Not so fast Tesla, NHTSA clarifies Model S crash test results

nhtsa clarifies tesla model s crash test results

Earlier this week, The Tesla Model S added another superlative to its collection by acing the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration’s (NHTSA) battery of crash tests. However, Tesla may have been a little too exuberant with its claims of success.

The NHTSA has issued a clarification regarding Tesla’s claim that the Model S scored the equivalent of 5.4 out of 5 in the crash tests.

In a paragraph-long statement, the NHTSA said that it only awards points on a scale of 1 to 5, and that a score higher than 5 is not possible.

“NHTSA does not rate vehicles beyond 5 stars and does not rank or order vehicles within the star rating categories. In addition, the agency has guidelines in place for manufacturers and advertising agencies to follow to ensure that accurate and consistent information is conveyed to the public,” the statement said.

The guidelines encourage carmakers to use specific phrases, such as “five-star” or “highest Government rating” to describe their crash test results. The NHTSA specifically discourages carmakers from using any language that might make consumers think a vehicle scored higher than a 5, including references to “double five-star” ratings for cars that received five stars in multiple tests.

In its original press release, Tesla said scores higher than 5 are recorded in the overall Vehicle Safety Score provided to manufacturers.

Tesla also said that the Model S broke the machine used in the NHTSA’s roof crush test, and that testers could not get the car to roll over. Neither point was referenced in the NHTSA statement.

Regardless of how the scoring works, the NHTSA crash tests have shown that the Model S is an incredibly safe car. It still scored a perfect 5 out of 5 on every test, which is literally as good as it gets.

Because it doesn’t have an engine, the Model S has a large front impact zone, while at the rear a double bumper provides extra protection. The Model S was also the only car to receive a “good” rating in the side pole intrusion test.

So while the Model S is an incredibly safe car, Tesla needs to be 0.4 points less boastful about it.

Product Review

It looks like a concept, but the Lexus LC500 is very much a real-life stunner

The LC500 sports car combines exotic looks, a raucous V8 engine, sumptuous interior, and responsive steering to make one of the most compelling Lexus-badged models ever and one of the sexiest vehicles on sale.
Cars

End your dependence on fossil fuels with one of these amazing electric cars

Electric cars are getting smarter, safer, and more capable with each passing year. Here are our picks for the best electric cars on the market, whether you're looking for a performance ride or a family-friendly crossover.
Cars

Audi is finally taking the wraps off its Tesla-fighting e-tron electric SUV

The 2019 Audi e-tron is an electric SUV aimed at the Tesla Model X, Jaguar I-Pace, and Mercedes-Benz EQC. It's Audi's first mass-market electric car, but will it make a good first impression?
Home Theater

Samsung has partnered with AKG to bring new wireless headphones to the U.S.

Samsung is partnering with audio legends to bring new wireless headphones to its customers in the U.S. with the new N700NC, Y500, and Y100, which range from over-ear noise-canceling models to lightweight in-ear models.
Cars

Volkswagen built a 210-mph Jetta, and broke a land-speed record with it

A modified 2019 Volkswagen Jetta just set a land-speed record at the Bonneville Salt Flats in the G/BGC class. Boasting a 600-horsepower engine, the Jetta hit 210 mph on the salt.
Emerging Tech

Smart sound system will give every car passenger their own wireless audio stream

Can't agree on what to listen to in the car? Imagine if each passenger could get their own way, courtesy of a personal audio stream — no headphones required. Sounds impossible, but it's almost here.
Product Review

Aston’s stunning DB11 V8 Volante proves exotic cars aren't just about lap times

With the DB11 Volante, Aston Martin’s marriage of luxury and performance is perhaps at its best, offering hustle that doesn’t feel rushed and refinement with emotion still intact.
Emerging Tech

No more scraping? Anti-frosting advance could mark end of frozen windshields

Hate frozen windshields in winter? Researchers at Virginia Tech may have found a way to banish them for good, thanks to the world’s first passive anti-frosting surface. Here's how it works.
Cars

Ferrari’s latest special editions are stripped down, old-school sports cars

The Ferrari Monza SP1 and SP2 are inspired by some of the Italian automaker's most legendary sports cars. They mix old school rawness with modern carbon fiber construction and 789-horsepower V12 power.
News

Lucid Motors accepts $1 billion investment from Saudi Arabian fund

The Public Investment Fund of Saudi Arabia will invest $1 billion in upstart electric car company Lucid Motors. Lucid hopes to launch a Tesla-fighting luxury sedan called the Air by 2020.
Cars

Lyft offers some fun stats to celebrate its 1 billionth ridesharing journey

Lyft cars have made a billion journeys since its ridesharing service launched six years ago. Announcing the milestone on Tuesday, September 18, the company revealed a few fun stats about its rides so far.
Cars

Nissan will invite Google into its cars’ dashboards starting in 2021

The Renault-Nissan-Mitsubishi Alliance has joined forces with Google to develop a brand-new infotainment system. Scheduled to launch in 2021, the yet-unnamed software will boast navigation via Google Maps over-the-air software updates.
Cars

Volkswagen shows us the workaholic side of its modern-day classic van

The Volkswagen I.D. Cargo concept is an electric, connected delivery van based on the I.D. Buzz concept from 2017. It boasts up to 350 miles of range and cool features like solar panels on the roof and a 230-volt outlet for power tools.
Cars

It’s not easy being green: California strips HOV rights from clean-air cars

Changes to California's Clean Air Vehicle decal program are raising the ire of early adopters. The decals let LEV and ZEV drivers travel solo in commuter lanes. More than 200,000 drivers will lose the privilege January 1.