at the top phones from yesteryear? We highlight some old flagships that are still worth buying and discuss new budget phones as an alternative.
Mobile

Stalking apps: Google deletes 7 Android trackers from the Play Store

Google has removed from the Play Store seven stalking apps that could track someone's phone without them knowing about it. The sneaky software also offers access to a phone's contact list, as well as its SMS and call history.
Mobile

Unihertz's rugged phone with a keyboard launches July 30 on Kickstarter

Recently, only BlackBerry's phones have offered a physical keyboard. Not any more. Chinese manufacturer Unihertz is preparing to launch the Unihertz Titan -- a rugged phone with a built-in physical keyboard.
Mobile

Free yourself! How to unlock a phone from the icy hands of your wireless carrier

Do you want to know how to unlock a phone through your carrier or a third-party service like DoctorSIM? Regardless of which way you want to go, we've compiled a list of requirements and methods for doing so.
Mobile

St. Paul, Minnesota, is the latest U.S. city to access Verizon's 5G network

Verizon is in the midst of a massive 5G rollout. Its mobile 5G network is now available in select areas of several cities such as Chicago and Denver. Here's everything you need to know about Verizon's 5G network.
Mobile

Renders suggest the Huawei Mate 30 Pro may have a special cinematic camera lens

The Huawei Mate 30 and Mate 30 Pro may join the Mate X folding phone as the company's star products for late 2019. This is what we know about the Huawei Mate 30 and Mate 30 Pro so far.
Mobile

A.I. photo filters use neural networks to make photos look like Picassos

Artificial Intelligence apps put a novel spin on social network-style photo filters. Instead of just overlaying an effect, these photo filters use machine learning and neural networks to transform an image into a predetermined style.
Mobile

Big, beautiful, and breakable: Check out the best Galaxy S8 Plus cases

There’s no denying Samsung’s ability to turn out an attractive smartphone, but glass curves are expensive to fix and metal chips easily. We've rounded up the best Galaxy S8 Plus cases on the market.
Wearables

FCC filing reveals impressive specs for luxury Movado Connect 2.0 smartwatch

It's been a while since we saw a smartwatch from luxury watchmaker Movado, but that drought may be over soon. FCC filings for the Movado Connect 2.0 have surfaced, and they paint a picture of a high-spec smartwatch.
Mobile

T-Mobile wants to give you a free smartphone when you add a line

Did someone say free smartphones? T-Mobile is offering free smartphones from a select range of affordable phones when a new line is opened on its $40 per month per line Magenta tier and above.
Mobile

Get your game on with the best controllers for Android smartphones

If you're looking to do some serious gaming on an Android device, you're going to need a gamepad. Here are the best controllers for Android games on smartphones and tablets, with rechargeable and wireless options.