Turn a new page: Why digital designs shouldn’t mimic physical designs

skeuomorphism ipad apple apps designWhen technology eliminates the need for something to look a certain way, but designers cling to the old look for familiarity, it’s called skeuomorphism. Think of everything from the rivets in your jeans to the “spokes” on a hubcap, neither of which need to exist anymore.

Skeuomorphism is one of the most debated trends currently happening in design, thanks in no small part to Apple’s copious use of them in digital interfaces. This drives designers — and design appreciators, like me — mad. Skeuomorphs are bad design. They should be stopped. Don’t take my word for it, though, take it from industrial design legend Dieter Rams. Here’s why one of the world’s most celebrated designers would probably disagree with skeuomorphs.

Skeuomorphism and the commandments of design

In the late 1970s, Rams asked himself: What are the ten most important principles for good design? The guidelines resulting from his inquiry have since been described by some as the “Ten Commandments” of Design.

Apple’s brilliant designers should adhere to these recommendations in their interface design, right? Surprisingly, they do not, and their skeuomorphs are often the worst violators. Here’s a rundown of Rams’ principles, and how Apple’s most recent designs violate every one.

“Good design is honest.” – D. Rams

Apple’s use of a tape machine in the interface for its Podcasts app is a great example of how to fail at this guideline. A reel-to-reel tape machine is totally unrelated to any podcast production process, almost all of which are recorded to digital media instead of analog tape. A reel-to-reel tape machine is also unrelated to broadcast radio, the media that I would argue podcasts are most similar to.

Creating and distributing podcasts never uses analog tape, calling into question the honesty of this interface cue.

“Good design makes a product useful.” – D. Rams

The Podcasts app’s tape machine does convey “state of system” information when the reels spin, but not in a particularly strong way. It can be easy to miss the differences in their spin speed.

The tape-machine metaphor will also be meaningless to anyone unfamiliar with tape machines, in which case it will just be wasted space on an already-cramped iPhone screen. Both of these problems suggest the space the tape machine occupies could have been better spent on another interface cue.

“Good design is long lasting.” – D. Rams

I’m 29 years old. Though my father has always been a music hobbyist, and a well-equipped one at that, at no point in my life was there ever a reel-to-reel player in my home. I understand the system, but I’ve never had first-hand experience with one.

In fact, very few people my age or younger could say they have. Even among recording studios, only the choosiest engineers even use reel-to-reel tape recorders, due to the cost and difficulty of maintaining one. As time goes on, fewer and fewer people will have experience with the technology that informs Apple’s metaphor.

ical skeuomorphic apple designThe tape-machine metaphor will only become increasingly outdated. Ditto the “bookshelves” in iBooks and the leather stitching in iCal. As these real-life analogs to Apple’s skeuomorphs become less prevalent, these metaphors will be less and less useful to users.

“Good design makes a product understandable.” – D. Rams

Inappropriate skeuomorphs can cause more problems than they solve. Take the “ragged pages” design cue in Apple’s iCal, which mimics a paper calendar.

On a paper calendar, you tear off last week’s page at the beginning of each new week, then toss it in the garbage or recycling.

This is very misleading in a digital environment. You won’t find the pages that iCal “tears off” in OS X’s “trash,” as you may expect. Instead, the pages are retained for later use. In this way, the “ragged pages” skeuomorph implies more limited functionality than iCal actually offers, and misleads the user as to their own ability within the system.

“Good design is unobtrusive.” – D. Rams

Examine the use of screen space in an application like iBooks, and you will realize that skeuomorphs can be very obtrusive. In iBooks on the iPad, a significant proportion of available screen space is wasted on page and page-margin design cues — and this on a device which already has an additional “margin” (bezel) surrounding the screen in every direction.

“Good design is environmentally friendly.” – D. Rams

Clearly, there is little real-world environmental impact from Apple’s use of a leather-stitching design cue in iCal. There is, however, impact to one’s virtual environment.

Bad skeuomorphs pollute our digital environments in the same way that a jackhammer disrupts the austerity of an otherwise serene neighborhood. They are like nails on a chalkboard to many designers: extremely distracting and impossible to miss.

Skeuomorphic pollution is so great in some cases that writing a column on the subject is sometimes all we can do.

“Good design is as little design as possible.” – D. Rams

Good design is accomplished more often by subtraction than by addition. There is no interaction-related reason to add skeuomorphs to an interface. If skeuomorphs do not help the user accomplish their goals, then they are more design than is necessary, and should be omitted.

“Good designs are innovative.” – D. Rams

There is nothing innovative about applying (or, just as often, mis-applying) the metaphor of a real-world object to a virtual system.

ibookshelf apple ipad app skeumorphicWhere is the innovation in a “bookshelf metaphor” for iBooks? Virtually every e-reader includes such an interface these days. Is the bookshelf a significant improvement over selecting a book from a list by title? I’d argue that the latter is often preferable, considering how “you can’t judge a book by its cover.”

“Good design is thorough down to the last detail.” – D. Rams

With such wide-ranging critiques against the use of skeuomorphs in software, it is easy to make a case that skeuomorphic interfaces do not result from “thorough” processes considerate of every “last detail.”

Why we can’t have nice things

Of course, that was only nine commandments. Traditionally, lists of “commandments” include ten items. Unfortunately, Rams’ last directive doesn’t help my case against skeuomorphs:

“Good design is aesthetic.” – D. Rams

Paraphrasing Rams further: Well-executed objects can be beautiful and can positively affect our environments.

This is the only way that skeuomorphs can be excused — many users simply prefer interfaces that are lousy with skeuomorphic garbage.

This was Alex Lindsay’s experience in his “previous life” as an interface designer. When the July 23rd MacBreak Weekly turned to criticism of Apple’s skeuomorphs, Lindsay cited the following anecdote:

We showed target audiences … an interface that looked like you could touch it, and it was a real thing — and then one that was all text and much more … not quite Windows 8, but very similar to that look. It was like eight out of ten wanted the one with pictures. … You can decide whether eight out of ten people have bad taste, but I’m just saying, from a pure consumer perspective: we did a ton of testing on it, and it was clear. It wasn’t close.

So, if you’re wondering why we can’t have nice things — eight out of ten people are the reason why. But, eight out of ten people don’t make a good design. People like Dieter Rams do.

Dieter Rams wouldn’t want skeuomorphs in his interface designs. Maybe that means we shouldn’t either.

The views expressed here are solely those of the author and do not reflect the beliefs of Digital Trends.

Product Review

We can’t find a reason to buy the Porsche Design Mate 20 RS over the Mate 20 Pro

The Huawei Mate 20 Pro looks like an exceptional phone, so can a version with Porsche Design’s involvement be worth spending twice as much on? We’ve taken the phone for a test drive.
Smart Home

Think inside the box with these tricked-out shipping container homes

Believe it or not, but sustainability can be sexy. These 30 shipping container homes mesh recycled steel with a wealth of different materials, culminating in a set of spectacular homes that showcase modern design at its finest.

Keep Notes is the latest app to get Google’s Material Design makeover

Google is updating more and more of its apps to come into line with its latest Material Design trends, and now it's Keep Notes' turn to get a new pair of pants. This update is now rolling out on Android devices.

Find out how to keep tabs on your phone with these helpful tracking tips

Need to keep tabs on the location of your cell phone or smartphone? Consult this guide for tips and tricks on how to track a phone, whether you're currently rocking Android, iOS, or something more old-school.

Declutter your life with our favorite wireless chargers for Android and iPhones

We checked out the best wireless phone chargers to make tangles and uncooperative ports a thing of the past. Whether you have an iPhone or Android, find out which wireless charging pads are worth buying, and how their features compare.

Save up to $900 with the best smartphone deals for October 2018

Need a better phone but don't want to spend a fortune? It's never a bad time to score a new smartphone and save some cash. We rounded up the best smartphone deals available that can save you as much as $900.
Product Review

With both style and substance, the ‘budget’ iPhone XR is the iPhone to buy

Apple’s iPhone XS and XS Max are flagship smartphones that do everything and anything. The iPhone XR is more interesting, because while it looks as futuristic as its siblings, it’s also less expensive and more stylish.

eBay’s new Instant Selling program turns old smartphones into new money

With eBay's new Instant Selling program, selling your smartphone just got easier. Immediately after listing your device, you'll receive a voucher that can be used toward the purchase of a new phone through the site.

Motiv smart ring can use your walking pattern to unlock online accounts

Remember Motiv's activity tracking smart ring? It's back with a raft of new features that adds biometric identification and token authentication, all on a device that fits on your finger.

Misfit's new Vapor 2 packs built-in GPS, NFC chip into a sleek smartwatch

Misfitlaunched its latest smartwatch in the Vapor lineup, the Misfit Vapor 2. The smartwatch comes with improved heart rate tracking, built-in GPS, runs Google's latest version of Wear OS, and more. Here's everything you need to know.

Safeguard your new Apple smartphone with one of our favorite iPhone XS cases

If the iPhone XS is your next device, then you’ll want to shop for some proper protection now. That glass sandwich design is all too easy to scratch or crack, so make sure you snag one of the best iPhone XS cases to keep it looking good.

A canceled education order is increasing hopes for new Macbook model

With Apple's October 30 event fast approaching, rumors continue to surface about new Macs and iPad models. In the latest news, a canceled education order is stoking hopes for a new MacBook model.

Apple's iOS 12.1 update will include a fix for iPhone XS, XR selfies

After months of betas, the final version of iOS 12 is here to download. The latest OS comes along with tons of new capabilities, from grouped notifications to Siri Shortcuts. Here are all the features you'll find in iOS 12.

Apple could show off a new iPad Mini and AirPower charger at October event

Apple's sprung a surprise event on us, even though this year has seen loads of new Apple releases. So what's left to come? Quite a lot as it turns out. Here's what to expect from Apple's October 30 event.