Where the silicon meets the mud: Smart AWD in next-generation crossovers

where the silicon meets mud smart awd in next generation crossovers nissan rogue

You’re driving on a farm road somewhere in the Midwest. Suddenly, you hit a rut and sink six inches into the deep stuff. In a crossover, your chances of driving out of it are fairly slim. In fact, these popular vehicles (essentially, they are a cross between an SUV and a passenger car) have lacked the technical chops to control wheel speed, apply engine torque, and get you moving again. Improved models – the Ford Edge, Lincoln MKX, and Nissan Rogue – use liberal doses of technology to address those challenges.

To test them, we took all three newly designed models on a winding dirt road, across a mud-caked farm field, and – just to make sure they handle well in a more typical scenario – on dry pavement at highway speeds. Surprisingly, each vehicle handled these driving conditions quite well, but with a slightly different experience. Read on to find out which one fared the best, and how they leverage tech to pry you out of the worst binds.

Ford Edge Sport

where the silicon meets mud smart awd in next generation crossovers ford edge

Newly redesigned for the 2011 model year, and with a heftier 3.7-liter engine than the base model, the Edge Sport is a pure crossover: It handles like an SUV when you need the power but normally drives like a car for taking the kids to soccer practice and your daily commuter route.

Ford has used accelerometers for stability control in previous models for years. These sensors can tell the speed of the vehicle, latitude and longitudinal position (aka, zig-zagging on the road), and the exact position of the foot pedal. What’s new for the 2011 model is that the sensors are now used for AWD control. Computer algorithms make fine adjusts in torque (e.g., the power provided to each tire) to make sure all four tires are working together to keep you going straight and smooth.

Most earlier crossovers adjusted tire speed based on how the tires slip. They would back off power to, say, the left rear tire to keep the vehicle moving. By using stability sensors for AWD, the Edge actually senses slippage before it occurs. For example, the car senses whether it’s moving forward and the accelerator is only pressed down slightly. Then, if you press down harder to get out of a mud bath, the Edge prevents slippage: there’s an interchange between the speed of the tires and whether the car is actually moving forward. The AWD is also tied to the steering wheel sensor, so the vehicle adjusts tire speed – based on the steering accelerometer – in order to keep you moving straight.

Okay, so how did all of this play out in our tests? First of all, the Edge Sport handled smoothly on dry pavement – it felt more like a car and less like a truck. In some cases, on especially dry pavement and around a curve, the vehicle still felt smooth and did not grip the road so tightly, which is common in vehicles like the Ford Explorer that tend to provide more grip no matter where you drive.

In our mud tests, the Edge Sport started from an idle position in about four inches of mud, gravel, and water, accelerating evenly with only a slight fishtail movement. On a gravel road, the Edge never had any of the typical slippage that can occur – even at speeds around 50 MPH. Overall, the Sport lived up to its name, even if there was just a hint of fishtailing in the thickest mud.

Check out our 2011 Ford Edge driving impressions.

Lincoln MKX

where the silicon meets mud smart awd in next generation crossovers lincoln mkx

The 2011 version of the Lincoln MKZ is another total re-design – it uses the same powertrain as the Ford Edge. Interestingly enough, the handling is actually different from the Edge Sport and the Edge Limited, which we drove several weeks ago. Ford told us the MKX uses different algorithms for handling but otherwise uses many of the same components and stability sensors for the AWD.

In the same test conditions, the MKX actually stayed a bit straighter and moved a bit quicker out of thick mud than either the Ford Edge or the Nissan Rogue. There was no hesitation at all, so it’s possible that the torque is applied for more of a robust feel when driving. Or, it could be that, at 5,420 pounds, the MKX is heavier than either the Edge Sport (at 5,174 pounds) or the Nissan Rogue (at 4,339 pounds).

Around corners on dry pavement, the MKX also handled a bit less ruggedly than the Ford Edge, providing a smoother and more refined ride, which is to be expected since the MKX is positioned as more of a luxury vehicle. In the Edge and MKX, there are no settings for adjusting the AWD mode like there is on the Nissan Rogue (which lets you lock in AWD for better traction in mud).

Overall, the MKX is a major improvement – the body styling competes easily with crossovers from Honda and even Mercedes, and the interior is well-made and nicely accented. This crossover was our top pick for longer drives because of the smooth feel and intelligent AWD system.

Nissan Rogue

where the silicon meets mud smart awd in next generation crossovers nissan rogue 2

The Nissan Rogue is a smaller and lighter crossover than the Edge or MKZ, which makes it more fun to drive around tight corners and a bit more responsive in certain situations – such as making a very tight corner in a parking lot. Like the Volkswagen Jetta we tested recently, the Nissan has tight handling even on a gravel road. In our tests, the vehicle responded well to steering wheel movements and felt more precise than the Edge or MKX for basic around-town driving and on the highway.

The Rogue is positioned as an entry-level crossover with a base price of around $20,000, whereas the Edge (at about $27,000 base) and MKX (at about $39,000 base) are positioned as higher-end crossovers. While the Edge and MKX can certainly handle off-road conditions, they are essentially passenger cars. The Nissan Rogue is still a passenger car, but in thick mud it behaved a bit more like an off-road truck.

One perk on the Rogue not found on the Edge or MKX is an AWD lock button, which automatically allocates 50 percent of power to the front wheels and 50 percent of power to the rear wheels. It only works under 5 MPH. If you do not push the button, the Rogue will allocate power automatically. (The button is easy to find, but the light that illuminates in the dash is a bit hard to spot.) Like other modern crossovers and mini-SUVs on the market, the Rogue uses traction control sensors that apply light braking to a wheel that is slipping (while AWD adds power to wheels not slipping). The Rogue has a steering wheel sensor and yaw sensor (to see if the car is at an angle) that also add braking to the front tires to keep you straight.

In the mud test, the Rogue actually slipped sideways a bit during a fast acceleration test from a standing position. There were a few minor instances when the tires felt like they slipped just slightly. For those who prefer a more responsive drive, the Rogue gripped the road tighter and more like an SUV, whether on mud or dry pavement. We ended up preferring the looser handling on the Edge and MKX for most driving conditions, but the Rogue was more fun to drive through heavy mud (even with the slippage).

Product Review

Mercedes-Benz updates the timeless G-wagen for the modern world

For decades, the G-Class has been an outlier in the Mercedes-Benz portfolio, a body-on-frame brute with the soul – and driving manners – of an off-road pickup. With the all-new G550, Mercedes seeks to smooth out some of the rough edges.
Cars

Watch a modified Audi e-tron electric SUV drive straight up a ski slope

A modified Audi e-tron climbed up an 85-percent gradient on an Austrian ski slope in a tribute to a classic Audi commercial. The vehicle used for the stunt sported an extra electric motor and spiked tires.
Gaming

Your PlayStation 4 game library isn't complete without these games

Looking for the best PS4 games out there? Out of the massive crop of titles available, we selected the best you should buy. No matter what your genre of choice may be, there's something here for you.
Product Review

The 2020 Volvo V60 Cross Country is a do-it-all Swedish army knife

Volvo laced up its smallest station wagon in hiking clothes to create the V60 Cross Country. It's a lifted, all-wheel drive wagon that laughs at icy roads while coddling its occupants. We travel to Sweden to try it out.
Cars

Nissan is using old Leaf batteries to power and connect off-the-grid campers

Nissan has teamed up with trailer manufacturer Opus to design a mobile, weatherproof power pack built with battery cells sourced from the first-generation Leaf. Called Roam, the pack stores enough electricity to power a camper for up to a…
Cars

Alfa Romeo’s latest Ferrari-powered F1 race car is ready to hit the track

Alfa Romeo is doubling down on Formula One racing after a decades-long hiatus. Now essentially a support team for Ferrari, its 2019 driver lineup includes a former world champion and a potential future star.
Cars

Researchers teach self-driving cars to predict pedestrians’ next moves

University of Michigan researchers are developing a system that teaches self-driving cars to predict pedestrian movement. Humans don't always act in their own best self-interest, so autonomous cars will need to practice protective driving.
Cars

Subaru’s latest VIZIV concept car is pumped full of adrenaline

The Subaru VIZIV Adrenaline is the seventh member of the Japanese automaker's family of VIZIV concept cars. It debuts at the 2019 Geneva Motor Show, but for now, all we're getting is a shadowy teaser image.
Cars

Audi is advancing the tech that teaches cars to talk to traffic lights

Audi is teaching its cars the language of traffic lights. The company developed technology that tells motorists what speed they should drive at in order to catch as many green lights as possible.
Cars

Waymo rules and Apple trails in California self-driving car benchmarks

California's DMV releases annual reports of self-driving car disengagements on public roads. In the most recent reports. Waymo had the best performance, GM Cruise came in second, and Apple's self-driving program was in last place.
Cars

Mamma mia! Alfa Romeo will unveil a new model at the Geneva Auto Show

Alfa Romeo told Digital Trends it will unveil a new model at the 2019 Geneva Auto Show. It stopped short of revealing what it has in store, but rumors claim it will be a crossover positioned below the Stelvio.
Cars

Citroën says you could drive its tiny Ami One electric car without a license

Citroën's Ami One concept car is an electric vehicle that's as cute as it is compact. The miniature motor only has a top speed of 28 mph, so the French automaker imagines it as a shareable runaround for short drives.
Cars

Arizona city slammed with $10M lawsuit over fatal Uber autonomous car accident

The family of Elaine Herzberg, the woman struck and killed by one of Uber's self-driving prototypes, has filed a $10 million lawsuit against the city of Tempe, Arizona. They claim Herzberg jaywalked because she was confused by a brick…
Cars

Mercedes lets the sun shine in one last time with SLC Final Edition convertible

The Mercedes-Benz SLC convertible sports car is going out of production. Launched in 1996 as the SLK, the model has been a fixture in the Mercedes-Benz lineup across three generations.