Skip to main content

Elon Musk: Battery swap ‘doesn’t make much sense’ with Supercharger availability

Tesla Model S
Electric car magnate Elon Musk announced Tesla’s battery-swap program last year, which would allow Model S owners to change out depleted battery packs for fresh ones quickly. According to the company, the switch could be done in just 90 seconds — less time than it takes an Audi A6 to fully refuel.

To test the procedure, the brand set up a pilot program in Harris Ranch, California. Tesla invited some 200 clients to enjoy the swapping service, but it didn’t go as planned. Only a handful of customers ever utilized the resource.

Related Videos

One reason could be that the changeover time exceeded 180 seconds in practical form, but that’s probably not the case. More likely is that the availability of high-speed Superchargers across the U.S. makes the system somewhat redundant, a statement that was echoed by Musk at a recent shareholder meeting.

As quoted by The Verge, Musk said: “People don’t care about pack swap. The Superchargers are fast enough that if you’re driving from LA to San Francisco, and you start a trip at 9 a.m, by the time you get to, say, noon, you want to stop, and you want to stretch your legs, hit the restroom, grab a bite to eat, grab a coffee, and be on your way, and by that time, the car is charged and ready to go, and it’s free. So, it’s like, why would you do the pack swap? It doesn’t make much sense.”

While it’s not an official condemnation, Musk’s comments likely mean that battery swapping won’t receive major financial support anytime soon. However, there are others factors that could have played into the pilot program’s uninspired reaction.

The first and most obvious is that the switch could only be done by appointment, which added a step to the refueling process that simply wasn’t there before. Moreover, the sample size around Harris Ranch was quite small, so the numbers Tesla received may not be indicative of nationwide interest.

Regardless of those circumstances, free, fast, and nationwide Supercharging is hard to argue with. We’ll keep you updated as the story develops.

Editors' Recommendations

Tesla Cybertruck prototype spotted with minor changes
A Tesla Cybertruck prototype.

What appears to be a new Tesla Cybertruck prototype has been spotted testing on public roads.

As relayed by Electrek, Twitter user Greg posted a photo Thursday showing a Cybertruck with a different front-end design from what we've seen previously. The front bumper has a more distinct rectangular opening, possibly for cooling. This prototype also has triangular side mirrors, as opposed to the squared-off ones seen previously.

Read more
Why you should consider a plug-in hybrid in 2023
2020 audi q5 tfsi e first drive review phev 19

EVs are all the rage — and it makes sense. Electric vehicles allow you to avoid high gas prices and feel good about not impacting the environment as much, plus they’re usually sleek, stylish, and fast.

But in 2023, owning an EV isn’t for everyone. After all, charging stations, while improving, still aren’t as common as they should be -- and depending on your car, they sometimes aren’t all that fast. If you’re worried about those issues, there’s an alternative — a plug-in hybrid (also known as a plug-in hybrid electric vehicle, or PHEV). These are cars that essentially offer the best of both worlds: A battery and electric motor for quick, clean trips around town, and a gas engine for longer road trips.
What makes a PHEV so great?

Read more
Tesla Destination Chargers vs. Superchargers: What’s the difference?
tesla starts opening its supercharger network to other evs

One of the best things about owning a Tesla is being able to take advantage of the massive network of chargers to quickly and easily charge up your car. Charging a Tesla is extremely easy — all you have to do is plug in your car, and all of the costs and payments are handled automatically.

But did you know there are actually different kinds of Tesla chargers? Tesla Destination Charging and Superchargers are the two main options, but there are some key differences between the two. Understanding these differences will help you make sure you’re taking advantage of the best charger for your needs.

Read more