Skip to main content

Forget Asimov's Three Laws, the U.K. issues official ethics guidance on robots

bsi robot ethics guidelines arousal
One of the most famous pieces of writing ever about robots was presented in the Three Laws of Robotics, as laid out by sci-fi author Isaac Asimov.

The laws state that a robot may not injure a human being or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm; that a robot must obey the orders given to it by human beings, except where such orders would conflict with the First Law; and that a robot must protect its own existence, as long as such protection does not conflict with the First or Second Laws.

Related Videos

Well, it seems such laws aren’t going to remain science fiction for too much longer — since the British Standards Institution, which is the U.K.’s national standards body charged with creating the technical standards and certification for various products and services, has just produced its first set of official ethics guidelines relating to robots.

“The expert committee responsible for this thought there was really a need for a set of guidelines, setting out the ethical principles surrounding how robots are used,” Dan Palmer, head of market development at BSI, told Digital Trends. “It’s an area of big public debate right now.”

The catchily-named BS 8611 guidelines start by echoing Asimov’s Three Laws in stating that: “Robots should not be designed solely or primarily to kill or harm humans.”

However, it also takes aim at more complex issues of transparency by noting that: “It should be possible to find out who is responsible for any robot and its behavior.” There’s even discussion about whether it’s desirable for a robot to form an emotional bond with its users, an awareness of the possibility robots could be racist and/or sexist in their conduct, and other contentious gray areas.

In all, it’s an interesting attempt to start formalizing the way we deal with robots — and the way roboticists need to think about aspects of their work that extend beyond technical considerations. You can check it out here — although it’ll set you back 158 pounds ($208) if you want to read the BSI guidelines in full. (Is that ethical?)

“Robots have been used in manufacturing for a long time,” Palmer said. “But what we’re seeing now are more robots interacting with people. For instance, there are cases in which robots are being used to give care to people. These are usages that we haven’t seen before — [which is where the need for guidelines comes in.]”

Editors' Recommendations

Spot’s latest robot dance highlights new features
Spot robot dancing.

Boston Dynamics’ Spot robot has hit the dance floor again in a new video that seeks to highlight recent improvements made to the quadruped contraption.

No Time to Dance | Boston Dynamics

Read more
Watch this robot peel a banana without slipping up
A peeled banana.

While most folks can peel a banana without giving it a second thought, incorporating the same capability into a robot is a greater challenge than you might imagine.

That’s because peeling a banana is in fact a highly delicate process. With so much variation among bananas according to shape, size, ripeness, and overall condition, your brain is making a series of lightning-quick decisions every time you go to peel one.

Read more
Inside the U.K. lab that connects brains to quantum computers
A student has a EEG Cap placed on his head.

In a room at the United Kingdom’s University of Plymouth, a Ph.D. student is sitting at a computer, eyes closed as if he’s meditating. On his head is what looks like a black swimming cap, but is actually an electroencephalogram (EEG) reader that’s sensing the electrical activity passing over his scalp. In front of him, on the monitor, there’s an image of a wireframe globe with two points marked “1” and “0.” In the center of the globe, like a clock with a single hand, is an arrow that oscillates between the two points. As the student changes his expression from one of relaxation to one of wide-eyed agitation, the arrow twitches and moves. Every several seconds, he enters a new digit.

It might not look like much (and right now, it’s still very early days for this work), but it’s nonetheless fascinating stuff. As the student changes his brain patterns from calm to energized and back again, he produces alpha and beta waves that are then used to manipulate simulated qubits – the elemental unit in quantum computing, reflecting the math of quantum physics – using nothing more than the power of thought.

Read more