Facebook fail? Study finds salespeople, not social media, influence car buyers the most

Facebook fail? Study finds salespeople, not social media, influence car buyers the most

With the seemingly endless piles of money spent each year by the automotive industry for marketing campaigns, commercials, and social media outreach/presence, it might surprise you to learn (it certainly surprised us) that the dealership salesperson — not the websites, Twitter, or Facebook — influence consumers the most when buying a car, .

According to an annual study conducted by St. Louis-based marketing firm Maritz Research, and pointed out to us by Automotive News, that often pushy, scheming salesperson at the dealerships outdoes all other marketing avenues when it comes to influencing car buyers. While we may live in a digital age — where using the Internet is as commonplace as putting on a pair of shoes — it would appear that good ol’ fashioned human interaction reigns supreme over the Internet. Of course Maritz’s findings are in stark contrast to the widespread belief that people today rely almost exclusively on online resources when buying or leasing a new automobile.

Can it be true? As the old saying goes: The numbers don’t lie. Maritz’s research found that  21.89 percent of car shoppers in 2011 indicated that a salesperson had the biggest impact on their purchase or lease. Coming in second was family and friends, with 18.66 percent of people saying they relied on those close to them as their new car council.

Facebook Thumbs DownBut why? With so much information at our fingertips, why are more people not taking full advantage of all the Internet has to offer? “People buy from people,” Chris Travell, vice president and strategic consultant for Maritz Research, explained in a statement. He added that while online resources can certainly help “support the selling effort,” social media sites like Facebook and Twitter still fail to usurp more traditional methods. Furthermore, according to Travell, Facebook and Twitter were not influential at all in helping customers make buying decisions last year.

While we are a little surprised to see how high salespeople rank among influencing factors for car buyers, what we’re not so surprised to see is how much faith people place in those around them, and through word of mouth, a sentiment Travell seems to echo: “We look to those we trust for their recommendation, especially when the buying decision is perceived as having a potentially high risk, like in buying a new car.”

Interestingly, Maritz’s findings arrive at a time when social media is under increased scrutiny over the actual benefits paid advertising through sites like Facebook provides. Less than two weeks ago, General Motors decided to pull the plug on its paid Facebook advertising account worth $10 million, and shortly after that announced it would not have an advertising presence at next year’s Super Bowl.

Regardless, it’ll certainly be interesting to see what effect, if any, Maritz’s study has on the automotive industry. One thing is for sure: the folks over at GM will certainly feel vindicate. And who knows, other may soon follow suit. Of course this isn’t going to stop companies, automotive or otherwise, from advertising on the Web, but if trends like this continue it could change how they go about doing it.

Here is a look at how various sources fared in Maritz’s overall ranking from top to bottom:

  • Salesperson at the dealership
  • Family, friends and word-of-mouth
  • Consumer and shopping guides
  • Dealer and manufacturer websites
  • Third-party Web sites
  • Automotive magazine reviews
  • TV ads
  • Dealer or manufacturer brochure
  • Dealer or manufacturer-sponsored event
  • Newspaper ads
  • Auto shows
  • Direct mail from dealer and/or manufacturer
  • Newspaper reviews
  • Online videos
  • E-mail from dealer and/or manufacturer
  • Magazine advertisement
  • Facebook
  • Radio ads
  • Outdoor ads
  • Twitter
  • Chat rooms, blogs, online forums
Emerging Tech

Awesome Tech You Can’t Buy Yet: camera with A.I. director, robot arm assistant

Check out our roundup of the best new crowdfunding projects and product announcements that hit the web this week. You may not be able to buy this stuff yet, but it sure is fun to gawk!
Movies & TV

From premiere date to footage: Here's all we have on 'Game of Thrones' season 8

With the eighth and final season looming, Game of Thrones fever has officially become a pandemic. Our list of all the relevant news and rumors will help make the wait more bearable, if you don't mind spoilers.
Home Theater

The seven best TVs you can buy right now, from budget to big screen

Looking for a new television? In an oversaturated market, buying power is at an all-time high, but you'll need to cut through the rough to find a diamond. We're here to help with our picks for the best TVs of 2019.
Mobile

Keep up-to-date with the best news apps on iPhone and Android

Are the days of traditional newspapers and broadcast news dwindling? With apps this good, maybe. Catch up on the latest headlines on any platform with the best news apps on iOS and Android.
Cars

Robomart’s self-driving grocery store is like Amazon Go on wheels

Robomart's driverless vehicle is like an Amazon Go store on wheels, with sensors tracking what you grab from the shelves. If you don't want to shop online or visit the grocery store yourself, Robomart will bring the store to you.
News

Ford has a plan to future-proof the hot-selling F-150 pickup truck

Worried about the threat of rising gas prices, Ford will add the F-150 to its growing portfolio of electrified vehicles. It is currently developing a hybrid F-150, and it will release an electric version of the next-generation truck.
Cars

Driving Daimler’s 40-ton eCascadia big rig isn’t just fun, it’s electrifying

Daimler Trucks brought its all-electric eCascadia semi-truck to the 2019 CES, and invited us to take the wheel. What does it feel like to drive one? Simply electrifying, of course.
Cars

Ford’s Mustang-inspired electric crossover will spawn a Lincoln luxury version

Lincoln will get its own version of parent Ford's first mass-market, long-range electric vehicle. While Ford's version will have styling inspired by the Mustang, Lincoln will take a more traditional approach.
Home Theater

Spotify adds simplified Car View mode for Android users

What was once just a test is now a reality: Spotify is rolling out a new, simplified in-car user interface for all Android users called Car View, which automatically engages when the app detects a car Bluetooth connection.
Cars

Boutique carmaker Karma Automotive, legendary design firm Pininfarina team up

Karma Automotive is partnering with legendary Italian design firm Pininfarina on future luxury cars. The first product of that partnership will appear later this year, Karma said, without offering other details.
Cars

Sibling rivalry: 2019 BMW Z4 takes on the 2020 Toyota Supra

BMW and Toyota forged an unlikely partnership when they set out to build a sports car platform together. Here, we examine the similarities and differences between the 2019 Z4 and the 2020 Supra.
Cars

Tesla cuts workforce by 7 percent, ends referral program to trim costs

Tesla has announced plans to trim its workforce by seven percent, and it will end the referral program that rewards customers who help it sell cars. These measures are ways to cut costs and boost profits.
Cars

Worried about commuting in winter weather? Nissan has the answer

The Nissan Altima midsize sedan is now available with all-wheel drive. To advertise that fact, Nissan's Canadian division slapped some tank-like tracks on an Altima to create a one-off show car.
Emerging Tech

Too buzzed to drive? Don’t worry — this autonomous car-bar will drive to you

It might just be the best or worst idea that we've ever heard: A self-driving robot bartender you can summon with an app, which promises to mix you the perfect drink wherever you happen to be.