Skip to main content

Judge backs govt. order to seize email accounts in criminal investigation

how to change your gmail account password version 1413698423
Image used with permission by copyright holder
Magistrate Judge Gabriel W. Gorenstein of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York defended an order that granted the government the ability to seize the contents of a Gmail account in connection with a money laundering investigation. The government was also granted access to address book and draft mail data as well.

However, this decision runs contrary to opinions offered in other courts around the country in Kansas, and the District of Columbia. A D.C. judge denied access to an email account because doing so would allow the government to get a hold of data “for which it has not established probable cause.” Meanwhile, the court in Kansas stated that a warrant similar to the one issued by Judge Gorenstein did not “limit the universe of electronic communications and information to be turned over to the government to the specific crimes being investigated.”

Due to the fact that communications between drug dealers often contain codewords in an effort to evade the attention of law enforcement officials, searching through emails isn’t a cut and dry exercise. That seems to be at least part of the basis of Gorenstein’s argument.

“For example, in a drug investigation, it might be obvious based on information from an informant or other source that emails referring to the purchase or importation of ‘dolls’ refers to cocaine, but investigators might only learn as the investigation unfolds that a seemingly innocuous email referring to purchase of ‘potatoes’ also refers to a cocaine shipment,” Gorenstein said.

Though the D.C. judge gave the government the option to enlist an email provider’s help with an investigation, Gorenstein said that the email service provider may not be able to adequately assist in these kinds of situations.

“While an agent steeped in the investigation could recognize the significance of particular language in emails, an employee of the email host would be incapable of doing so,” Gorenstein said.

Judge Gorenstein’s support for the search and seizure of an email account will likely raise privacy concerns, and it will be interesting to see whether Google issues a statement on the matter.

Konrad Krawczyk
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Konrad covers desktops, laptops, tablets, sports tech and subjects in between for Digital Trends. Prior to joining DT, he…
How to install Windows on a Chromebook
The HP Dragonfly Pro Chromebook rear view showing lid and logo.

The Google Chromebook is an excellent alternative to traditional PC setups, but some users may miss the look and feel of a Windows machine. If you’re the proud owner of a Chromebook, and yearn for the Microsoft OS experience, you’re in luck. Using a few simple tools, a couple of installs, and some patience, it’s actually not too difficult to get Windows 11 or 10 onto a Chromebook.

Read more
How to build a PC from scratch: A beginner’s guide for building your own desktop computer
Installing RAM in a desktop PC.

Building a PC from scratch might seem like a daunting task. From motherboards and CPUs to GPUs and cooling systems, there are a lot of moving pieces to consider. But despite all these fancy components, building a desktop computer is surprisingly simple. In fact, if you know how to handle a screwdriver and aren't afraid of connecting a few cables, it's possible for beginners to build a PC that's powerful enough to handle even the most demanding games and software.

Read more
How to convert your VHS tapes to DVD, Blu-ray, or digital
VHS tape lifestyle DVD burner combo deck

While DVD and Blu-ray dominate today's world, VHS tapes ruled supreme in the '80s and '90s. It wasn't uncommon for families to document birthday parties, holidays, sporting events, and other big moments in life with their handheld camcorder, recording the footage onto a trusty VHS tape. Unfortunately, playing those VHS tapes is challenging nowadays, as it's unlikely that you still have your old VHS player (or that it's even still in working condition).

That means you'll need to look into converting your VHS tapes to DVD, Blu-ray, or digital formats to take a trip down memory lane. Even if you're not interested in checking out the footage today, it makes sense to get the film converted – after all, those VHS tapes are slowly deteriorating, and if they go bad, all that footage will be forever lost.

Read more