The update debate: Why the latest version of software isn’t always the best

are software updates always for the best not windows update
If there is one thing that distinguishes the modern state of software, it’s how the software is updated. The days of shipping a patch out on physical media are long gone. Today, patches are instantaneous. It seems many applications and programs can’t go more than a few days without needing something tweaked or fixed, and if users don’t see such updates, they assume the developers are resting on their laurels.

And yet, despite the ease with which fixes can be applied, it’s not necessarily true that having the most up-to-date software is a plus. AMD’s new Crimson drivers are a recent example. Fans jumped on the revamped graphics card back-end, hopeful of the performance and usability improvements it could bring. But some of them were faced with graphical glitches and overheating GPUs thanks to a fan speed bug.

Using fans as testers is great in theory, but puts them on the receiving end of the most disastrous bugs.

Although updates are easier than ever to release and apply, they are rarely mandatory. There are occasional jumps that will cut off users who aren’t willing to perform the update, but rarely is anyone forced to do so. With that in mind, we thought we would ask the question — is it worthwhile to always update to the latest software?

There are certainly some that argue for that. Many companies have taken advantage of user desire to run the latest build, as soon as possible. Perhaps it’s thanks to a climate where our phones are telling us every five minutes that something needs updating, or simply because, as content and products come faster and faster, we want them to improve more quickly, as well.

Using fans as test dummies

The Windows Insider program is the perfect example of how companies are using fans. Microsoft was able to secure itself over a million beta testers for Windows 10, none of whom it had to pay a cent. In years gone past, QA was handled exclusively by in-house employees, a third party company, or at worst, the friends and family of the developers. Most, if not all of those people would require compensation of some kind.

Using fans as testers is great in theory. The fans receive the software first, and the company receives free feedback. But it also puts loyal followers at the receiving end of the most disastrous bugs.

AMD’s Crimson was an important update, but its initial release had a major bug

Some of the latest Windows 10 updates have been far from perfect. The most recent, dropped in November, had to be temporarily pulled due to a privacy bug that reset user privacy settings without their knowledge. The issue is an example of why some people, companies, and governments prefer to stay well away from the latest releases. And as the needs of a user or group of users become more critical, their willingness to adopt an update early decreases.

Older can be better, or at least necessary

The U.S. Navy is currently spending millions of dollars on legacy support from Microsoft for the thousands of systems it has in operation that are still running Windows XP. Why is it running an operating system that is almost a decade and a half old?

For the same reason that a Windows 3.1 bug caused the closure of an entire French airport just last month, and the same reason huge industries still use equipment that requires the use of 3.5-inch floppy disks. Often, an older technology was built with decades of use in-mind, so upgraded alternatives weren’t made, or threaten to break existing functions.

But it’s not just companies that have a good reason to stay technologically in the past. Take the case of George R.R. Martin, the writer of the A Song of Ice and Fire series, more commonly known as Game of Thrones. He’s a big fan of retro technology, even borrowing Ernest Cline’s Delorean at one point. However, it’s in his writing habits that he betrays his love of older software.

While Martin could certainly afford to purchase himself a high-end PC to tap away, he actually uses an ancient DOS based computer that is completely disconnected from the Internet. Even more retro, he uses the ’80s word processor WordStar 4.0 to write everything, including the ASOIAF books.

Why? Because it doesn’t have any features he doesn’t needs. “It does everything I want a word processing program to do and doesn’t do anything else,” he said on a talk show interview. Using the older device likely affords him some unique security benefits, as well.

He doesn’t have to worry about it trying to correct his spelling, which could become quite tiresome with character names like Daenerys Targaryen and Joffrey Baratheon. Nor does he have to be concerned about viruses or people hacking his machine to try and find out what he’s writing.

This is a way of thinking that’s worth consideration. While it’s exciting to be on the cutting edge, running betas, and accessing new features, it does have inherit problems. And the benefits of the cutting-edge aren’t always apparent in everyday use.

This one is on the developers

It’s not just down to us to make sure we only install software and updates that we know won’t be harmful to our system. It’s down to the developers, too. QA has become less of a focus for software developers in recent years as the ease of patching programs have improved. That leaves users at risk.

Changing the software used by millions with a single update is a big responsibility.

I’m not suggesting we would all be better off running DOS off a tape drive, but it is important to keep updates in perspective. The ability to change software used by millions of people within minutes — as in the case of Windows update — is a huge responsibility. It must be wielded with responsibility, and it should be recognized that those who don’t jump on the latest technological bandwagon aren’t always luddites. Updates, particularly to critical software, deserve to be viewed with skepticism.


2018 was a terrific year for new cameras. Here are our favorites

This year, we saw the unveiling of several exciting new cameras. We look back at our favorite models -- each delivering something unique, yet all are powerful and feature-rich. Camera fans, rejoice!

Rough it in absolute comfort with the best sleeping pads available

Shopping for a sleeping pad for your next backpacking trip? Don't buy something that feels like a cold slab of stone. Narrow your selection with our carefully selected list of the best sleeping pads available.
Home Theater

These awesome A/V receivers will swarm you with surround sound at any budget

There is no one-size-fits-all approach to shopping for a receiver, so we assembled our favorites for 2018, at multiple price points and all loaded with features, from Dolby Atmos to 4K HDR, and much more.

These are the best video games you shouldn't leave 2018 without

Developers showed up with a number of amazing games this year. Each capitalized on something unique but there's always one that outdoes them all. Here are our picks for the best video games of 2018 and game of the year.

PewDiePie supporters hack printers, hope to boost his subscription numbers

In an attempt to garner more subscribers for their favorite vlogger and secure his status as having the most YouTube subscribers, PewDiePie supporters claimed to have hacked thousands of printers worldwide.

Chrome fights manipulative sites that don’t allow you to hit the back button

Have you encountered a webpage that won't let you hit the back button? Someun scrupulous websites employ what's known as history manipulation, preventing you from hitting the back button, but now Google Chrome will be fighting back.

Forget painting-style transfers, this A.I. creates realistic portraits of fake people

Do these images look computer-generated? Nvidia researchers recently published a paper on a new variation on style transfer artificial intelligence that's able to generate entirely new portraits.

With our Steam guide, you can give the gift of gaming this holiday season

The holidays may have passed, but it's always a good time to give the gift of gaming (especially when there's a Steam sale)! Here's our quick guide on how to give a Steam game as a gift.

Leaked HP laptop listing reveals entry-level Nvidia MX250 GPU

Alongside powerful graphics cards, Nvidia may have more mobile GPUs to show off at next year's CES show in January. The MX250 has been spotted in a listing for an HP laptop, potentially replacing the entry-level MX150.

ZSpace’s laptop brings education to life with its own 3D technology

The ZSpace laptop wants to overhaul education and training by offering affordable access to 3D mixed reality through a bespoke screen and glasses technology that is already supported by a wide array of applications.

Former Microsoft intern claims Google may have sabotaged Edge browser

Google's Chrome web browser has been able to establish such dominance that Microsoft is abandoning its web rendering engine, switching Edge over to Chromium, but did Google play dirty in an attempt to force Microsoft to make the decision?

ViewSonic’s 1080p gaming monitor lets you experience the action in style

ViewSonic is catering to gamers with its latest monitor, the XG240R. Featuring a 1080p 144Hz panel, RGB lighting, and a fast 1ms response time, you can conquer your opponents and do it in style.

Here’s why you might still be using Wi-Fi after cellular 5G launches

Cellular 5G might be around the corner and promising to deliver lightning fast speeds, but the folks over at the Wi-Fi Alliance have a few reasons why they think you shouldn't dump Wi-Fi just yet.

Pinning websites to your taskbar is as easy as following these quick steps

Would you like to know how to pin a website to the taskbar in Windows 10 in order to use browser links like apps? Whichever browser you're using, it's easier than you might think. Here's how to get it done.