Active vs. passive 3D TV technology: What’s the difference?

Kid active 3d glasses

TV makers are introducing 3D HDTVs at a fast and furious clip. For example, Panasonic has 14 new ones, Vizio five, LG seven…the numbers keep piling up. Screen sizes range from 32- to 70-inches, and there are enough features and price variations to make your head spin. We’ll leave those specifics for another day. What we want to address is the issue of the 3D technologies you’ll encounter as you don your glasses and gaze at the infamous wall of flat panel TVs at the local store.

The practical difference

Active and passive 3D technology are two rival systems for accomplishing 3D effects, both competing for your money. We’ll get into the mechanics shortly, but the key differences are the 3D glasses supplied with each type of set. Passive glasses are similar to ones handed out at the movies: They’re light, cheap and do not require any power. LG, for example, includes four pair with its new models, such as the recently reviewed the 47LW5600. We reported the 3D experience was quite good, and the price for the 3D eyewear is definitely right.

LG passive 3d glassesLG passive 3D glasses

Active 3D glasses are bulkier, heavier, require battery power and cost a lot more than their passive counterparts. Typically, one or two pairs are supplied with a new 3D TV, while additional glasses cost anywhere from $50 to $179 per pair. Want to invite a bunch of friends over to watch Tron in 3D? Get ready to spend. That said, the quality is better, with much finer detail and the extensive sense of depth one expects from 3D HDTV.

Sony active 3D glassesSony active 3D glasses

How they work

Active 3D HDTV, which uses active shutter glasses, is a sequential system. All 1080 lines of resolution are beamed from the TV display panel to your eyes. An infrared signal paired to the supplied eyewear opens and closes the left and right lenses of the glasses at a very rapid rate, hence the term active shutter. Your brain perceives these fast-moving alternating frames as 3D. The important fact to note is the amount of resolution – 1080 lines. Active models are often labeled Full HD 3D.

The vast majority of passive 3D HDTVs use panels are supplied by LG Display, which operate on Film Patterned Retarder (FPR) technology. The 3D effect is created when the set’s left and right images are viewed with polarized glasses. Instead of active’s sequential frames, it’s an odd/even system and resolution drops to 540 lines to each eye, but you perceive high-def 3D. The glasses do not have to turn on and off; they just rest there “passively.” That’s why they’re so cheap, light and in our view, more comfortable. The system works well, and besides the fact quality isn’t as good as a top-tier active shutter HDTV, they are less forgiving in terms of placement; you really have to be at eye level for the best 3D effect.

What do they look like?

We recently sat through a side-by-side comparison of a new Panasonic plasma using the active system versus a passive 6500 series LG 3D LED LCD HDTV. The difference was dramatic as the detail and effects of the Panasonic looked far crisper and more realistic. A still image was shown of a guitar on both screens. The strings on the LG had jagged edges, and turned into double lines as you stood up and moved off center. The Panasonic held rock steady. We know this is not a true apples-to-apples comparison as plasmas use a faster self-illuminating technology that’s far more responsive than any LCD on the market. This speed is the reason plasma 3D effects have less blur and crosstalk, which you see as double images on the screen. Competitors readily admit plasma has an inherent advantage over LCD because of this faster response time. So if you’re looking for the absolute best quality in 3D as well as 2D, plasma is the way to go. They also admit plasma doesn’t lend itself to passive technology—it’s too difficult and expensive to implement.

panasonic 3d tv family

The price of perfection

Now the price-versus-quality debate begins. Take a look at that wall of 3D HDTVs and check out new passive models from LG and Vizio. We gave the passive LG 47LW5600 an Editor’s Choice award because the 3D quality is very good, the price is right while the glasses are inexpensive and light. We have absolutely no problem recommending them. And yet active shutter 3D is better, especially on a plasma display. Those in the active shutter camp well know the sticker shock consumers face dealing with the cost of eyewear. That’s why Samsung recently dropped the price of its basic glasses to around $50, plus many of its sets come with two pair of active shutter glasses. You can expect similar price drops from other makers as the year progresses. Competition is a wonderful thing!

See for yourself

It’s hard to make sweeping pronouncements once you start comparing one specific model to another, as features and prices vary greatly. And unless you’re a total video geek you won’t have active and passive 3D HDTVs sitting side-by-side in your house. We’ll get on our soapbox now — it’s absolutely imperative you do a glasses-on comparison of the two technologies, compare features and then find your best price. You might opt for Vizio’s Theater 3D, LG’s Cinema 3D (both passive with lighter eyewear), a Sharp Quattron LCD or Panasonic Viera plasma with active shutter glasses as your final choice. Join an online debate if you feel strongly one way or the other. As for us, it’s all good. We just wish there was more 3D content to watch…

Product Review

Bigger, louder, smarter: The new Echo Show is better in every way

The pressure was on to make a bigger, better Echo Show device, and Amazon delivered. Featuring a larger screen and better sound, the new Show is a combined smart speaker, TV, and overall entertainment center in one.
Movies & TV

'Prime'-time TV: Here are the best shows on Amazon Prime right now

Amazon Prime brings more perks than just free two-day shipping. Subscribers get access to a huge library of TV shows to stream at no extra cost. Here are our favorite TV shows currently available on Amazon Prime.
Home Theater

Google Chromecast and Chromecast Ultra: Everything you need to know

Google's Chromecast plugs into your TV's HDMI port, allowing you to stream content from your tablet, laptop, or smartphone directly to your TV. Here's what you need to know about all iterations, including the 4K-ready Chromecast Ultra.
Home Theater

TV calibration 101: Here's how to tune up the picture of your new TV

You’ve got your new TV out of the box, but now what? Our TV picture adjustment guide takes you through the simple steps to get the best picture from your brand new TV so you can set it and forget it.
Mobile

Keep the iPhone XS display crack-free with these screen protectors

Apple might have proclaimed the iPhone XS's glass as being its most durable ever, but that's not going to stop you from wincing if you drop your phone. Stay protected with the best iPhone XS screen protectors.
Mobile

Apple iPhone XS Max vs. Huawei P20 Pro: Clash of the titans

Anyone seeking a great new smartphone with plenty of money to spend has two amazing options, but which is better for you? We pit the Apple iPhone XS Max vs. Huawei P20 Pro in various categories to help you choose.
Emerging Tech

From flying for fun to pro filmmaking, these are the best drones you can buy

In just the past few years, drones have transformed from a geeky hobbyist affair to a full-on cultural phenomenon. Here's a no-nonsense rundown of the best drones you can buy right now, no matter what kind of flying you plan to do.
Computing

Gaming on a laptop has never been better. These are your best options

Gaming desktops are powerful, but they tie you down to your desk. For those of us who prefer a more mobile experience, here are the best gaming laptops on the market, ranging from budget machines to maxed-out, wallet-emptying PCs.
Photography

When you're ready to shoot seriously, these are the best DSLRs you can buy

For many photographers the DSLR is the go-to camera. With large selection of lenses, great low-light performance, and battery endurance, these DSLRs deliver terrific image quality for stills and videos.
Smart Home

Put away that sponge and let us help you pick the best dishwasher for your buck

Tired of doing dishes by hand? Take a look at our picks of the four best dishwashers currently available and let a machine do the dirty work for you. They’ll do a much better job, anyway.
Music

The best new music this week: Prince, Brockhampton, Mountain Man, and more

Are you looking for the best new music? Each week, we scour the internet to find the most compelling new releases. On tap this week: Prince, Richard Swift, Christine and the Queens, Brockhampton, and Mountain Man.
Photography

The best mirrorless cameras pack all the power of a DSLR, minus the bulk

Mirrorless cameras offer a lot of photography firepower, inside a compact body. Explore the best mirrorless cameras, from the pro-level to the beginner-friendly shooters, in this guide.
Computing

Tired of choosing between Windows and Mac? Check out these Chromebooks instead

We've compiled a list of the best Chromebooks -- laptops that combine great battery life, comfortable keyboards, and the performance it takes to run Google's lightweight Chrome OS. From Samsung to Acer, these are the Chromebooks that really…
Computing

What's the best laptop? We've reviewed a lot of them, and this is our answer

The best laptop should be one that checks all the boxes: Great battery life, beautiful design, and top-notch performance. The laptops we've chosen for our best laptops you can buy do all that — and throw in some extra features while…