Skip to main content

See how popular car brands fared in new Consumer Reports survey

Consumer Reports has just released its annual report card that rates which car brands make the best vehicles — and it contains a few surprises.

Mazda, for example, tops the list for the very first time, moving up three places from last year. The Japanese automaker has enjoyed success with its subcompact Mazda CX-30 SUV, as well as its midsize CX-9 SUV, which received plenty of praise in Digital Trends’ hands-on review.

BMW ranked second, climbing an impressive six places, while Subaru held on to its number three spot.

Consumer Reports arrives at its rankings by looking at individual scores for each model that factor in road-test performance, predicted reliability, owner satisfaction, and safety. It then works out the average to come up with a brand’s overall score.

“Brands that rise to the top tend to have the most consistent performance across their lineup,” CR said in an article about the results, adding, “however, it is important to research the individual models when shopping because every brand has a range of product performance.”

Consumer Reports

The rankings show Honda making a big leap, moving up 10 places from last year to number five on the chart, which Consumer Reports said was partly attributable to improved reliability, adding that all but two Hondas now have average reliability or better, according to its research.

At the other end of the the rankings is Italian automaker Alpha Romeo, at the very bottom after dropping five spots from last year to 32. Land Rover sits just above it at 31, with Mitsubishi at 30.

Chrysler and Buick ranked highest among U.S. brands, both climbing an impressive 10 places to take eighth and ninth spots, respectively.

Relative newcomer to the auto industry, Tesla, placed 16th, down five. The luxury brands Genesis (15th, down 13) and Lincoln (28th, down 15) registered the biggest drops. The nonprofit consumer organization noted that big moves can usually be attributed to “changes in predicted reliability for individual models within a brand’s lineup.”

Consumer Reports’ recently published owner satisfaction survey reveals a rather different set of rankings. Check out which came out on top and ranked at the bottom.

Editors' Recommendations

Trevor Mogg
Contributing Editor
Not so many moons ago, Trevor moved from one tea-loving island nation that drives on the left (Britain) to another (Japan)…
How much longer will consumers keep buying cars at dealerships?
prodigy car dealership sales platform colorful cars in a lot

Do you like negotiating with car salespeople? There actually are some people who enjoy buying cars at auto dealers, but if you're one of them, you're in a minority. The 2016 Beepi Consumer Automotive Index, based on an online Harris Poll survey, found 87 percent of Americans dislike something about car shopping at dealerships and 61 percent feel they're taken advantage of while there.

Harris conducted the survey of 2,135 U.S. adults 18 and older in April 2016, on behalf of the Beepi used car online peer-to-peer marketplace. The purpose of the survey was to find out how Americans feel about car ownership experiences, including traditional and newer buying alternatives. The survey also checked attitudes about autonomous vehicles.

Read more
Consumer Reports joins in asking Tesla to turn off Autopilot, Tesla still says no
tesla model s autopilot expected update crash death

It's beginning to feel like piling on. Six days after Consumer Watchdog sent a letter to Tesla saying the electric car maker should turn off the semi-autonomous Autopilot feature, Consumer Reports has made the same statement and received the same answer, according to Electrek. In both cases Tesla said no.

The Consumer Reports article and other recent attention paid to Tesla's Autopilot and Autosteer follow a fatal accident that occurred on May 7 with Autopilot engaged, and at least two other accidents in which the drivers claimed Autopilot was turned on but failed to prevent a collision. In some cases, Tesla's data records for the involved vehicles showed that Autopilot mode either was not turned on or that alerts were sounded and displayed but ignored by the driver.

Read more
Toyota's 2016 Prius is Consumer Reports’ fuel economy king
2016 Toyota Prius

When the 2016 Toyota Prius was unveiled late last year, the fourth-generation model boasted a number of improvements over its predecessor. The driving dynamics were noticeably better, for one, and it featured new safety technologies like a pre-collision system, lane departure alert, and full speed dynamic radar cruise control. The styling was completely revamped as well, and while the interior looked a bit like a Stormtrooper’s skivvies to our eyes, we appreciated the new layout and upgraded materials.

Fuel economy is the name of the game in the Prius world, though, and in that sense, the new model knocks it completely out of the park. According to a new batch of tests by Consumer Reports, the 2016 Prius is the most fuel efficient vehicle the group has ever tested.

Read more