How the Apple rumor mill got the iPhone 4S so wrong

iphone-5-concept-teardrop

Wow, did we get it wrong. No tear-drop design. No edge-to-edge screen. No 4G LTE or NFC. No two iPhones. No iPhone 5 at all. We, the tech press, really botched things up this time – and I’m as guilty as anyone, maybe more so than most. With months of extra speculation before Apple finally, mercifully, announced the fifth-generation iPhone 4S on Tuesday, the iPhone rumor mill had spun wildly out of control. And seeing as rumors for the next iPhone have already started to creep onto our pages and editorial agendas, it’s safe to assume the haphazard reporting will only continue.

From our side, it’s all too easy to get swept up in every new Apple rumor. Why? Because the people love it. To avoid unsubstantiated Apple news is to ignore what readers want to read about, and the traffic that goes with delivering it. Traffic that equals precious advertising dollars that can allow a publication to hire more writers, attend more events and ultimately, produce better coverage. It is as enticing as it is dangerous. And it must be stopped.

So rather than maintain the pitiful status quo, I’ve listed a number of key points that I plan to remember vividly when reporting all things Apple, from here until eternity. They should illuminate what went wrong this time as much as they help steer us straight in the future. I hope some of my fellow tech journalists will join me, and perhaps add some of their own suggestions to the mix. For you, the reader, I hope to offer some clues as to what to look out for when reading Apple news and unsubstantiated news in general.

Don’t take analysts at their word

The tech press and market analysts are good friends. That’s because it’s the job of both parties to have a solid understanding of the technology industry, and both sides benefit from what the other has to offer. Analysts provide a professional assessment of what to expect from the technology industry, and journalists can help bolster the careers of analysts by treating them as authorities on certain matters. For investors, analysts can help them know how to place their bets on the stock market. For journalists, analyst opinion adds validity to reporting.

Unfortunately, it also leads to a lot of misinformation. As my colleague Molly McHugh reports, the whole ‘two iPhone’ rumor that persevered throughout this past iPhone rumor season originated with Deutsche Bank analyst Chris Whitmore, who told clients to expect both the iPhone 5 and iPhone 4S. Fortune then reported Whitmore’s prediction, and the rest is history.

Of course, not all analysts got it wrong. But that’s not the point. The point is that, just because someone is an analyst, it doesn’t mean they have some inside scoop. In fact, sometimes they predict something simply because they think it makes sense, not because they have any evidence to support their claims. Their opinions should be treated with as much trepidation as information from the infamous “person familiar with the matter.” Which brings us to…

Anonymous sources don’t carry much weight

If I had it my way, news outlets would never publish another story based on the mutterings of an unnamed source. But that’s just not going to happen. We in the tech press would, however, be wise to not publish a story every time someone happens to have a “tip,” or at least not publish stories based purely on data from people unwilling to back up their claims by giving up their names. We must dig deeper, and use information from anonymous sources to find more information, which could, eventually, lead to some actual, reportable evidence. We must do this, or risk becoming worthless.

As necessary as this change in procedure is for the tech press, it’s also one of the most difficult to accomplish. Thorough reporting takes time and money – the two things few online publications have to spare. But larger publishing institutions – Reuters, Bloomberg, The New York Times and the Wall Street Journal all come to mind – must lead the way. Many technology news outlets, this one included, take many of our cues from the big guys because they have the money, history, connections and deep reporter pools to do the hard, expensive work. Good or bad, that’s just how things work nowadays. And it’s not going to change any time soon. That said, what can change is the media’s overwhelming reliance on those who wish to remain anonymous.

Major publications get it wrong, too

Just because some bit of news is reported by a blog (or even a tweet, for that matter) doesn’t mean it’s not true. By the same token, the fact that a major news outlet (like those listed above) reports something doesn’t make it so.

An example: Early in February, both Bloomberg and the Wall Street Journal published stories claiming that Apple would release a new, less-expensive iPhone this year that would sell for about $200 and be available unlocked, without a contract.

Given the status of these trusted publications, tech news sites (again, this one included) jumped all over it. Sure, we all added the caveat that the news was simply a “rumor,” but it all had an air of believability that it likely would have lacked had the news had come from a no-name blog. Of course, as well all now know too well, none of it turned out to be true.

Now, I’m certainly not saying tech blogs are any better — they aren’t. The goal should be to treat both with an equal helping of skepticism, especially when anonymous sources are involved.

Cases mean nothing

This is the most specific point on the list, but I think it needs to be said: If someone makes a case to fit an unannounced iPhone or iPad, it doesn’t mean they know something we don’t.

This year, we saw a plethora of supposed “iPhone 5” cases and case design documents leaked to the press. Many of them were made to fit a device with a slimmer, tear drop-shaped design and a larger screen. And a lot of people took this to mean that they had some insider knowledge about what Apple was producing, especially because many of the cases came from China, which is also where Apple produces the iPhone.

Turns out, the case makers made a terrible gamble. One company, Hard Candy, made a full 50,000 iPhone 5 cases to fit a device with a 4.44-inch screen. It got its information from three independent sources, all of whom reported the same measurements. And all of them were wrong. The phone Apple released is exactly the same shape and size as the iPhone 4 – no new case design needed, whatsoever.

So next year, when real iPhone 5 (or whatever it will be called) cases begin to emerge, just remember, “Nothing to see here.”

Most of these points likely seem glaringly obvious – and they are. In fact, they are mostly just basics of journalism. But obviously, that doesn’t mean we couldn’t all use a bit of a refresher, and remember how things got so grossly out of control this year.

The up-to-the-second tech news is great for those of us who love to know what’s next on the gadget horizon. But we serve ourselves and our readers poorly when we let the rumors run the show.

The views expressed here are solely those of the author and do not reflect the beliefs of Digital Trends.

Mobile

Apple’s new iPads are hardly new at all. Don’t waste your money

It has taken Apple four years to get around to updating the iPad Mini line, but the new iPad Mini is virtually identical to its predecessor. It’s joined by a confusing iPad Air with no obvious target audience. Is Apple just trying to sell…
Mobile

Whether by the pool or the sea, make a splash with the best waterproof phones

Whether you're looking for a phone you can use in the bath, or you just want that extra peace of mind, waterproof phones are here and they're amazing. Check out our selection of the best ones you can buy.
Home Theater

Apple's Airpods 2 could be released as early as this week

Apple may release new AirPods in the first half of 2019. A wireless charging case, health sensors, water resistance, and better Siri integration are some of the improvements rumored to be part of the new package.
Mobile

Free yourself! How to unlock a phone from the icy hands of your wireless carrier

Do you want to know how to unlock a phone through your carrier or a third-party service like DoctorSIM? Regardless of which way you want to go, we've compiled a list of requirements and methods for doing so.
Wearables

These are the best smartwatches for everything from fashion to fitness

Tempted to buy a smartwatch? If so, then the growing number of great models available means you've got plenty to choose from. But which one should you pick? Here is our list of the best smartwatches.
Mobile

These voice-changing apps will have you punking friends and family like a pro

Have you ever wanted to call your friends as Darth Vader or Alvin from the Chipmunks? If you want to play a prank on your friends, we have the best voice-changer apps for iOS and Android, whether you want to record audio or make a call.
Mobile

Even older Apple Watches could be effective at spotting heart conditions

The Apple Watch Series 4 is known for detecting heart conditions like atrial fibrillation thanks to having an electrocardiograph feature. It turns out that older Apple Watches could be effective at tracking AFib, too.
Mobile

iPad Air vs. iPad Mini: Which new tablet from Apple is best for you?

Apple has unveiled two new iPad models, including a new iPad Air and a new iPad Mini. Both devices have a lot to offer. But which iPad is right for your needs? We put the iPad Air and iPad Mini to the test to find out.
Deals

The best Apple AirPods alternatives for Android, Windows, and iOS devices

Apple AirPods, nice as they are, aren't the only game in town. Other makers are offering their own truly wireless earbuds, and if you're looking to buy a pair of high-end in-ear headphones, we've got the best AirPod alternatives on the…
Deals

It’s time to check out the best Apple Watch deals for March 2019

The Apple Watch has surged to prominence in recent years. If you're in the market for an iOS wearable, we've sniffed out the best Apple Watch deals available right now for all three models of this great smartwatch.
Deals

Need a new tablet? Here are the best iPad deals for March 2019

In the wide world of tablets, Apple is still the king. If you're on team Apple and just can't live without iOS, we've curated an up-to-date list of all of the best iPad deals currently available for March 2018.
Deals

Amazon drops price on Apple Watch Series 4 with a rare deal

Since Apple first unveiled the Series 4, the price for one has pretty much held fast. This has finally started to change with a nice little $15 discount on Amazon. If you've been wanting the newest Apple Watch, now is a great time.
Movies & TV

Netflix confirms it won’t be a part of Apple’s new video-streaming service

Netflix has confirmed that subscribers to Apple's new video streaming service won't have the option to view Netflix content on it. Apple is set to unveil its new TV service next week.
Gaming

Angry Birds AR: Isle of Pigs brings 3D demolition into your living room

Angry Birds is releasing its next entry in the spring of 2019 - with a new spin. Bringing 3D environments and destruction, Angry Birds AR: Isle of Pigs uses augmented reality to add a new dimension to a classic series.