Skip to main content

Is it time for the government to rein in Google?

Google’s insatiable appetite for expansion is well documented and increasingly worrisome to those who doubt the company’s genuine commitment to its adopted motto “don’t be evil.” In case you need reminding, Google currently has dozens of tech ventures that include an e-mail service, online advertising, a Web browser, an Internet mapping service, a mobile operating system, office software applications, and not to mention an effort to become the world’s largest library.

In a recent column, Washington Post writer Steven Pearlstein suggests that Google’s dominance in the tech world is ipso facto not a good thing and that the federal government should work to curb Google’s expansion into new technology sectors.

Related Videos

“Where I have a problem,” Pearlstein says, “is in allowing Google to buy its way into new markets and new technologies, particularly when the firms being bought already have a dominant position in their respective market niches.”

Google can use its vast riches to easily bully its way into new markets wherever it sees fit. The question, Pearlstein asks, is whether or not Google is buying companies to simply derail competition. Pearlstein suggests that Google may buy companies in markets not only to prevent smaller companies from growing into competitors, but as a means to preempt established competitors from making strategic acquisitions themselves thus becoming a greater challenger to Google’s dominance. Pearlstein says that’s not only bad for competition, but also bad for creative innovation in the tech industry.

According to Pearlstein, the failure of antiquated antitrust laws to be successfully applied to the economics of the tech industry is, in large, part responsible for Google’s ability to spread so quickly and so easily into new tech markets. In a blog post (posted through Google’s own blogging service), Google’s Deputy Council Don Harrison, takes issue with the suggestion that it is not operating within the spirit of antitrust laws:

Antitrust law is designed to protect consumers, not competitors, and our acquisitions have created great things for consumers. Our 2004 acquisition of Keyhole led to Google Earth, which for the first time provided free satellite imagery for consumers. Our 2005 acquisition of a small company called Android–and our investment in the technology that Andy Rubin was developing–later led to the creation of the Android mobile operating system, which has injected more competition and openness into the smartphone space.

Pearlstein admits that it won’t be easy for regulators to mount a challenge against Google, but that it may well worth the effort in the pursuit of continued innovation in the technology industry. “Aggressive enforcement of the antitrust laws has been a crucial part of the history of technological innovation in this country,” Pearlstein writes,  “enforcement that allowed AT&T to be supplanted by IBM, IBM by Microsoft and Microsoft by Google.”

Editors' Recommendations

Topics
Get this 22-inch monitor for $80 with this limited time deal
cyber monday deals drop this 22 inch dell monitor to 110 se2222h feat image

Do you need to replace your old monitor but you're on a tight budget? Then you shouldn't miss Dell's offer for the Dell SE2222H monitor, which you can currently get for a very cheap $80. You'll pocket $50 in savings from its original price of $130 if you're able to take advantage of the discount, which may go away at any moment like most monitor deals that are this affordable.

Why you should buy the Dell SE2222H monitor
The Dell SE2222H monitor is the perfect partner to a new PC that you got from desktop computer deals. It's made by a brand that's a mainstay in our list of the best monitors, so you know that you'll be getting a top-quality display. The Dell SE2222H monitor features a 22-inch screen with Full HD resolution, for bright colors and clear details when you're working on projects, watching streaming content, and browsing the internet. The monitor also offers a 60Hz refresh rate, which is how often the images on the screen are updated, and an 8ms response time, which is how quickly image transitions are shown, according to our computer monitor buying guide.

Read more
The biggest Apple design fails and screw-ups of all time
Apple Pencil

Apple is world-famous for its design success stories, from the iMac G3 to all the best iPhones. But things don’t always go according to plan, even for the most design-savvy tech firm on the planet.

No, Apple has had its fair share of design howlers over the years. Here, we’ve rounded up eight of the most egregious design sins Apple has ever committed. It’s a good reminder that no one is above dropping a few absolute clunkers -- even Apple.
The butterfly keyboard

Read more
What is 5G? Speeds, coverage, comparisons, and more
The 5G UW icon on the Samsung Galaxy S23.

It's been years in the making, but 5G — the next big chapter in wireless technology — is finally approaching the mainstream. While we haven't yet reached the point where it's available everywhere, nearly all of the best smartphones are 5G-capable these days, and you're far more likely to see a 5G icon lit up on your phone than not.

There's more to 5G than just a fancy new number, though. The technology has been considerably more complicated for carriers to roll out since it covers a much wider range of frequencies than older 4G/LTE technology, with different trade-offs for each. It's also a much farther-reaching wireless technology, promising the kind of global connectivity that was once merely a dream found in futuristic sci-fi novels.

Read more