The computer mouse has served for decades, but could its reign come to an end?

The Palette offers an alternative to both mice and keyboards with an old-school approach: a customizable blend of buttons, dials and sliders.
In just a few decades, the humble computer mouse has gone from cutting-edge technology to a rather ubiquitous device — and, in fact, one that seems a little outdated in an era of holograms and hoverboards.

Trackpads and touch screens have already cast doubt on whether mice are the proper input method for modern computing, but neither has managed to kill it entirely. Could it extinction be around the corner? If so, what’s on the horizon to take its place?

A brief history of the mouse

The birth of the mouse isn’t all that simple to pinpoint, because in an odd way, it was actually born three different times.

Back in the 1940s, computing was very much in its infancy. The British Navy was working on a radar project known as the Comprehensive Display System, and user input was being communicated via a joystick,  likely due to its military origin. A scientist named Ralph Benjamin questioned whether this was the best method, and by 1946 his research had led to a prototype “ball tracker.”

Ralph Benjamin built a prototype trackball in 1946, but it was considered a British military secret.

Today, we would refer to that device as a trackball, but in 1947 it was patented as the roller ball. Benjamin’s work laid the foundation for today’s mice, but at the time it was a military secret. It would remain that way for decades, as Benjamin only revealed the timescale of his work in a 2005 interview with the IEEE History Center in 2005. In the interview, he made reference to his confidence that the “roller ball” would go on to “long-term solution” to those early input problems.

Until that 2005 interview, it had generally been agreed upon that the fathers of the mouse were Douglas Engelbart and Bill English of the Stanford Research Institute. Quite separately, the pair had created a similar ball-based device with one major difference — instead of the user directly interacting with the ball component, it would be encased within a box with the intention of being ran over a flat surface.

In 1968, Engelbart assembled an event that he referred to as ‘the mother of all demos’. He intended to bring together all the research his team had been doing, and give his audience a glimpse into the future of computing. The presentation was highly influential, and its effects are still reverberating to this day. Except he had been beaten to the punch.

A German company called Telefunken released its Rollkugel (rolling ball) device to consumers on October 2, 1968 — weeks ahead of Engelbart’s presentation on December 9 of that same year. Around the world, separate teams had come to very similar conclusions regarding the problem of input. It seemed that the mouse was the perfect method for controlling one’s computer.

Touch heralds a change, but the change might not be touch

For the most part, mice are as ubiquitous today as they ever have been. Desktop computers are rarely seen without a mouse attached, and while laptops always ship with touchpad, many users prefer to attach a portable mouse instead.

Over the last thirty years, every other computer component has radically changed. Even the USB port that connects a mouse to your system has evolved substantially, and continues to do so to this day. But the mouse itself is largely the same. The ball has been replaced by an optical or laser sensor, but it performs an identical function — just more efficiently.

Not even touch has caught on with mainstream PC owners as of yet.

It might be argued that computer users are so accustomed to using a mouse to navigate their computer that it would be difficult to convince the masses to try something new. However, the past decade has demonstrated that we’re a more adaptable bunch than some would give us credit for.

It wasn’t that long ago that touch screens were thought of as a novelty. Now, smartphones and tablets have made them just as natural to use as a traditional keyboard and mouse set-up. In fact, we’re seeing more and more hybrid devices that give users the capabilities of a desktop with the option of a touch-based interface.

Windows 10 goes out of its way to accommodate touch-centric users, and Cortana could be seen as the first step towards a voice-controlled interface. It’s clear that manufacturers are beginning to test the water for new input methods in familiar computing scenarios. But the direction we should be headed in remains elusive. There are many possibilities, but not even touch has caught on with mainstream PC owners as of yet.


Fortunately, there are some very talented people working towards the goal of a better computing experience. Some of those are stationed with the biggest names in tech, working on well-publicized projects like HoloLens. Others call smaller organizations home — but their efforts might be just as newsworthy if they can create an input method that takes off in the mainstream.

Unexpected innovations

Calvin Chu is the original designer of the Palette, a device that attempts to turn the one-device-fits-all mentality of the computer mouse on its head. “While I was an undergrad, I was very interested in human-computer interaction,” he tells me, but it wasn’t until he combined that fascination with his understanding of music production and photography that the project began to take shape.

“We’re in an era of personalization.

Calvin tells me about how the “collision” of these interests led him on the thought process that would help him and the Palette team successfully carry out a $100,000 Kickstarter campaign. “DJs have been using tactile controllers for decades. Why aren’t other professionals in the world using similar tools? Why not photographers? Why not designers?”

This line of thinking brought about the Palette, a modular collection of switches, dials and buttons that sets out to give the user the ability to build their own workspace. If you’re simply looking for one slider to use exclusively for a particular Photoshop tool, you can do that — but if you’re looking to assemble an array of dials for use with music production software like Ableton, that’s just as simple.

Related: We go hands on with Microsoft’s HoloLens headset

Calvin tells me that he’s looking to “create a new paradigm for interface,” and that implicitly suggests there’s something wrong with the current model. When the computer mouse was being designed, it was intended for a very specific purpose. Since then, our usage of computers has diversified a great deal, and the way we interact with our devices hasn’t been quick to follow.

It’s easy to find specialized computer software that caters to even the most unusual tasks, but the same can’t be said of hardware. The mouse is used for everything from simple web browsing, to photo manipulation, to video gaming. While it’s not a bad input method for any of those tasks, it stands to reason that specialized devices would be able to do a better job.

This is where the Palette steps in, thanks to its status as a “personalized peripheral.” While the device is just one of many projects looking to redefine the methods we use to interact with our systems, the philosophy behind it seems to be a winning formula.”We’re in an era of personalization,” Calvin says. “Experiences and products revolve around the user, and not the other way around.”

Best laid plans

In its time, the computer mouse was nothing less than a revelation. The burgeoning world of computers might never have taken flight without such a robust input method, and for that, all those involved with its creation deserve a great deal of credit. However, that doesn’t mean that we shouldn’t look to improve upon it.

It would be foolish to say that the mouse of today isn’t fit for its purpose. Still, there’s plenty of untapped potential for other input methods like Palette. In the fluid world of technology, there’s always room for a new product that can simply do the job better.

Perhaps one day, we’ll look at the mouse like we do the floppy disk. It’s still a part of the culture of computing — at this point, it would be sacrilege to see a save icon that looks like anything else. But the floppy disk was killed off by new thinking that took advantage of advances in technology, and computing is better for it.


A turn for the better: Loupedeck+ adds custom dials, more to Lightroom console

The Loupedeck+ improves on the original Lightroom console by adding welcome customization options and introducing support for Skylum Aurora HDR. What's even better is that it does this all at an even lower price.

Apple AR glasses will launch in 2020, says respected industry analyst

Apple AR glasses may be closer to reality than we thought. Here is everything we know so far about the augmented reality system, including the rumored specifications of Apple's Project Mirrorshades.

‘Super Smash Bros. Ultimate’ goes all-in on fan service, and it’s better for it

The ridiculous number of characters and stages in Super Smash Bros. Ultimate proves Nintendo understands the series is about fan service before competitive fighting, and the game will be better for it.
Home Theater

What is MHL, exactly, and how does it work with your TV?

There are more ways to mirror your smartphone or tablet to your TV than you might think. Check out our rundown of MHL for everything you need to know about the wired protocol and its myriad uses.

Nvidia teases new GeForce RTX 2080 launch at Gamescom next week

Gamers will have something exciting to look forward to next week when Gamescom starts. Nvidia posted a teaser video to YouTube containing hints that it could use the venue to announce the new GeForce RTX 2080 graphics chip.

Nvidia introduces its eighth-generation ‘Turing’ design, but not in gaming cards

Nvidia revealed its new graphics chip design called “Turing” during SIGGRAPH 2018. Rumored to be the foundation of Nvidia’s next family of GeForce cards, the company instead showcased Turing in Quadro RTX-branded cards for pros.

The browser-based Monero miner Coinhive generates around $250,000 each month

Despite a fall in cryptocurrency mining, the Coinhive Monero miner is still highly active, generating around $250,000 each month. Coinhive also contributes 1.18 percent of the total mining power behind the Monero blockchain.
Home Theater

HDMI 2.0b is a whole lot more than just a connection to your TV

HDMI 2.0b is the backbone for many of the latest updates in 4K UHD technology. And while a new cable standard can often involve a bunch of changes for consumers, that is not the case this time around.

Want to watch Netflix in bed or browse the web? We have a tablet for everyone

There’s so much choice when shopping for a new tablet that it can be hard to pick the right one. From iPads to Android, these are our picks for the best tablets you can buy right now whatever your budget.

For work or for play, these are the 5 best laptop deals for college students

Whether you're getting ready for a new school year, shopping for a special student, or just need a new computer, we've got you covered: These are the five best laptop deals going right now, from discounted MacBooks to an on-the-go gaming…

Steam survey shows PC gamers are still mostly playing in 1080p and lower

Valve Software’s latest hardware and software survey for July 2reveals that 63.72 percent of Steam’s registered members still play games with a 1080p resolution. Even more, only 1.14 percent are playing at a 4K resolution.

The Andromeda botnet still lingers as nations struggle to clean infected PCs

A report by Fortinet suggests that although the FBI and Europe ended the Andromeda botnet’s reign in late 2017, there are still infected PCs. Cleaning up these PCs isn’t progressing at the same pace across various regions.

8 easy ways for you to transfer photos from an Android phone to a PC

If you haven't already, you should back up your photos to a computer. Here's how to transfer photos from an Android phone to a PC using third-party services and a wealth of storage devices.

Windows 10 can split and resize windows with ease. Here's how to do it

Windows 10 is a great desktop operating system, and its many window management features are part of the reason why. Here's how to divvy up windows using Snap Assist and other native tools.