Skip to main content

Uber’s Pittburgh robotaxis amuse riders, still struggle with double parked cars

About a month ago, Uber rolled out its fleet of self-driving robo-cabs in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. You might be wondering why it wasn’t Palo Alto, California or New York City, but the location is far from random. Pittsburgh is also the home of Carnegie Mellon University, which provided much of the brainpower for Uber’s new Advanced Technologies Center. That’s where the autonomous cabs are being developed.

Uber is tight-lipped on specifics, but according to the Mayor of Pittsburgh, Uber now has over 500 employees in the city. A quick look through Uber’s current job openings turns up 64 available positions in Pittsburgh against a total of seven for the rest of the world, and most of those are in Detroit. So it’s safe to say that this is more than an experiment. Uber is going all-in to put self-driving cars on the road as soon as possible.

Not quite driverless

Right now, Uber has a small fleet of autonomous vehicles plying the streets of Pittsburgh. The self-driving Ubers are Ford Fusion Hybrids, and they’re fitted with a special roof-mounted array of cameras, GPS receivers, and a LIDAR (laser radar) system that collectively generate over a million data points every second. The autonomous system is designed to handle acceleration, braking, steering, and point-to-point navigation.

It’s safe to say that this is more than an experiment. Uber is going all-in to put self-driving cars on the road as soon as possible.

For all that, the Uber robo-cabs still have a human being in the driver’s seat. In part, that’s because Pennsylvania law requires a human being to be able to take control of the vehicle, but riders have reported that the self-driving system will drop the car into human control if it gets confused and doesn’t know what to do. For example, riders reported that if the robo-taxi encounters a double-parked car in its lane or a stalled car, it tends to wait for the car ahead to move. When that happens, the human driver can take control and get around the unpredictable obstacle.

Ask the riders

We got ahold of a couple customers who have used the new self-driving Uber. One was Aaron Butler, a lawyer in Pittsburgh and a regular Uber rider.

“It was a little different than what I thought initially,” Butler tells Digital Trends. “I thought it would be like The Magic School Bus, or that I’d go in and it would be like KITT from Knight Rider. But it’s not The Magic School Bus. You have a human driver and he’s driving at least 30 percent of the time.”

The Pittsburgh streets present a set of challenges that are unique, but also representative of what self-driving cars may have to manage in any city.

“Pittsburgh is pretty hilly with small, narrow streets,” Butler explains. “So it’s really tricky for cars to navigate on their own. On a narrow street, it takes a human who knows to ease it over a few inches.”

How it works

For now, getting a ride in a robo-cab is limited to certain established Uber customers, like Michelle Bastable-Maher who is an IT consultant in Pittsburgh and uses Uber frequently. She’s a fan of the new service. “There were two incredibly knowledgeable and personable guys [driving], so I felt completely safe at all times,” she says.

“The fact is, it’ll get you where you need to go, but it’s not going to get you there quickly.”

If you’re one of Uber’s selected riders, you just hail an Uber ride as you normally would, and if you’re hailing between 7:00 AM and 10:00 PM, there’s a chance that the ride will be one of the robo-cabs. If it is, you and a friend can climb in the back and control the ride from an iPad mounted there. You confirm the destination, verify that there are only two of you and that you’re both buckled up, then tell the taxi to go.

Uber’s car will choose its own route and manage normal traffic situations. Speed is controlled by two factors: the speed limit and the flow of traffic.  As a rule, the streets on which the automated Ubers are driving have limits no higher than 35 mph, and the cars are programmed to obey all traffic laws.

“The fact is, it’ll get you where you need to go, but it’s not going to get you there quickly,” Butler says. “It doesn’t have human intuition about how traffic is going to speed up or slow down, and it won’t take a right on red without it being posted.”

If the car needs to drop out of autonomous operation, a chime sounds and the human driver takes over, or the driver can take control simply by taking the wheel or stepping on either of the pedals. When the situation is managed, the driver hits a button and the car takes over driving again.

“When the car arrived [the human drivers] were manually driving. They drove to the end of the road, about 100 yards, and then put the car into driverless mode,” Bastable-Maher reports. “On my first ride, [the human drivers] took back control at one point when we got into the centre of Pittsburgh and there were a lot of pedestrians crossing. The second time I believe it was, apart from the first 100 yards, driverless all the way.”

Learning the Pittsburgh Left

As Uber has been testing the system, a few sensational news stories have appeared alleging a one-way street violation and even an accident. However, it turns out that the one-way incident happened under the control of the human driver, and the accident was human error when another driver rear-ended the Uber.

One outlier that had to be learned is known as a Pittsburgh Left, a courtesy that drivers extend to each other.

Digital Trends asked the Pittsburgh Department of Transportation and the Mayor’s office whether there was any change in traffic incidents since the program started. Both said there was “no information of note.”

Right now, the Uber robo-cabs (and their human babysitters) are limited to certain neighborhoods in Pittsburgh. By restricting the operating area to a known map, Uber is able to make fast iterations on software without accounting for too many outlier cases while they’re perfecting the basics.

One outlier that had to be learned is known as a Pittsburgh Left. This is simply a courtesy that drivers extend to each other, but you won’t find it anywhere in the vehicle code. A Pittsburgh Left applies in a situation where left-turning traffic does not have a left-arrow at an intersection, and is simply the habit of letting the first left-turning car make its turn before the straight-through traffic takes the right-of-way.


Speaking on background, an Uber employee told Digital Trends, “We learn every day from every ride we take, be it about the type of traffic in a specific area or about Pittsburgh Lefts, which the cars know about but do not perform themselves.”

The end game

Uber’s not saying anything about when or where they’ll expand their robo-cab experiment, but they’ve stated the ultimate goal clearly in their marketing materials for the program: “Self-driving cars can help fast forward to a future where no one needs to own a car. When you can reliably push a button and get a ride in minutes, why bother with the hassle of looking for your keys, your directions, your car and a parking space?”

As an Uber customer, Butler agrees. “I think it’s novel and it’s fun, and I think within ten years it could be a standard,” he says. “I was surprised at how safe it was. It’s a lot safer than riding with a human driver. But to be a standard, more cars will have to be self-driving.”

That standard may be a lot closer than you expect.

Editors' Recommendations

A weird thing just happened with a fleet of autonomous cars
A passenger getting into a Cruise robotaxi.

In what must be one of the weirder stories linked to the development of autonomous vehicles, a fleet of Cruise self-driving cars gathered together at an intersection in San Francisco earlier this week, parked up, and blocked traffic for several hours. And to be clear: No, they weren't supposed to do that.

Some observers may have thought they were witnessing the start of the robot uprising, but the real reason for the mishap was more prosaic: An issue with the platform's software.

Read more
Elon Musk eyes 2024 for Tesla robotaxi sans steering wheel, pedals
Elon Musk - Tesla CEO

Tesla is aiming to mass produce a robotaxi by 2024, CEO Elon Musk revealed during an earnings call with investors on Wednesday as the company reported better-than-expected quarterly figures.

The dedicated robotaxi will feature a “futuristic” design and come without a steering wheel or pedals, Musk said, adding that the vehicle, which would build on the automaker’s current self-driving technology, could be “a massive driver of Tesla’s growth.”

Read more
Officers confused as they pull over an empty self-driving car

In what appears to be the first incident of its kind, police officers recently pulled over a self-driving car with no one inside it.

The incident, which took place on a street in San Francisco earlier this month, was caught on video by a passing pedestrian. It shows several traffic cops pondering about how to handle the incident after stopping the vehicle for failing to have its front lights on while driving at night.

Read more