Skip to main content

BMW has ‘M’ and ‘i’ brands and – stupidly – says never the twain shall meet

bmw has m and i brands stupidly never the twain shall meet i8 on track
The BMW i8 may one day compete with a sister BMW supercar. Image used with permission by copyright holder

BMW rocked both the sports car and the plug-in hybrid worlds last week with its unveiling of the i8. Immediately many – including yours truly – speculated about a future i8 M performance model.

As it stands, the i8 is capable of 0-62 mph in 4.4 seconds. Clearly, the i8 is fast but not mind-bogglingly so. Impressively, despite the i8’s quick acceleration, the i8 design team didn’t receive any help whatsoever from BMW’s M performance arm.

This, it might surprise you to learn, will remain the way of the BMW branding world for the foreseeable future, as BMW intentionally aims to keep i and M as distinctly separate BMW sub-brands.

“It was a deliberate decision to have two strong brand pillars to support the identity of BMW from two angles,” said BMW M head of product management Carsten Pries.

In an interview with Car Advice at the Frankfurt Motor Show, BMW Group head of technology communications Cypselus von Frakenberg said, “These (M) are the high performance cars with combustion engines, and on the other side you have the ‘i’ cars with electric drive. They won’t come together.”

To me, this decision doesn’t make sense. It would be fine if BMW had stopped its i investment with the compact i3. When it added the performance i8, however, it erased all reasons for M separation. Frankly, the exclusion of M engineers from the i8 design floor could prove damaging to both brands.

By BMW’s admission, the i8 is presently a competitor with the Porsche 911 Carrera S – in terms of price but not performance.

This makes the i8 a niche car – and an expensive one at that. But this doesn’t mean the world doesn’t want an even faster and more expensive i8 that could go toe-to-toe with the Carrera S in acceleration, too. Ferrari already sold all 499 units of its $1.6M+ LaFerrari plug-in hybrid supercars and nearly all of the million-dollar McLaren P1s are spoken for, too. It stands to reason, then, an i8 M would sell just as well.

Keeping the i and M worlds separate is foolhardy at best. Pries admits that i and M could very well one day compete in terms of performance but doesn’t know when that day might come. If left unchecked, I wager that day could be just around the corner.

I fear, however, BMW brass will artificially hold the i team back, as to not let its cars cannibalize sales of the M models. For as much as I love internal combustion, its days as the performance leader are numbered. BMW ought to wise up and let the electrons take the reigns.

Editors' Recommendations

Nick Jaynes
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Nick Jaynes is the Automotive Editor for Digital Trends. He developed a passion for writing about cars working his way…
BMW’s electric Concept i4 has two words for Tesla’s Model 3: Watch out
2020-bmw concept i4



Read more
BMW’s electric i4 will make its debut in 2021 with 530 hp, 300 miles of range
bmw i4 electric car launching in 2021 with over 300 mile range report camo 1118 2


BMW beat its rivals to the electric car segment when it released the i3 in 2013, but the city car was far too quirky to gain mass appeal. As i3 production continues, the Munich-based company is developing a battery-powered sedan named i4 it hopes will locks horns with Tesla, among other competitors. BMW released the model's preliminary specifications.

Read more
2019 Acura NSX vs. 2019 BMW i8
Hybrid fight! The Acura NSX vs the BMW i8 is the battle for our driving future
2019 acura nsx vs bmw i8 feat

The 2019 BMW i8 and the 2019 Acura NSX may seem like very different machines in your mind’s eye, given that the beemer is most likely to be seen at the new downtown cocktail bar, while the fancy Honda’s natural habitat is the parking lot of a post-IPO dog rental service. But pop on those mental reading glasses and look again. Both cars are two-seaters, both are focused on showcasing cutting-edge technology, and both have outrageous styling. Most importantly, and most surprisingly, both start at the same price. You can drive home in either an i8 or an NSX if you’ve got $155,000 in Dogecoin (or the internet monopoly-money of your choice). So while you might not initially think of cross-shopping these two vehicles, they are actually playing in the same league. Therefore, let’s put them head-to-head and see who comes out the winner. The answer may surprise you. Or not. I’m not in your head.
Judging a book by its cover
While you might not initially think of cross-shopping these two vehicles, they are actually playing in the same league.

Both cars look the part of $155k+ supercars, but they go about their visuals in very different ways. The i8, and especially the roadster we tested in this beautiful E-Copper hue, looks like a car from the near future – say 2030. The i8 is all swoops and curves, and it is often difficult to tell where distinct panels start and end. It looks like nothing else on the road, in the best possible way. The Acura, on the other hand, looks like an amalgam of various Ferraris, Hondas, and even a hint of Corvette. It’s like you asked an AI to generate a supercar. It is certainly handsome and eye-catching, but never distinctive enough to really grab your imagination. A win on exterior styling must go to the i8.
It’s what’s inside that counts
Things are reversed on the interior. The BMW feels fancier than a 3-series but doesn’t quite deliver your $155,000 worth of luxury or materials. It’s such a letdown to see so beautiful a car, to operate its amazing swan doors, and then plop into a ho-hum interior that is all-too contemporary. The designers took such stylistic chances on the body, why couldn’t they do the same with the materials and surfaces here? Especially when the interior of the down market i3 is so much more futuristic with its floating screens and matte wood trim. The one high-point on the i8 would be the uncured carbon fiber cloth accents that are used throughout the cabin.

Read more