OS security showdown

decrypt os security showdown ailpu76
2014 has been a tumultuous year for personal security. Through the continuing revelations of NSA leaks, North Koreans shutting down Sony, and the big bad bug that made everyone’s Heart Bleed, the past twelve months have shown that the hairiest of hacks are almost always in the last place you’d think to look.

But as long as you’re not planning on releasing a movie that depicts the faux-assassination of foreign leaders in the near future, you should be safe. Right? Well, that partially depends on the operating system you use.

I’ll weigh the pros and cons of privacy from the top four consumer operating systems, and help you decide which is the best choice for maintaining the safety, security, and privacy of your personal data while working and playing online. Only one can offer the best OS security of them all.


Windows has always enjoyed a stable (read: overwhelmingly dominant) slice of the PC market, and is already long past the point of needing to prove itself. It enjoys the widest range of software around, too — a boon that’s also its curse.

When talking about security it’s hard not to mention the many pitfalls of the Windows architecture. The same wide tundra of customization users have come to expect also makes it one of the most vulnerable operating systems around. Though it would be close to impossible to list all the security flaws found burrowed in its binary during the course of the past year, one needn’t look much further than the discovery of the decades-old Schannel bug as a prime example for what users should expect whenever they run a Windows variant on their home or business networks.


An SSL vulnerability which laid dormant in every version of the OS stretching back to the earliest iterations of Windows 3.1, the Schannel vulnerability shows that even after thousands of security updates, new builds, and from-the-ground-up certification audits, the sheer magnitude of what Windows offers means it will always be a little bit further behind the curve than the rest.

And then there’s this: Microsoft cut XP from the list of Windows versions that receive regular updates from the company’s Patch Tuesday roster in March. System administrators everywhere collectively shuddered at the thought of what virus distributors would come up with to exploit an OS that makes up nearly 15 percent of current installations still active in their ecosystem.

Granted, that number has been falling steadily month by month, but the threat should still be a very real concern for anyone who wants to be sure that what they’re doing on the web isn’t being monitored or monetized by an unknown third party.

Overall, Windows is the option if you’re looking to strike a balance between hardware capability and application availability, but it falls short in security. Microsoft can’t clamp down on malware without restricting its relatively open stance towards applications — which, of course, is part of why Windows is so popular. How’s that for a bind?


This OS is built for power users and lays out a blank canvas for anyone with a bit of programming prowess who wants to create an operating system experience that’s tailor-fit just for them.

Unfortunately, much like Windows, its open-ended architecture gives viruses room to play. This year saw the introduction of Operation Windigo, a particularly ingenious piece of code that had weaseled its way into upwards of 25,000 UNIX servers and has the potential to sneak into the backdoors of another half million Linux-based desktops across the globe.


The virus spreads the way most do, by spamming out troves of infected email attachments to thousands of accounts at once, and throwing out a line to any recipients that were foolish enough to send something back.

And just a few days ago Digital Trends reported on the discovery of the holiday-hampering Grinch bug, an unfixed flaw deep in the Linux source code which gave those with knowledge of its existence the ability to access root-level control of every aspect of the Linux file system, including most builds of Android from Gingerbread to the upcoming Lollipop 5.1.

Linux benefits from its extreme range of customization options and is at its best when the used by someone who actively uses the best security practices. If you’re tech-savvy enough to take on the task, this OS is an optimal choice, but not everyone has such knowledge. Though arguably safer than Windows because it’s less frequently used (a concept known as security through obscurity) it’s not inherently more secure.

Mac OS X

“Hi, I’m a Mac. And I’m a PC.”

Unless you were living under a rock during the mid-2000’s you can probably recite with near word-for-word accuracy how the commercial goes from there. Mac is more secure than PC. Mac doesn’t get viruses, and has the cleanest, most efficient operating system. Plus, it’s obviously the much cooler choice because Justin Long is wearing a blue hoodie, opposite John Hodgman’s buttoned-down gray suit.

Apple has long since waved goodbye to its comparison campaign. Today the company focuses on the sleek, slim, and sexy design of its products instead of what makes its computers more secure than the rest. That may be because OS X is no longer a nigh-impenetrable fortress. As the rate of adoption for Apple laptops and desktops surged, malware makers looked to OS X as a viable platform for pulling in profits through their clandestine hacking networks.

2014 saw some of the largest and most financially successful exploits ever released for OS X. This list includes the traffic-logging Rootpipe trojan, an iPhone cracking installation called WireLurker, and the iSight-integrated webcam-peeping app that plagued 2013’s Miss Teen USA, Cassidy Wolf. Apple was able to coast on its low-key laurels for the better half of its lifespan, but now the wolves are circling, ready to attack the Mac’s growing user base.

Despite these slight slips, though, OS X remains one of the safest operating systems available today. Apple’s firm grasp over its operating system has resulted in a reliable string of updates that plug up holes before they have a chance to snowball out of anyone’s control. Out of all the entries in this list, OS X (and its mobile cousin iOS), are the only two that weren’t affected by the now infamous Heartbleed bug that had been tearing the Internet in two for over five years before anyone noticed it was a problem in the first place.

Increased popularity means more programs and applications are coming to OS X, which could mean more vulnerabilities. Apple has responded with a stringent approval process that catches most issues before they go live. The company has been able to keep most of the wolves at bay. For now.

Chrome OS

Now I arrive at the newest operating system in the fight. One which, by way of its youth and vigor, happens to be the most secure.

Google has, for the time being at least, landed itself in the sweet spot that Mac enjoyed for the early half of the previous decade. A comfortably covert crevice where its share of the market isn’t large enough to make serious exploits profitable (or glamorous) enough for the average hacker to pursue, and the underlying structure of its system is fresh enough that staying on top of security isn’t a cumbersome task.

Toshiba Chromebook 2 front open

Time and time again the search giant has been able to stand tall at the mother of all cryptography competitions, its very own bi-annual Pwnium hacking consortium held at the CanSecWest Security Conference. Of all the entries at the competition, Google let slip a comparatively minor three holes in its operating system and web browser combined, each of which were patched up before the contest participants could check their badges on the way off the main show floor.

The sole drawback of this operating system is that if you want your Chromebook to be more secure than it already is there’s no way to install third-party software without digging into the guts of the machine and morphing it into a box running a bastardized version of Ubuntu Linux first. Google maintains its security superiority by restricting users to the confines of the web browser and restricting the installation of third-party software.

Limited customization is always frowned on by certain users, but it’s not a bad thing for security. Chromebooks make good sense for kids or grandparents who want to get on the net as effortlessly and safely as possible. They also work wonders if you’re in need of a cheap, reliable way to stay connected on the road without having to tweak your firewall rules for every Wi-Fi hotspot along the way.

Wrap Up

So what’s the best option if security is a prime concern?

I’d have to say Chrome OS. However, the limited functionality and restricted flexibility of the operating system make it a hard sell for anyone who wants something more out of their laptop than a web browser with a couple of add-ons installed can provide.

From a practical perspective, then, OS X is the obvious choice. Apple has proven itself to be one of the best at fighting off the bad guys, yet there’s also a broad range of software available. Not as much as Windows, to be sure, but enough for most users to get their feet wet.

OS X is a prime example of what modern operating system security should look like. It’s not impenetrable, but when the chips are down and North Korea’s knocking at your back door you’d be better of with Apple’s operating system than with any other.

Image credit: isak55/Shutterstock, Jayson Photography/Shutterstock,


Former student uses USB Killer device to fry $58,000 worth of college’s PCs

A former student used a USB Killer device to short circuit more than $58,000 of computers at a private New York college earlier this year. The student pled guilty to the charges and sentencing is scheduled to begin in August.

Worried about your online privacy? We tested the best VPN services

Browsing the web can be less secure than most users would hope. If that concerns you, a virtual private network — aka a VPN — is a decent solution. Check out a few of the best VPN services on the market.
Home Theater

From the Roku Ultra to the Fire TV Cube, these are the best streaming devices

There are more options for media streamers than ever, so it’s difficult to pick the best option. But that’s why we're here. Our curated list of the best streaming devices will get you online in no time.

In 2019, laptops are better than ever. Here are the best of the best

The best laptop should be one that checks all the boxes: Great battery life, beautiful design, and top-notch performance. Our picks for the best laptops you can buy do all that — and throw in some extra features while they're at it.

Chromebooks are laptops, but they do things a little differently

Chromebooks are an intriguing branch of laptops that are often cheaper and faster than their Windows counterparts, but they are a little more limited. Intrigued? Here's everything you need to know about Chromebooks.

AMD Ryzen CPU prices get slashed ahead of Ryzen 3000 release

AMD's Ryzen CPUs have had their prices slashed as we edge towards the release of their third generation. Whether you're a gamer or someone who needs multi-threaded performance, there's a deal for everyone with some heavy discounts to take…

The number pad on HP’s Chromebook 15 makes spreadsheet work a breeze

HP's Chromebook 15 comes with a 15.6-inch display, a metal keyboard deck with full-size keys, and a dedicated number pad, making it the second Chromebook model, following Acer's Chromebook 715, to be suited for spreadsheet work.

Gaming on a laptop has never been better. These are your best options

Gaming desktops are powerful, but they tie you down to your desk. For those of us who prefer a more mobile experience, here are the best gaming laptops on the market, ranging from budget machines to maxed-out, wallet-emptying PCs.

Here's how you can download the best free music players for your Mac

Tired of your Mac's default music player? Take a look at our picks for the best free music players available for your Apple rig. Whether you're a casual listener or an audiophile, you're sure to find something that fits your needs here.

Want to make calls across the internet for less? Try these great VOIP services

Voice over IP services are getting more and more popular, but there are still a few that stand above the pack. In this guide, we'll give you a few options for the best VOIP services for home and business users.

Transform into the ultimate leader with our tips and tricks for Civilization 6

Civilization VI offers both series veterans and total newcomers a lot to chew on from the get-go. Here are some essential starting tips to help you master the game's many intricacies.

AMD’s 2020 Ryzen CPUs could have a big boost in power efficiency

The sequel to AMD's Zen 2-based Ryzen 3000 CPUs is slated for a 2020 release and when it arrives, could leverage the new Zen 3 architecture to deliver impressive gains to performance and power efficiency.

The iPhone’s Screen Time and Siri Shortcuts could land on Macs this year

For its desktop computers, it appears that Apple may continue to draw from the iPhone for inspiration. iOS 12 features, like Screen Time and Siri Shortcuts, are believed to be making their way to MacOS this year at WWDC in June.

Dell slashes prices of XPS 13 and Alienware 17 laptops in latest promo

Dell's latest promotion will score you big savings on the XPS 13 or the Alienware 17. The stylish XPS 13's discount is for $430, and only the rose gold model is on sale, while gamers who choose the Alienware 17 will save $860.