2019 BMW X5 xDrive40i first drive review

With the new X5, BMW is back to building Ultimate Driving Machines

The X5 joins a growing list of new BMWs resurrecting the once-lost ultimate driving experience.
The X5 joins a growing list of new BMWs resurrecting the once-lost ultimate driving experience.
The X5 joins a growing list of new BMWs resurrecting the once-lost ultimate driving experience.


  • Incredible driving dynamics for something so big and heavy
  • Significantly more refined than outgoing model
  • The ultimate driving experience returns
  • Surprising off-road capability when properly equipped
  • A powertrain you can’t help but love


  • Eye-watering price when loaded
  • Interior controls took a slight step backwards
  • Run-flat tires still don’t do favors for ride quality

If you were to guess what BMW’s best-selling model is, which one would you nominate? The 3 Series? Nope. The 5 Series or 7 Series? Not those either. What about the M3 or the M5? Not even close. Despite being the first cars to come to mind when you think of BMW, they are far from the best-selling ones.

If you guessed the X5 you’d be correct, though BMW representatives say the top-seller award changes hands between the X3 and the X5. We already reviewed and fell in love with the latest X3. The all-new fourth generation X5 is next on BMW’s launch list for the 2019 model year. We had a chance to get our first impressions of BMW’s latest sports activity vehicle in Atlanta recently.

With its $60,700 starting price, the X5 can be cross-shopped with quite a few alternatives. The traditional battle continues with the newly-reworked Mercedes-Benz GLE and the upper tiers of the Audi Q7. But that $3,000 hike over the outgoing X5 makes the competition – the Acura MDX, Land Rover Discovery, Infiniti QX60, Jaguar F-Pace, Cadillac XT5, Lexus RX, Volvo XC90, and Range Rover Velar – look way more value-driven than ever before.

Opt for the far pricier $75,750 V8 model and you’ll find yourself on the same battleground as the Range Rover Sport, Maserati Levante, Porsche Cayenne, and even the full-size Mercedes-Benz GLS. You can’t forget the Jeep Grand Cherokee SRT8 or Trackhawk Edition if performance SUVs are your thing.

Interior and tech

Immediately after entering the new X5, one is greeted by an interior that’s far plusher and more luxurious than the one in the outgoing car. The overall design of the dashboard and interior represents an evolutionary move forward rather than a revolutionary one thanks to the driver-oriented dash, which is a BMW interior design tradition.

Being BMW’s largest crossover available, until the new X7 comes out, the X5 boasts the usual and comfortable interior for five adults found on previous X5s. And while the X5’s trunk offers plenty of space for stuff with 73 cu. ft. of cargo volume, we can’t imagine it being comfortable for full-size adults when BMW introduces the option for a third row of seating later in the production cycle.

Chris Chin/Digital Trends

The number of buttons is also kept to a surprising minimum, especially considering the reputation German automakers have of cramming in way too many of them to compensate for all the tech. However, we wish the HVAC temperature controls were still dials because they were much easier to use than the rocker buttons that replaced them. And the crystal gear shifter screams “Volvo copycat” a little too loudly. Those are minor quibbles for what’s otherwise a well-designed interior. And with a car that sells as well as the X5, it’s better not to fix what isn’t broken.

But that doesn’t mean the 2019 X5 is shy on technology, because it isn’t. All of the X5’s gizmos and functions are primarily managed by iDrive.

After entering the new X5, one is greeted by a far plusher and more luxurious interior than the outgoing car’s.

The latest iteration features BMW’s Live Cockpit Professional technology, which is a dual high-resolution 12.3-inch infotainment system and digital instrument display. It unsurprisingly mimics the twin-screen system found in Mercedes-badged rivals. It’s controlled via the traditional dial selector with haptic and touch-sensitive controls and BMW’s gesture-control technology that first arrived on the 5 and 7 Series.

If you’ve been acquainted with BMW’s iDrive system over the past decade or so, the 2019 X5 won’t feel like distant territory. Rather, it feels similar but more refined than in previous generations. There are still some quirks: some menu options and locations can feel redundant and misplaced. And, if you’re a New Yorker/New Jerseyan who likes to talk with their hands, BMW’s gesture control technology can actually get rather annoying. Ask us how we know.

2019 bmw x5 xdrive40i

With the new X5, BMW also rolls out its latest BMW Connected software, the company’s customer-experience-driven application and connectivity suite that basically serves as your vehicular butler. It can connect to Apple and Android devices thanks to apps available in the app store and pairing capabilities with Alexa and Google Home devices. When connected—no pun intended—the system performs some neat features, like finding the best route for your morning commute to circumvent traffic. Eventually, BMW hopes to roll out real-time parking information for dense metro areas.

The 2019 X5 comes standard with a suite of driving aids including blind-spot detection, lane-keep assist, rear- and front-cross-traffic alerts, and pedestrian detection with automatic braking. BMW groups these features under the name Active Driving Assistant. Most competitors offer similar technology.

Unfortunately, we do miss out on a few cool features bespoke to European models. The optional display key found on the 5 and 7 Series cars isn’t available on the U.S.-bound X5s. And we also don’t get the company’s trick Sky Lounge panoramic moonroof, which lights up like a Christmas tree with LEDs featuring a variety of hues.

Driving experience

If you were expecting a disappointing review of another BMW that just doesn’t seem to drive like it used to, we’re actually happy to report the opposite. Now, imagine meeting a straight-faced German in the workspace who seems to take things too seriously. But then, said person unexpectedly takes you on a thrilling skydiving trip, while still wearing a suit. That pretty much sums up the persona of the X5.

Our tester came with the lovely 3.0-liter, turbocharged straight-six engine, tuned to 340 horsepower and 332 pound-feet of torque and bolted to a ZF-sourced eight-speed automatic. The drivetrain left us with no complaints in the performance department, with BMW claiming a 0-62 mph time of just 5.5 seconds.

If you were expecting another disappointing review of a BMW, we’re actually happy to report the opposite.

This time around, all X5s come with an electronically-controlled adaptive suspension and offer the option of a pneumatic air setup which is part of the off-road package — we’ll get to that in a second. Like other models sporting the Roundel emblem, the X5 places road-going handling and stability above all. Cruising on the interstate at highway speeds makes you feel like you’re only experiencing an iota of the X5’s potential.

BMW’s clever navigation system with real-time traffic information rerouted us around Atlanta’s terrible morning rush. We found ourselves traversing the hills just south of Chattahoochee National Forest. Once on the swoopy bits, the X5 felt athletic and brutish with plenty of forward grunt on the straights. If the turbo-six is more than adequate, we can’t imagine how much more we’d be grinning with the turbo-eight under the hood.

2019 bmw x5 xdrive40i headlight

BMW always pitched the X5 as a road-biased crossover SUV. That was made obvious throughout the years as we tested X5s in conditions normally suited for a Range Rover, where it often failed. When the X5 was conceived, BMW owned Land Rover and feared making its SUV more capable off-road would create internal competition. That’s no longer the case, and the X5 is no longer confined to paved surfaces. The off-road package adds an air suspension that unlocks an adjustable ride height. In this configuration, the X5 exhibited a level of off-road prowess that we were simply not expecting, especially considering its road-biased, run-flat Pirelli tires. Through a heavily-forested off-road trail better suited for a Jeep Wrangler, BMW’s test drivers took us on a loop that involved a lot of hill ascending and descending in damp and somewhat muddy conditions.

When it came to creeping around tight corners with raised obstacles — such as large rocks or tree stumps — the X5’s 360-degree camera system went straight to work, pulling up exterior views of the car on the center display, depending on where the obstacle was located. There’s also a gyroscope and other directional information, all apart of the off-road package to improve visual maneuverability.

Owners of these fancy SUVs are unlikely to drive through such conditions. But it’s comforting to know the capability is there, just as much as the road-going ultimate driving experience.


All BMWs come with a four-year, 50,000-mile warranty for everything, including the engine and transmission. BMW placed eighth in the 2018 J.D. Power Vehicle Dependability Study, tied above Toyota with 127 problems per 100 vehicles manufactured new. That’s down one place from last year’s survey.

BMWs in general have a reputation for being reliable and dependable under warranty and when cared for punctually. If you plan to own and drive the vehicle past its warranty period, we advise extending the factory policy as BMW parts and dealer shop labor rates are known to be quite wallet-busting for the average person.

How DT would configure this car

If money was no object, we’d probably spring for the V8 model since, well, who doesn’t love lots of go-power, especially in a BMW. Though from just testing the six-cylinder base model, it’s more than adequate, even for the power-hungry, thanks to its superb tuning. Because of it proportions and its status a luxury crossover, we’d take it with all the bells and whistles since there’s a lot of tech to enjoy in the X5.

If money was no object, we’d probably spring for the V8 model.

Keep this in mind: The fully-loaded, six-cylinder-powered 2019 we tested in Atlanta costs an eye-watering $80,230. That’s over $5,000 above the V8 model’s starting figure, which means you’ll have some hard decisions to make. Particularly since we can’t imagine the V8 model being modestly equipped.

We could probably do without the X5’s off-road package, unless we decided to make camping out in the wilderness a frequent experience or lived in an area where road maintenance is questionable. Though we’d have to try one without the air suspension to be certain because the X5 already comes with an adaptive suspension. At that price point, however, if off-roading is a priority we suggest looking at the Range Rover Sport, Lexus’ GX and LX, and the incredibly capable Porsche Cayenne.


All of the automakers competing in this segment have a solid foundation on which to make a great luxury crossover that strikes an excellent balance between versatility, practicality, comfort, and performance. But with BMW’s latest, the X5 proves that it can push the envelope even further and become one of the go-to luxury SUVs, especially for buyers who like performance and handling. Just be ready to part with a sizeable chunk of change for it.

More so, the X5 joins a growing list of new BMWs that exhibit a proper return to the brand’s heyday of making the ultimate driving machines. To that, we tip our hats and say “well done, BMW.”

Product Review

Mercedes-Benz updates the timeless G-wagen for the modern world

For decades, the G-Class has been an outlier in the Mercedes-Benz portfolio, a body-on-frame brute with the soul – and driving manners – of an off-road pickup. With the all-new G550, Mercedes seeks to smooth out some of the rough edges.

From DSLRs to mirrorless, these are the best cameras you can buy right now

From entry-level models to full-frame flagships, many cameras take great photos and video. The best digital cameras, however, push the industry forward with innovative sensors and improved usability, among other things. Here are our…
Smart Home

Let a robot do your chores! Here are the best robot vacuums for 2019

Robot vacuums are a convenient way to tidy up your home and minimize your weekly to-do list. From a top-of-the-line model to a handy budget option, here are the best robot vacuums you can buy right now.

BMW’s X3 M and X4 M pack 503 horsepower in nontraditional form

BMW is starting even further from its heritage with the 2020 X3 M and X4 M performance crossovers. But with up to 503 horsepower available in each vehicle, does that really matter?

The Polestar 2, Sweden’s answer to the Tesla Model 3, begins taking shape

Volvo sister company Polestar has released a teaser image to give us our first look at the 2, its second model. Polestar tells us the 2 will arrive as a four-door fastback with a 400-hp electric powertrain and about 300 miles of range.

2020 Kia Soul and Soul EV continue to think inside the box

The 2020 Kia Soul is the third generation of Kia's boxy curiosity. The Soul maintains its signature look, but gets tech and powertrain upgrades. The all-electric Soul EV returns as well.
Emerging Tech

Awesome Tech You Can’t Buy Yet: Grow veggies indoors and shower more efficiently

Check out our roundup of the best new crowdfunding projects and product announcements that hit the web this week. You may not be able to buy this stuff yet, but it sure is fun to gawk!

Psychedelic Volkswagen Microbus from Woodstock returns for an encore

With its trippy paint scheme, the Volkswagen "Light" bus became a symbol of the 1969 Woodstock music festival. VW teamed up with the artist who created this rolling mural to stage a comeback in time for Woodstock's 50th anniversary.

Amazon plugs in with $700 million investment in electric pickup company Rivian

Amazon invested $700 million for a minority stake in U.S. all-electric truck maker Rivian, according to a joint release. The announcement follows a Reuters report that GM and Amazon might invest $1 billion to $2 billion in the company.

2019 RAM 1500 Classic Warlock special edition: Badass style without the whoop

If you like the looks of blacked-out badass trucks without the cost of a desert racer, FCA announced the 2019 Ram 1500 Classic Warlock, a special edition pickup that focuses on appearance with only a touch of additional off-road capability.

2020 GMC Acadia toughens up on the outside, gets smarter on the inside

The 2020 GMC Acadia crossover gets styling updates and a more rugged AT4 trim level. Under the skin, the Acadia sports a new turbocharged four-cylinder engine and a wider array of tech features.

Nissan is using old Leaf batteries to power and connect off-the-grid campers

Nissan has teamed up with trailer manufacturer Opus to design a mobile, weatherproof power pack built with battery cells sourced from the first-generation Leaf. Called Roam, the pack stores enough electricity to power a camper for up to a…

Alfa Romeo’s latest Ferrari-powered F1 race car is ready to hit the track

Alfa Romeo is doubling down on Formula One racing after a decades-long hiatus. Now essentially a support team for Ferrari, its 2019 driver lineup includes a former world champion and a potential future star.

Researchers teach self-driving cars to predict pedestrians’ next moves

University of Michigan researchers are developing a system that teaches self-driving cars to predict pedestrian movement. Humans don't always act in their own best self-interest, so autonomous cars will need to practice protective driving.