Warrant Confirms Editor Could Face Felony Charges over iPhone Prototype

New details continue to emerge regarding the “lost” iPhone 4G phone that Gizmodo purchased and exposed in April. We knew that Apple was not pleased, especially when they whispered into the ear of the Silicon-Valley-based sheriff’s department, but the release of the search warrant issued confirms just how deep the legal ramifications go. The warrant, obtained by Scribd, confirms that the iPhone is being treated as stolen, the purchase of the phone is being considered the purchase of stolen goods, and the shape the iPhone was returned to Apple in is being treated as a case of malicious damage.warrant confirms editor could face felony charges over iphone prototype 4g giz 1

Most of this we suspected when the San Mateo County Sheriffs kicked in the door of Gizmodo editor Jason Chen’s house, but this confirms the extent of severity that Apple and the police are pushing for. Chen has been questioned by police, but he has not been charged yet. Those charges may soon be coming though, as all of the charges being investigated as part of the search warrant are felonies.  Although the search warrant is specifically for Chen, it also paints a darker picture for Brian Hogan, the man that found and sold the phone.

The search warrant is specifically investigating Chen for the following crimes:

“Buy or receive stolen property; Theft-Without authority make or cause to be made a copy (definition includes photography) of any article representing a trade secret; Maliciously damages property of another valued over $400”.

Each crime is a felony in California.

The warrant outlines the investigation by Matthew Broad, a San Mateo County Sheriff detective, and a member of the Rapid Enforcement Allied Computer Team (REACT). Broad confirms that he met with Apple representatives on April 20th, the day after Gizmodo posted the story of the iPhone prototype.

The Apple reps confirmed that Robert “Gray” Powell lost the prototype phone on March 25th. The phone soon appeared on Gizmodo, and the Apple reps claimed that the release of the prototype information would hurt current sales of the iPhone, as customers would wait for the newer model and spurn the current generation of phone, “thereby hurting overall sales and negatively effecting Apple’s earnings.” Apple reps could not give an exact estimate of losses, but they stated that the numbers would be “huge.”

When asked about the monetary value of the iPhone, Apple reps stated that it was invaluable, but it was at least worth the $8,500 to $10,000 that Hogan sold it for. Originally, the dollar figure was reported to be $5,000, but it appears Gizmodo promised Hogan an additional $3,500 once Apple officially announced the phone, and possibly a further $2,500 bonus, although no one is sure what that money is for or when it would be paid.

The report then explains how Apple discovered Hogan’s involvement. On the April 19, Hogan’s roommate, Katherine Martinson, called Apple and told them that Hogan had sold the phone to Gizmodo. Martinson said that she believed that Hogan had connected the phone to her computer without her authorization, and she wanted to absolve herself of criminal responsibility. This may be damning to Hogan, as it confirms that at least one person let him know that the device was stolen and that there could be severe legal repercussions.

Broad confirms that Hogan found the iPhone in the bar that Powell left it. The story also confirms that a bar patron handed Hogan the phone, thinking it was his. Hogan then stayed for a bit at the bar before returning home with the phone.

Hogan returned home and told Martinson that he was able to briefly connect to the iPhone, and that he learned that the phone belonged to Gray Powell. The software was then remotely wiped by Apple, and Hogan removed the 3G case and realized that it was not a typical iPhone. Martinson claims that Hogan is technically proficient, and he soon suspected that the phone was a prototype, due to the new features such as the forward-facing camera. He then attempted to connect the phone to Martinson’s computer in order to reload an OS and make the phone work again, but he was unsuccessful.

Hogan then searched for Powell online and discovered through LinkedIn that Powell was an engineer at Apple. He finally realized exactly what he had, and he knew the value of the phone.

He then contacted Gizmodo, PC World, and Engadget in an attempt to start a bidding war. Hogan knew that the publication of the iPhone details would generate hits to the website of whoever won the bidding war, and within 10 days, Chen had offered Hogan $10,000 for the phone. Gizmodo would pay $5,000 on delivery, with another $3,500 paid once Apple officially announced the phone. No one is sure about the conditions attached to the remaining $2,500.

Hogan has since apologized for his actions, and claims that he regrets not doing more to return the phone. This apology rings a bit hollow, as Martinson confirms that she, and others tried to convince Hogan to return the phone because the sale could ruin Powell’s career. According to the documents, Hogan responded, “Sucks for him. He lost his phone. Shouldn’t have lost his phone.”

In interviews with Powell, the Apple engineer says that he recalled placing the phone in his bag, but the bag was knocked over a few times in the busy bar and that the phone likely fell out. He also says that it was possible, although unlikely that someone took the phone from his bag.

When Broad went to Hogan’s house, he told Hogan that he was not yet being charged, and that it was imperative that Hogan cooperated and that any attempt to destroy evidence would be an obstruction of justice and Hogan would immediately be arrested. Hogan then confirmed that Thomas Werner, Hogan’s roommate, had taken his computer, a flash drive with evidence, and Apple stickers from the prototype phone, and left the house. Hogan called Werner, who eventually confirmed that the laptop was at a local church. Officers seized the laptop, but the flash drive has yet to turn up. As for the stickers, Werner claimed to have lost them at a local gas station. Broad searched the station and recovered the stickers. Broad believes that Werner is also culpable for the iPhone theft and subsequent sale, but again, no charges have been filed.

The search warrant more or less confirms the information we have been hearing for weeks now, but it is telling to see Hogan’s role in all of this, especially the fact that he may have known exactly what he was doing, and did it anyway.

Last week a second iPhone prototype may have turned up on the Web, this time in Vietnam. No word yet on where this phone came from. Some are suggesting that it is a Chinese knock-off, but the stickers and serial codes seem to suggest it is real.


Google is buying mysterious smartwatch tech from The Fossil Group for $40 million

Google is about to step up its smartwatch game. The company has agreed to buy an unnamed smartwatch technology from The Fossil Group for a hefty $40 million. Considering the acquisition, it's clear Google is serious about smartwatches.

Join the Apple club with our complete guide to switching from Android to iOS

If Android simply isn’t cutting it for you anymore, then you might be considering Apple’s warm embrace. Here’s how to make the switch from Android to iOS without losing your contacts, sleep, or hair!

Benchmark scores surface for Google's midrange Pixel 3 XL Lite

The Google Pixel 3 and Pixel 3 XL are considered to be two of the best Android smartphones, but it looks like Google could be prepping a midrange line. Say hello to the Pixel 3 Lite and Pixel 3 Lite XL.

Reluctant to give your email address away? Here's how to make a disposable one

Want to sign up for a service without the risk of flooding your inbox with copious amounts of spam and unwanted email? You might want to consider using disposable email addresses via one of these handy services.

The iPhone XS Battery Case's battery has a smaller capacity than previous cases

Apple has been rumored to be working on a new iPhone battery case for the iPhone XS, iPhone XS Max, and iPhone XR. Now, those new cases are finally here, offering seven hours of extra use for each iPhone and are available for $129.

It’s back! Here’s how to switch to Twitter’s reverse chronological feed

Twitter has finally brought back the reverse chronological feed, allowing you to see your feed based on the newest tweets, rather than using Twitter's algorithm that shows what it thinks you want to see. It's easy to switch.

Want more power, but faster? This new charging tech claims it can deliver

Chunky power bricks and slow charging could be a thing of the past with GaNFast technology from Navitas Semiconductors. By using an alternative to silicon, GaNFast reduces power consumption and boosts output.

Having trouble logging in? Here's how to reset your Apple ID password

To use any of Apple's services, you need to have an Apple ID and know your password. Thankfully, there are ways to deal with forgotten passwords and regain access to your account. Here's how to reset your Apple ID password.

Turn to these apps to help you in your next hunt for a job

Looking for a job can be a stressful experience, but these days, a simple mobile app can help you to find and apply for jobs all over the country -- here are some of the best job search apps for iOS and Android.

Omron HeartGuide brings blood pressure monitoring to your wrist

High blood pressure leads to heart attacks, strokes, and many other health problems, so it's important to keep an eye on. Omron's HeartGuide is a fitness tracking watch that can also monitor your blood pressure from your wrist.

Learn how to play YouTube in the background on iOS and Android

We show you how to play YouTube in the background with apps such as Opera, Chrome, and Firefox -- along with the premium offerings like YouTube Premium -- whether you have an Android or iOS device.

Android vs. iOS: Which smartphone platform is the best?

If you’re trying to choose a new phone and you’re not sure about the merits and pitfalls of the leading smartphone operating systems, then come on in for a detailed breakdown as we pit Android vs. iOS in various categories.

Verizon’s deal could get you a free iPhone XR — but there’s some fine print

Verizon launched a new deal for its smartphones aimed at encouraging customers to open a new line. If you're willing and you want two new phones, you could get a free Samsung Galaxy S9, iPhone XR, or Pixel 3.

Keep your laptop battery in tip-top condition with these handy tips

Learn how to care for your laptop's battery, how it works, and what you can do to make sure yours last for years and retains its charge. Check out our handy guide for valuable tips, no matter what type of laptop you have.