2011 Dodge Challenger SRT8 Review

2011 Dodge Challenger STR8 Review hood

Meat and brawn, physical dexterity, the chops to take you down in one swift move. No, we’re not talking about Vin Diesel from the Fast and Furious movies. The 2011 Dodge Challenger is out for serious blood against similar muscle cars from Detroit like the Ford Mustang and Chevy Camaro.

Driving an all-white V8 model for a week, we found a few perks that impressed us beyond what even the Mustang 302 and Camaro SS offer (we’ve tested both souped-up versions of those cars in the past six months, including closed-track tests). The Challenger’s styling is arguably more of a throwback to the days when Starsky and Hutch were household names, but still sports fun digital perks, like in-car options for measuring braking distance calculator and a 0-to-60 timer.

That said, the Challenger has some tough competition that’s priced a hair lower. The 470-horsepower V8 Hemi model we tested costs $44,000, but even the base version with a V6 costs $24,895. Meanwhile, the base model Ford Mustang, which still has a 305-horsepower V6 engine, costs $22,310. The 2012 Camaro Coupe costs $23,200. Dodge, you have your work cut out for you convincing us.

2011-Dodge-Challenger-STR8-rear-side-view

One early point of victory for the Challenger: we definitely prefer the starting block punch. In testing the Challenger V8 against the 302 and SS, the Dodge has some immediate urgency. There’s a real thrill in punching the sport mode button, squealing the tires, and gobbling up open roadway. In our tests, we achieved a best time of 4.6 seconds using the paddle shifters in sport mode with the traction control disabled. In the quarter mile, we hit 13.28 seconds at the flag, and ran the eighth-mile in 8.80 seconds. Those times are a bit under the rated specs that are just milliseconds lower. (Times are often dependent on the tires you use, the road you’re on, and the person doing the driving.)

The reason the Challenger felt more muscular off the block is that it has a 470-horsepower engine that delivers 470 lb-ft of torque, compared to the Camaro SS (420 lb-ft) and the Boss 302 (380 lb-ft). The Challenger has a lurching, burly drive – you feel every piston. This is not a German racing machine, so the gears shifts are more pronounced and even a bit jarring. Cornering on the Challenger is meant to be boxy and road-heavy in a good way, not at all like a Corvette that glides around curves.

Another major difference with the Challenger compared to the Mustang and Camaro: The styling is more like what you might remember from the 70s. There’s a decidedly classic-looking front end, with a smooth angular slope toward the back. Fortunately, even with this more reminiscent look, it was easy to see out of the Challenger, and we had plenty of headroom even with the sunroof door closed.

2011-Dodge-Challenger-STR8-right-side

Our test model came equipped with a powerful 900-watt amplifier and a Boston Acoustics 18-speaker stereo system. With that much audio power, you can crank up the subwoofer to a point where the whole car shakes with each beat. Unfortunately, the audio quality was not great – the stereo lacked the distinct tones of luxury cars like the Audi A8, where you can pick up specific parts of a song. Instead, you get volume and a bit too much distortion. We ended up thinking most of the music we played had power but lacked tonal distinction.

Our test car was also outfitted with a performance suspension. At $44,000, all of the trimmings put it in a class where we had to compare the Challenger directly with other performance cars, including the Boss 302 and the Camaro SS. We ended up preferring those cars, but for entirely different reasons. The Camaro has a hungrier growl, especially in idle and also when you rip into the upper gears. On a lonely country road, we the Camaro SS punched through third and fourth gear with more power.

The Boss 302 is a racing machine that’s (barely) street legal. We remember careening around corners at insanely high speeds and noting that the car barely flinched. The Challenger may be outfitted with a racing suspension, but in our experience the car felt a bit unsure on tight corners. That means, against the Boss, you might get to the first marker before anyone else, but you’ll lose on the first corner.

2011-Dodge-Challenger-STR8-steering-wheel

For fuel economy, the Challenger guzzles gas, but not quite as much as we expected. The 22MPG highway rating for the V8 is respectable, but around town we noted a 16MPG rating that meant we had to fill up twice in one week. The base-level Mustang gets 31MPG and the 302 gets 23MPG. The base level Camaro gets 30MPG, and the SS gets around 24MPG.

The Challenger is quite tight in the rear seats – passengers complained during a test drive almost constantly. There were a few other gripes as well: the trunk is unusually heavy, so kids who tried to open it had to struggle. We also had some trouble with music playback – an iPhone 4 stopped working with the stereo on one trip and we had to turn the car off, sit for a bit, and power on again.

When the Challenger just doesn’t perform as well as its Ford or Chevy competitors but costs more, you might wonder – who is the target market? For starters, it’s anyone who appreciates the classic design. Maybe it’s a car you even drove back in the day. A second prime customer: those who want to use the measurement tools, which are located right near the speedometer. We had a blast using them to test 0-to-60 acceleration, braking distance, and a quarter mile test. And there is the raw engine spec. The Challenger has more power and more torque, and if you want to make a statement in your neighborhood about who has the most muscle, this is the muscle car for you.

Also make sure to check out our 2011 Dodge Challenger STR8 photo gallery.

Product Review

Volvo’s redesigned 2019 S60 sedan is the best kind of remix

The 2019 Volvo S60 borrows almost everything from other recent Volvo models, but that’s not a problem. From its infotainment system to an available plug-in hybrid powertrain, the S60 takes the best bits from a lineup of great cars.
Cars

Bored with stock? The best tuner cars are begging to be modified

Modification has been around almost as long as the automobile itself. Here are 25 of the best tuner cars you can find, ranging from American muscle standouts to Japanese drift cars.
Cars

Hold on to your butts: These are the fastest cars in the world

Think your car is unbelievably fast? Think again. From wind-cheating bodywork to powerful engines, these cars were designed for the singular pursuit of speed (and it shows).
Cars

Watch this 1,000-horsepower Jeep Trackhawk scorch supercars in the quarter mile

The Jeep Grand Cherokee Trackhawk is pretty quick out of the box, but Texas tuner Hennessey Performance Engineering never settles for stock. Its HPE1200 Trackhawk boasts over 1,000 horsepower.
Cars

Room to roam: The supersized X7 is unlike any BMW you’ve ever seen

The first-ever BMW X7 is the 7 Series of the SUV world in terms of size, price, and image. Its supersized body has enough room for seven adult passengers and enough tech to impress even the most cutting-edge buyers.
Cars

'4WD' or 'AWD'? Which setup is right for you?

Although four-wheel drive (4WD) and all-wheel drive (AWD) are related, they are actually quite different in how they operate. Here, we talk about the fundamental differences between the two systems, and what it means for you as a driver.
Cars

Google Maps now shows EV owners the way to the nearest charging station

Google Maps now lets electric-car owners find the nearest charging station with ease. It's also added data on the number and types of ports available, charging speeds, and notes on the business where the station is located.
Cars

Heads up, George Jetson: Terrafugia starts taking orders for its flying car

The Terrafugia Transition flying car will go on sale next year, roughly a decade after the first prototype rolled out of its hangar. Terrafugia promises improvements, including a hybrid powertrain, to make up for the long wait.
Cars

At 503 mph, Turbinator II is the world’s fastest wheel-driven vehicle

The Turbinator II is a four-wheel drive streamliner powered by a 5,000-horsepower helicopter engine, and it just achieved 503.332 mph at the Bonneville Salt Flats. That's an unofficial record for a wheel-driven car.
Cars

Lyft has a new fixed-price subscription plan for frequent passengers

Lyft wants you to save money by using rideshare services instead of owning a car. The new Lyft All-Access Plan monthly rideshare trip subscription includes 30 rides a month with a small discount for additional trips.
Cars

Could the next Mazda3 boast a fuel-saving breakthrough in engine tech?

Mazda released a teaser video that likely previews the next Mazda3. Expected to make its global debut at the L.A. auto show, the next 3 will wear a more curvaceous design and offer one of the most advanced engines in the automotive…
Cars

Workhorse takes on diesel with lighter, cheaper NGEN-1000 electric delivery van

Ohio-based Workhorse Group claims its new NGEN-1000 electric delivery van costs the same as a conventional diesel van and can haul a similar amount of cargo. A lower curb weight makes this possible.
Product Review

Audi's new A8 is so sophisticated and serene, it practically deletes potholes

The 2019 Audi A8’s outline looks promising: Level 3 autonomous driving capability, haptic-feedback infotainment screens, rear-wheel steering, Matrix LED headlights and OLED taillights, plus a predictive suspension.
Cars

Forget transponders with Peasy’s nationwide pay-as-you-go toll service

Verra Mobility launched Peasy, a consumer highway and bridge toll payment service. Designed to be less hassle than managing traditional transponder or toll tag accounts, Peasy pays tolls as they are levied across most of the U.S.