Skip to main content

Judge rules against Apple in FaceTime lawsuit

applevirnetxA Texas judge has upheld a legal decision against Apple over whether the company’s FaceTime application infringes on another company’s existing patents. The result gave the Cupertino giant less than two months to make good on the millions of dollars it owes in damages.

Judge Leonard Davis of the Eastern District of Texas released his ruling on Tuesday, denying Apple’s two requests for a new trial to overturn the November 2012 jury verdict in favor of patent holding company VirnetX or, at the very least, reduce the amount of damages owed from the initial $368.2 million amount. Instead, Davis ordered the two companies to come to an agreement regarding a licensing deal that would allow Apple to continue using the problematic patents in exchange for proper renumeration.

VirnetX has initially launched legal action against Apple back in 2010, alleging that Apple’s FaceTime – the app that allows real-time video conferencing between Apple devices – infringes on four separate patents owned by the small company. According to a Bloomberg report on the original jury trial, the company’s patents “cover the use of a domain-name service to set up virtual private networks, through which a website owner can interact with customers in a secure way or an employee can work at home and get access to a company’s electronic files.”

Apple isn’t the only company that has been sued by VirnetX over infringements of these patents; the company has already settled a suit with Microsoft in 2010, and is headed towards a court appearance with Cisco next month.

The $368.2 million verdict awarded to VirnetX is lower than the $708 million that the company was initially looking for. In another setback to their plans, Judge Davis also refused the company’s request for an injunction against Apple continuing to offer FaceTime until the two companies have reached a licensing agreement. There is an additional incentive for Apple to find such an agreement quickly – Judge Davis ordered the company to pay VirnetX $330,211 per day until the agreement has been reached. Davis also set a deadline for the agreement: Both parties have 45 days in which to sort everything out, or else the Court will make an additional ruling that may, it’s believed, grant the injunction request.

As you might expect, Apple has yet to release any comment on the matter – it’s possible that the company is merely perfecting the right amount of passive aggression to instill into the inevitable public “apology” for the whole matter – but VirnetX’s CEO Kendall Larsen has already issued a statement on the ruling. “We are extremely pleased with the Court’s Order in our suit against Apple,” Larsen said. “We look forward to negotiating a license with Apple that includes an ongoing royalty agreement.”

Topics
Graeme McMillan
Former Digital Trends Contributor
A transplant from the west coast of Scotland to the west coast of America, Graeme is a freelance writer with a taste for pop…
How to change your language in Google Chrome on desktop
Chrome OS

Google Chrome supports a wide range of languages. While it'll default to English in most cases, there's nothing stopping you from changing its settings and displaying pages in Spanish, French, or dozens of other languages.

Changing your default language in Chrome takes only a few seconds, and the technique used is the same across Windows and Mac. Aside from changing your language, note that Chrome now gives you the option to automatically translate pages written in another language – making it easy to read content from around the globe.

Read more
23 of the best Netflix hacks, tips, and tricks
The Netflix home screen.

Netflix is one of the most popular streaming platforms for all things movies and TV shows. Home to an immense library of titles, the Netflix archive is constantly changing and evolving, and so are the many ways you can use your Netflix account. 

For instance, did you know you can access region-locked Netflix shows and flicks by using a VPN? Or that you can disable that pesky Autoplay feature? There are tons of Netflix hacks, tips, and tricks out there, so we’ve gone ahead and rounded up all of our favorites! 
Expand your streaming with a VPN

Read more
How to make a GIF from a YouTube video
woman sitting and using laptop

Sometimes, whether you're chatting with friends or posting on social media, words just aren't enough -- you need a GIF to fully convey your feelings. If there's a moment from a YouTube video that you want to snip into a GIF, the good news is that you don't need complex software to so it. There are now a bunch of ways to make a GIF from a YouTube video right in your browser.

If you want to use desktop software like Photoshop to make a GIF, then you'll need to download the YouTube video first before you can start making a GIF. However, if you don't want to go through that bother then there are several ways you can make a GIF right in your browser, without the need to download anything. That's ideal if you're working with a low-specced laptop or on a phone, as all the processing to make the GIF is done in the cloud rather than on your machine. With these options you can make quick and fun GIFs from YouTube videos in just a few minutes.
Use GIFs.com for great customization
Step 1: Find the YouTube video that you want to turn into a GIF (perhaps a NASA archive?) and copy its URL.

Read more