Android doesn’t infringe on Oracle patents, rules Jury

Google Android Oracle patents

Following a closely-followed six-week courtroom trail, a California jury has found that Google did not infringe on two Java-related patents now owned by Oracle, likely clearing a major cloud from the future of Google’s “free and open” Android mobile operating system. The outcome is a disappointment for database giant Oracle and its notoriously aggressive CEO Larry Ellison, which had consistently insisted that Google knew it needed a license for Java.

During the first phase of the trial, the jury that Google had infringed on Oracle’s copyrights by copying a single nine-line function. Now that the jury has found Google did not infringe on Oracle’s Java patents, that means Google is only on the hook to Oracle for copying that single function. With trebling of damages, that could amount to as much as $150,000 — small change to companies the size of Oracle and Google, and not likely to even put a dent in the legal fees Oracle has incurred so far. The figure is also a far cry from the $1 billion Oracle had been seeking from Google for its re-implementation of Java.

Oracle has vowed to press on with the case. “Oracle presented overwhelming evidence at trial that Google knew it would fragment and damage Java,” Oracle spokeswoman Deborah Hellinger told Reuters.

Key issues brought out at the trial remain unresolved. During the copyright phase, the jury could not reach a decision on whether Google’s use of 37 Java APIs could be considered fair use — which means Oracle cannot currently collect any damages for Google’s use of the APIs. Of deeper interest to the entire software industry, District Judge William Alsup has reserved the question of whether APIs can be copyrighted at all as an issue solely for his consideration. He has not yet ruled on the matter.

Speaking with reporters after the trial, jury foreperson Greg Thompson revealed that the jury had been leaning strongly in Google’s favor both during the copyright and patent portions of the trial. According to Thompson, the jury was split nine to three in favor of Google on copyright issues — and Thompson himself was the lone holdout in favor of Oracle on the patent questions. Thompson eventually concluded that, despite his reservations, Oracle hadn’t met its burden of proof.

For Oracle to make its case, the jury would have had to have returned unanimous decisions in its favor.

The trial will now move into its damages phase, which should be straightforward given that Oracle can currently only expect to receive damages from Google’s copying of that single nine-line function.

Judge Alsup has not indicated when he may rule on the issue of whether APIs can be copyrighted, although some case-watchers expect his decision may come as early has next week. However, instructions to the jury during the copyright phase were to assume that APIs could be copyrighted.

For Oracle, that’s not great news. Even if Judge Alsup rules APIs can be copyrighted, the best Oracle can hope for is a new trial on at least the copyright matters, since the jury hung on the question of fair use. A finding that APIs are copyrightable would, however, have broad ramifications throughout the software industry — and Google would no doubt seek to appeal such a finding before any sort of new trial could begin.

If Judge Alsup judge rules APIs cannot be copyrighted, Oracle’s only recourse will be to appeal the ruling.

The result so far is a significant disappointment for Oracle, which in pre-trial motions was seeking damages in excess of $6 billion from Google for infringement. The was reduced to around $1 billion by the time the trail commenced — and now it appears Oracle won’t walk away with much of anything.

Emerging Tech

Leafy greens are grown by machines at new, automated Silicon Valley farm

Farming hasn't changed too much for hundreds of years. Now a new startup called Iron Ox has opened its first automated hydroponics farm, producing a variety of leafy greens tended by machines.
Home Theater

How to buy speakers: A beginner’s guide to home audio

From the difference between bookshelf speakers and monitors to the proper way to audition, our ultimate speaker buying guide has all the information you need to create your own home audio nirvana.
Product Review

For picture quality on a budget, Vizio's new P-Series is absolutely unbeatable

Vizio’s P-Series TV line has always been the best among the brand’s long run of budget-friendly TVs, but this year’s model has really stepped up. While the competition is also improving, Vizio’s latest P-Series keeps the brand among…
Gaming

Open-world video games are getting too big for their own good

As technology has progressed, open-world video games have grown increasingly bigger. What seems like a universal positive has shown problems preventing the genre from truly moving forward, however.
Mobile

Xiaomi phone with 5G and 10GB of RAM will become more than just a rumor next week

Xiaomi will announce the Mi Mix 3 smartphone on October 25, and according to the company's spokesperson, it will be capable of connecting at 5G speeds and feature 10GB of RAM -- two world firsts.
Product Review

Google’s Pixel 3 is a hair away from pocket-sized perfection

Google’s Pixel 3 smartphone is the best Android phone you can buy. It doesn’t have the best looks or the best hardware, but you’ll be hard pressed to find better software and unique A.I. functionalities.
Product Review

Mediocre battery and a big notch slight Google's otherwise perfect Pixel phone

Google’s Pixel 3 XL has two big flaws: The gigantic notch on the front, and mediocre battery life. That being said, this is the best Android experience you can find in a smartphone today.
Mobile

Key settings you need to change on your brand-new LG V40 ThinQ

Now that you've got your brand-new LG V40 ThinQ, it's time to get to work. Whether its hiding the notch or setting a schedule for the blue light filter, here are some key settings you'll want to change on your LG V40 ThinQ.
Mobile

Keep Notes is the latest app to get Google’s Material Design makeover

Google is updating more and more of its apps to come into line with its latest Material Design trends, and now it's Keep Notes' turn to get a new pair of pants. This update is now rolling out on Android devices.
Mobile

The upcoming OnePlus 6T may get a major camera update

According to a recent report, the launch of the OnePlus 6T could be different from any other OnePlus launch in history. How? It could have the backing of a major U.S. carrier. Here's everything we know about the OnePlus 6T.
Mobile

Verizon's newest deals can net you $500 off the LG V40 ThinQ

Looking for a new LG flagship? The LG V40 ThinQ is here, and it's bringing a familiar style, two more camera lenses, and upgraded specs. Here's absolutely everything you need to know about the LG V40 ThinQ.
Mobile

Pixel 3 XL vs. Pixel 2 XL vs. Pixel XL: Which XL is best for you?

A Google Pixel XL is the best phone to get if you want the perfect Android experience on a big screen. However, with the release of the Pixel 3 XL, you have more choices then ever. Which Pixel XL should you buy?
Mobile

LG V40 ThinQ vs. Samsung Galaxy Note 9: Can the V40 unseat the king?

The LG V40 ThinQ is packing a massive display and an incredible five lenses, making it a unique offering in the market. But is it better than the Galaxy Note 9, another phone with a huge display and great cameras?
Mobile

There are four versions of the Mate 20, but which one is the best?

Huawei revealed its full range of Mate 20 handsets, and it seems that there is a device that fits everyone's needs. We've compared all the options, including the Huawei Mate 20 Pro, the Mate 20 X, the Mate 20, and the Mate 20 Lite.