In the Shadow of the iPad: Why Apple is Succeeding Where Microsoft Fails

in the shadow of ipad why apple is succeeding where microsoft fails

I was at the EMC World cloud computing conference last week, and once again I observed a number of people who otherwise would have been using notebooks, using iPads instead. The number is small, but telling, because initially when Microsoft announced the tablet computer, I observed similar behavior, but missing the critical part. It wasn’t what people were using, but how they were using it that was important. The difference may highlight why a company like Apple can launch a product that drastically departs from what people are currently using, and why a company like Microsoft has to follow the paths that companies like Apple forge.

Just because your product creates a market, that creation doesn’t mean you’ll own what results. The Apple II created the PC market, but initially Commodore benefitted the most, and eventually Microsoft. On the other hand, Apple defined the MP3 market with the iPod and remained the biggest beneficiary, had arguably the same success with the iPhone, and is on track to repeat with the iPad, so betting they won’t succeed with this last platform may be a fool’s bet.

Why can’t Microsoft drive change, while Apple can do it consistently? I think it comes down to one core skill that Apple has that is unique, not just to technology, but to business in general: understanding how to win over the hearts of consumers.

Is Manipulation a Bad Thing?

When we call someone “manipulative,” it is generally considered an insult. The most famous manipulator was likely PT Barnum, and it didn’t help that his most memorable saying was “there’s sucker born every minute.” He was incredibly successful and thought of himself as a showman. Like Steve Jobs, he had some tough times, but emerged from them stronger than when he went in, and actually went on to be a politician for a time. I maintain that Steve Jobs is our generation’s PT Barnum, and given that Barnum died in 1891, folks with his unique talent who rise to power in business are a very rare breed.

It is interesting to note that unlike Jobs, Barnum did apply his skills to philanthropy, and was the initiator of a philosophy that Google “invented,” called profitable philanthropy. I believe Jobs could embrace this concept as well, but I’ve drifted off topic.

Manipulation, like any other tool, isn’t in itself good or bad. But it is incredibly powerful, and if used for good, the results are more powerful and farther reaching. If used for evil, it results in pyramid schemes and confidence scams, and can do just as much damage. Folks that excel at this skill tend to think rules no longer apply to them, and their falls from grace are both certain and catastrophic. Both Jobs and Barnum had a number of close calls, but are generally regarded in a positive light.

Microsoft vs. Apple’s Great Magician

Steve Jobs seems to inherently understand that products requiring people to do things differently have to have some magic to them, and that this magic is largely an artificial construct created by the initial presentation and marketing of the product.

apple confirms ipad wifi connectivity issues offers fixes the 001If you look at the iPad, it really isn’t that special in terms of hardware. To an engineer, it’s a hobbled netbook without a keyboard, a crippled interface (compared to a Mac), and an inability to multitask or run Flash. I’m sure plenty of engineers at Apple competitors think the iPad is crap.

But the iPad is incredibly simple, physically beautiful, and promotes behavior that folks currently aren’t demonstrating on their PCs or phones often. In other words, regardless of its shortcomings, it is designed to be in a story, and the result is magic.

Magic is about illusion, but it is nonetheless wonderful, and we actually love magical things. I mean, wouldn’t it be great if fairies actually did create the iPad?

Microsoft doesn’t get the need for “magic” in getting people to do things differently – and I would say this is true of 99.9 percent of companies in the world. The most popular Windows tablets came in clamshell designs that people effectively used as heavier, smaller, more expensive laptops. That’s not magical, that’s stupid. There was no magic, and the people I saw using Windows tablets years ago were using them just as if they were laptops, and they generally weren’t smiling like the iPad users are.

If you look at Microsoft projects like Origami, Mira, and the new Kin phones, you see a distinct lack of magic, yet each were attempts to change how people were currently doing things. It wasn’t that these offerings didn’t have potential, but that the folks creating them didn’t understand how to create magic, so none of them prioritized the magical parts, or presented the products in a way that captured our imaginations.

Microsoft’s most successful and magical product launch was Windows 95. It was magical, and the company has never repeated it. It is almost as if Microsoft execs said, “Oh crap, this was ‘too good,’ let’s not do that again.” Meanwhile, Apple relearned magic formula again with the return of Steve Jobs, and effectively used it to help make the iPod, iPhone, iPad, MacBook Air, and Steve Jobs became CEO of the last decade.

People in Microsoft with magical inclinations, like Kathleen Hall, aren’t in a position to do more than add glamour to an existing offering. Her team was at the core of why Windows 7 has been vastly more successful than earlier Windows offerings. But imagine what could happen if Windows 8 or any other Microsoft product was designed to be special like Apple’s offerings.

The Power of Manipulation and Magic

Most people live miles from where they are born, have beliefs that aren’t that much different than their parents, drive the same make of cars year after year, and still use computers mostly like typewriters on steroids. We mostly eat at the same places and rarely try new things. To get us to move to something different requires a cattle-prod-like skill, and whether you call the wielder of such a skill a manipulator or a magician, it is critical to making products like the iPod, iPhone, and iPad successful.

I think it is a skill that more companies should develop, a skill that likely will be lost once Steve Jobs leaves Apple (it was a long time from PT Barnum) and a skill that provides too much enjoyment to lose. It is also the skill that explains why Apple can be successful with the iPad, but Microsoft wasn’t successful with its tablets. There should be a little PT Barnum or Steve Jobs in every CEO. Wrapped with a strong ethical core, the end result would be more magical products like the iPad, more successful companies like Apple, and more truly special products we could enjoy.

The views expressed here are solely those of the author and do not reflect the beliefs of Digital Trends.


It took Dell years to fix 1 problem on its best laptop. Here’s how they did it

The new Dell XPS 13 moves the webcam from the below the screen to the top, finally vanquishing the one obstacle facing thin, sleek laptop displays. We have the exclusive story on how it was done.

How to choose an iPad in 2019: A practical guide to Apple’s tablets

Selecting an iPad from Apple's lineup can be intimidating, but it doesn't have to be. Our comprehensive guide should put the numbers and specs in practical, easy-to-understand terms. Find your ideal iPad with the help of our guide.

Need a new tablet? The best iPad deals for January 2019

In the wide world of tablets, Apple is still the king. If you're on team Apple and just can't live without iOS, we've curated an up-to-date list of all of the best iPad deals currently available for December 2018.

Rekindled yet again, Nokia’s next-gen phones offer more than just nostalgia

HMD Global, a startup that designs and builds Nokia Android smartphones, wants to put the Nokia brand name back “where it belongs.” It helps that it’s made up of ex-Nokia employees. We go behind the scenes to see how HMD formed.

Apple resurrects the iPhone SE with brand-new units starting at $249

Apple quietly started selling the iPhone SE again, at even lower prices than when it was discontinued four months ago. Brand new units of the 32GB version are on sale for $249, while the 128GB version is going for $299.

Text up a storm with the best messaging apps for iOS and Android

These days, most people tend to favor digital messages over phone calls. We have the best messaging apps that allow you to share photos and documents, send text messages, and more with end-to-end encryption.
Product Review

Controversy has dogged the MacBook Pro lately. Is it still a good purchase?

The MacBook Pro is a controversial laptop these days -- and that's unfortunate. Due to some divisive changes Apple made to the functionality of the MacBook Pro, fans are more split. Does the 8th-gen refresh change that?

Want a MacBook that will last all day on a single charge? Check these models out

Battery life is one of the most important factors in buying any laptop, especially MacBooks. Their battery life is typically average, but there are some standouts. Knowing which MacBook has the best battery life can be rather useful.

The best iPhone 6 cases for style and protection

No one likes a bruised Apple. Scratches, scuffs, and cracks on a new iPhone 6 are enough to ruin anyone’s day. Check out the best iPhone 6 cases and get some protection on that shiny new smartphone.

Is 5G as fast as they’re saying? We break down the speeds

We take a look at the kinds of speeds you can expect from 5G when the networks roll out. Find out 5G compares to the last generation of network technology, what the minimum and maximum speeds will be, and what it means for us.

Tizen 4 arriving on Samsung’s Gear S3 and Gear Sport smartwatches

Samsung is updating the Gear S3 Classic, Gear S3 Frontier, and the Gear Sport to the newest version of Tizen 4. Along with of some little tweaks to usability and quality-of-life, Samsung has added some new features.

Mobvoi’s TicWatch E2 and S2 are the most affordable Wear OS smartwatches yet

Quality smartwatches don't have to be expensive, and Mobvoi's TicWatch is the proud paladin of that philosophy. Mobvoi's new TicWatch S2 and are both available for low prices from Amazon and Mobvoi's website.

Save up to $950 with the best smartphone deals for January 2019

Need a better phone but don't want to spend a fortune? It's never a bad time to score a new smartphone and save some cash. We rounded up the best smartphone deals available that can save you as much as $950.

Apple Pay coming to more top U.S. stores, including Target and Taco Bell

Apple Pay is the best way to pay on your iPhone and Apple Watch. Apple Pay support is being rolled out across the U.S. for a variety of top retailers, including Taco Bell, Target, Hy-Vee, and more.