Intel can’t keep up Moore’s Law, and we’ll all suffer

Gordon Moore
Intel
On April 19, 1965, Gordon Moore, future co-founder of Intel, predicted that transistors on a single computer chip would double in capacity annually for the next 10 years. When his forecasts materialized, Moore extended that rule to every two years, and for the past half century, Moore’s Law has ruled the semiconductor production space.

“My real objective was to get the idea across [that] we have the technology that’s going to make electronics cheap,” explained Moore in a video posted by Intel earlier this year. “But I didn’t expect this binary order of magnitude increase — the thousand-fold increase in complexity — to be very accurate.”

IBM built a 7nm chip last week, putting Intel behind the curve for the first time in years. 

Moore, now 86, never expected his axiom to catch on with tech companies to the degree that it did. But, to be clear, Moore’s Law isn’t a law at all, because it doesn’t technically govern or dictate. Moore’s Law was an observation of trends — and a prediction of what might be possible.

Intel has become the shining beacon of processor research and production, particularly in the consumer space. It has continually broken ground on smaller production nodes, and it currently owns four fabrication facilities capable of working on the cutting-edge 14 nano-meter process. The closest competitors, Samsung and Global Foundries, have just one each, and the latter company’s fab facility reached “volume production” capability just a few months ago.

Now, however, even Intel is having trouble with smaller, more advanced production. Its 10nm process has been “indefinitely” delayed, and a new 14nm design has been stuck in its place — a rare event. Does Intel’s struggle indicate a broader issue, and the possible end of Moore’s Law?

“Ticked” off by delays

As Bob Dylan once famously declared, the times they are a-changin’, an utterance not limited to Moore’s Law, which has undergone numerous alterations over the years, but one thing remains consistent. That is, the number of transistors in an integrated circuit generally doubles over a set period of time. Thanks to former Intel executive David House, 18 months has served as the magic number since 1975.

Nowadays, Intel is unquestionably the world’s most successful chip maker, but the cancellation of the 10nm process raises concern. IBM built a 7nm chip last week, putting Intel behind the curve for the first time in years. As it turns out, radically advancing technology is often paired with equally profound challenges.

intel-tick-tock-model
Intel
Intel

What was once perceived as the law of the land may have finally met its match. In the case of Intel, the complications started back in 2013 when its 14nm Broadwell chips were delayed until early 2014. Intel CEO Brian Krzanich blamed a “defect density issue,” which directly impacted chip production. Put simply, too many chips were leaving the line with problems.

The delay was not only significant due to its impact on Moore’s Law, but the move negatively affected Intel’s “tick-tock” model, which has been in place for the company since 2007. Tick-tock takes the fundamental principle of Moore’s Law and integrates it into a series of procedural cycles. Each “tick” aims to introduce a new shrinking of the previous architecture’s process technology while every “tock” brings forth a new micro-architecture design. Intel has held true to this cadence since 2007 without difficulty. The sudden stumble is curious.

Skipping a beat

While Broadwell’s chips were technically available in late 2014, the initial roll-out only targeted low-power laptops. Even then, the pickings were slim. Now Broadwell is finally making its way to consumers and businesses alike, albeit only months before the launch of Intel’s next micro-architecture redesign, or “tock” as Intel would insist.

Intel’s tick-tock cadence could be headed towards extinction.

That tock is Skylake, better known as 6th-generation Core, and it will be out sometime in August or September, as scheduled. What should follow is a “tick” to a 10nm processor, which planned, and code-named Cannon Lake. It is now delayed.

Therefore, the next scheduled tick in its corporate roadmap will be interrupted by yet another tock. That tock is Kaby Lake, the successor to Skylake and Intel’s third micro-architecture in a row to feature a 14nm manufacturing process, a consequence of the company’s failure to fully realize its next-generation die shrink technology.

The mere existence of Kaby Lake indicates the “Tick-Tock” could be headed towards extinction, undeterred by Krzanich’s utter denial on the matter. In a recent earnings call, however, the Intel CEO did admit that “the last two technology transitions have signaled that our cadence today is closer to 2.5 years than two,” according to The Verge.

Reputation Reparations

Intel’s recent behavior appears to signify the beginning of the end for the historically effective observations of Gordon Moore. And, from there, the speculation only gets worse. Following the launch of Cannonlake and its presumably 10nm successor, Intel’s next microarchitecture shrink is scheduled to feature a 7nm chip processing technology. However, in doing so, Intel has acknowledged that the use of new materials will be required — which could very well cause even greater delays.

Moore’s Law might not die if there was another company that could pick up Intel’s slack — but there isn’t. IBM has managed to produce a 7nm chip in the lab, but it has no capability to market such a chip to consumer electronics. It is working with two major partners, Samsung and Global Foundries, towards that end. But IBM says the process won’t actually be ready for serious production until 2017 or 2018, at the earliest.

Intel Core M Broadwell Y Package Diagonal
Intel’s 14nm Broadwell package Intel

And while both those partners are major players in the chip industry, neither has the production capacity to rival Intel’s broad product roll-outs. Even if IBM’s breakthrough encounters no delays, which is unlikely, we’ll see 7nm chips debut only in a small number of premium devices, like Samsung Galaxy smartphones. Moore’s Law has been important not only because companies manage to achieve impressive cadence, but also because the resulting chips showed up in computers quickly, something made possible by Intel’s mass of fabrication facilities.

Moore’s Law was never intended to last forever, and it seems now that we’re beginning to see why. Not only is this a sign of the world’s Intel’s inability to keep up, but when the world’s biggest chip company is incessantly suffering from manufacturing issues, consumers see the consequences. If a rising tide lifts all ships, then the reverse is also true — and it appears the tide is going out.

Product Review

Long live the king! Dell’s new XPS 13 defends its throne with ease

The redesigned Dell XPS 13 doesn’t reinvent the laptop’s winning formula, but does offer much-needed tweaks including the latest Intel hardware and a thinner, lighter body. Is it enough to keep Dell’s laptop at the top of our ratings?
Computing

AMD is pulling ahead in the die shrink race with 7nm CPUs and graphics cards

AMD might have played second fiddle to Intel and AMD for a long time, but it has the potential to leapfrog both when it debuts its new 7nm CPUs and graphics cards in 2019, leading the die-shrink race for the first time in years.
Computing

AMD’s impressive Vega 7nm graphics cards arrive, but they’re not for gaming

AMD's new Vega 20 graphics cards are the first 7nm GPUs to become available, but they won't be rendering your next game. They're more likely to end up in server and render farms, bringing enormous memory bandwidth with them.
Computing

In 2018, the rivalry between AMD and Intel has become more interesting than ever

When it comes to selecting a CPU for your PC, there's no shortage of chips for you to choose from. With Ryzen, Threadripper, and Core i9 CPUs though, the AMD vs. Intel argument is muddier than ever.
Computing

Stay connected with the Surface Go LTE Advanced, coming November 20 for $679

The new Surface Go LTE Advanced model delivers benefits for anyone who is looking to enjoy LTE coverage and stay connected on Windows 10 when traveling on the road or away from home.
Computing

Cloudflare’s privacy-enhancing 1.1.1.1 DNS service comes to iOS and Android

Cloudflare's 1.1.1.1 DNS resolver service has been ported to mobile devices, and now anyone with an Android or iOS device can download it for free to take advantage of its speed and privacy-boosting features.
Gaming

The plug-and-play PC Classic joins the retro console bandwagon

Gaming company Unit-e is creating the PC Classic, a plug-and-play retro console that will come bundled with around 30 of the best DOS games. The system will support gamepads and keyboard setups.
Computing

Is your PC slow? Here's how to restore Windows 10 to factory settings

Computers rarely work as well after they've accumulated files and misconfigured settings. Thankfully, with this guide, you'll be able to restore your PC to its original state by learning how to factory reset Windows.
Computing

Best Buy’s pre-Black Friday deal takes $330 off the 2017 Surface Pro bundle

If you don't need the latest Surface Pro, Best Buy has a heavily discounted rendition of the 2017 model available in its pre-Black Friday sale. For just $1,000, you can get the tablet with a Core i5 CPU.
Computing

If you've lost a software key, these handy tools can find it for you

Missing product keys getting you down? We've chosen some of the best software license and product key finders in existence, so you can locate and document your precious keys on your Windows or MacOS machine.
Computing

Mozilla’s built-in price-tracking extension makes it easy to shop with Firefox

Mozilla has heard those worries about Black Friday shopping, and is now introducing a new set of experimental extensions which aim to make it easier to find the best deals online.
Computing

Buying a laptop on Black Friday? Don't make one of these rookie mistakes

Shopping for a laptop on Black Friday can win you some excellent deals, but you should also avoid making common mistakes. Check out what to avoid when buying a laptop for Black Friday and what danger signs to be wary of.
Computing

The Mac mini's price jump has crept into iMac territory. How do they compare?

Apple announced a long-awaited update to the Mac mini. Thanks to the updated specs and increase in price, it's begun to creep up to the base model iMac. In this guide, we now put up the specs on the newest refreshed Mac mini against the…
Computing

Our favorite Windows apps will help you get the most out of your new PC

Not sure what apps you should be downloading for your newfangled Windows device? Here are the best Windows apps, whether you need something to speed up your machine or access your Netflix queue. Check out our categories and favorite picks.