Sorry automakers, 2 screens are definitely not better than 1

Generally, with cars, more is better. More horsepower, more space, more fins, all of these things are desirable. But when it comes to infotainment, the opposite is true; simpler is better. That’s because user interfaces, particularly ones that are supposed to be used while driving two tons of metal at 60 mph, need to be simple to work.

However, a slew of new, two-screen infotainment systems are chasing sales at the expense of usability … and it has me worried.

The two big offenders are Acura and Infiniti, both of which have released two screen systems in the last few years. Acura released its two-screen AcuraLink system on its flagship RLX sedan in 2013, and has now introduced the setup on the MDX and the brand-new TLX. Its other models are up for midlife refreshes soon and will likely be receiving it then. Meanwhile, Infiniti’s system InTouch has just made its debut on the Q50, but is likely to replace the aging system in its other models.

While both of these systems are unique, they share many of the same problems.

Take Acura’s creatively named AcuraLink system, as featured on the new TLX. Acura has decided to split infotainment tasks between its two screens. The lower touchscreen handles audio and climate control, while the upper handles navigation, phone, vehicle settings and a duplicate set of audio controls.

In theory, this means a driver can keep his or her navigation screen up while still messing with other functions. In practice, however, it means spending far more time looking away from the road, while glancing back and forth between two screens. This isn’t just a question of confusion either. The human eye takes time to refocus at different distances, which means that glancing between two screens that are different distances from the driver is time consuming and hard on the eyes.

Both Mazda and Audi engineers have explained to me that they place their screens in such a way that the eye’s focal distance changes as little from road to screen as possible. Having multiple screens makes this impossible.

Multiple screens also seem to lead to an explosion in control systems. AcuraLink can be controlled via touchscreen, mouse, steering wheel buttons, and voice command. I understand the thinking, there is a control system for everyone! However, this creates a problem. Developers have a finite amount of money and time. Pouring limited resources into not one but two systems results in a dual-screen system that is not half as good as it would be if it were a single unit.

audi-tt-virtual-cockpit-at-the-ces-970x646-c
Audi’s “virtual cockpit” infotainment system

Infiniti’s new InTouch system, featured on the Q50S, handles this side of things a little better with a very intuitive touch screen interface and the second screen devoted largely to navigation. Despite being a bit simpler, it still shows another big problem with two screen setups: aesthetics. Two screens may sound like a great boardroom proposal. Reality is, however, that the screens aren’t duplicates. This means different resolutions and different graphics combine to look less like the Enterprise and more like a low-budget project from Pimp My Ride.

So why are these systems getting made if they are so obviously flawed? In a word: marketing.

For companies like Acura and Infiniti that are constantly battling not just for market share but attention, having something that stands out is perhaps more important than an intuitive system. Adding a second screen to an infotainment system allows Acura or Infiniti to advertise that they have something that their luxury competitors like BMW, Audi, and Mercedes lack: another screen! It also allows innovation to be done on the cheap, by adding more of what automakers already have access to.

By contrast, innovation like the combined instrument cluster and infotainment system in the new Audi TT takes a lot of time and money. For example, Audi had to work with Nvedia to redevelop an entire chipset to withstand the rigors of working in a car.

Cadillac CUE
Cadillac CUE

While companies like Audi, BMW, Mercedes, and Lexus might be able to move forward on their established reputations and mountains of R&D money, I worry that smaller automakers will resort to gimmicks like a second screen to draw attention. We have already seen Cadillac release is interesting but problematic CUE infotainment suite with its gesture recognition feature.

Perhaps it is a coincidence that Infiniti and Acura released such similar systems in such close proximity, but it may also suggest that these two similar companies have found something in their market research to suggest that these systems would be popular. And it may not stop with Acura and Infiniti. Companies like Hyundai and Kia are attempting to move up market, and may be refreshing their infotainment systems soon.

Not only do these systems not really work, they would actively steer me away from up and coming companies and back to the German ‘Big Three.’ I can only hope that Acura and Infiniti realize this before anyone ends up joining them and starts taping screens to door panels.

Wearables

Google's Wear OS update 'H' promises battery life improvements

Google has rebranded its Android Wear operating system to Wear OS. Removing the Android name may help people better understand Google-powered smartwatches, which also play nice with iOS devices. 
Computing

PDF to JPG conversion is quick and easy using these simple methods

Converting file formats can be an absolute pain, but it doesn't have to be. We've put together a comprehensive guide on how to convert a PDF to JPG, no matter which operating system you're running.
Computing

Here's why 64-bit (not 32-bit) dominates modern computing

Today's computing world isn't the same as it once was. With 64-bit processors and operating systems replacing the older 32-bit designs, we look at what 32-bit vs. 64-bit really means for you.
Computing

Printing to PDF in Windows is easy, no matter which method you use

Microsoft's latest operating system makes it easier than ever to print to PDF in Windows, but there are alternative methods for doing so, even if you want to forgo Adobe Acrobat. Here's how.
Cars

Our favorite fuel-efficient cars are as frugal as they are fun

You don't need to opt for a hybrid or an all-electric ride in order to achieve good fuel economy. These vehicles pack both performance and style, whether you're in the market for a luxury sedan or a game-changing pickup truck.
Cars

Out of juice? Learn how to jump-start a car with this quick guide

Jumping a car is a simple procedure, but not everyone knows how to properly do so. To make things easier, we've put together a quick-hit guide on how to fire up your vehicle using jumper cables and a second power source.
Cars

Many adults believe fully self-driving cars are already traversing U.S. highways

The American Automobile Association tested cars with features such as lane-keeping and adaptive cruise control and found them lacking in real-world conditions. Forty percent of surveyed U.S. adults think self-driving cars exist now.
Cars

Born to run (forever): The most reliable cars you can buy right now

We all dread the thought of our car turning into a money pit, but choosing a dependable vehicle from the start can help us rack up countless care-free miles. Here, we've rounded up some of the most reliable cars available.
Cars

Prep your car for the coming snow and sleet with these cold weather tips

Driving in the winter, whether downtown or across the country, is rarely easy. Luckily, we've put together a quick rundown of a few things you should do to winterize your car before the snow officially hits.
Digital Trends Live

DT Daily: Waymo’s driverless cars, ‘Fallout 76’ tips, and Racella

In today's episode of DT Daily, we discuss Waymo's foray into the ridesharing sector, along with various tips for making the most of the recently launched Fallout 76. We also sit down with singer Racella to chat about her new EP, Waves.
Cars

Want to keep connected on the road? Here are 5 ways to add Bluetooth to your car

The best way to make an old ride feel young again is to bring it up speed with the 21st century. Here's how to properly add Bluetooth to your vehicle, via independent kits, vehicle adapters, or aftermarket head units.
Cars

Jeep’s outdoorsy Gladiator pickup truck bares it all ahead of schedule

Jeep will introduce the long-promised Wrangler-based pickup truck at the 2018 Los Angeles Auto Show. Named Gladiator, the model was designed to conquer the great outdoors, not for the construction site.
Cars

The hamster-friendly 2020 Kia Soul will rock out at the Los Angeles Auto Show

Kia has released a teaser image to preview the next Soul. Scheduled to make its debut at the 2018 Los Angeles Auto Show, the 2020 Soul will keep the outgoing model's boxy proportions but it will wear a sharper design.
Cars

2020 Toyota Corolla sedan aims to offer sharper handling, better tech

The 2020 Toyota Corolla sedan gets the same upgrades as the recently-introduced Corolla hatchback, including a firmer foundation, new engine, and more tech features. Will that be enough to keep the long-lived Corolla nameplate relevant?