Skip to main content

Forget Windows! Mac OS X Yosemite is the update desktop users deserve

Promotional logo for WWDC 2023.
This story is part of our complete Apple WWDC coverage

The last two years have been filled with much woe for desktop PC owners. Windows 8 was designed from the ground up with touch in mind, resulting in a compromised operating system that doesn’t properly serve the needs of desktops or tablets. Fortunately, there is an OS giving users exactly what they want – and its name is OS X Yosemite.

Mobile makes the desktop better

The rumors that leaked out prior to Yosemite’s reveal correctly guessed that the company would continue to change its desktop operating system with interface ideas inspired by iOS. This was a cause for concern, because what works on mobile often doesn’t work on the desktop, as Windows 8 so aptly demonstrated.

Apple, however, has deftly integrated mobile features with the desktop environment. Most shocking was the reveal of full SMS and voice call integration with OS X. Got an iPhone? Now all of your text messages and phone calls can be received on your desktop, too – and the integration works both ways. Want to call a number you see while browsing on your desktop? No need to pick up your phone! You can call directly from Safari. Skype has been trying for years to convince users that the PC can be used as a phone, but never succeeded. With a single announcement, Apple has accomplished what the now Microsoft-owned service never could.

Unlike Microsoft, however, Apple only borrows ideas that work.

Perhaps the most useful feature, though, is Handoff. Owners of iPhones and iPads can now instantly transition between a mobile device and a Mac. If you have a spreadsheet open on your desktop, for example, but you have to leave for a meeting, you can beam it from your Mac to your iPhone. And you can do the opposite when you return. This functionality extends to documents, Web pages, and more.

These two features are just the start of a long list of extras that build upon the strengths of iOS. The Notification Center, Spotlight, Safari, Email and Calendar all in some way integrate with or borrow ideas from Apple’s mobile devices, making the desktop stronger in the process.

Unlike Microsoft, however, Apple only borrows ideas that work. There’s still no sign of touchscreen integration, no fat, finger-friendly icons, and no replacement of the desktop itself. OS X Yosemite builds on the dominance of iOS, but doesn’t force desktop owners into changes they don’t want or need. That’s a strategy that offers the best of both worlds.

The cloud at your fingertips

This theme carries over to iCloud, where Apple has once again leveraged its expanding cloud services to provide interesting and accessible features. iCloud Drive, which allows automatic syncing of files between OS X, iOS and Windows devices, is the most useful. It’s effectively DropBox, except it comes baked into the operating system from the start.

Cloud storage isn’t new, of course. Microsoft has had SkyDrive, now called OneDrive, for some time. But the problem with OneDrive, as is the case with so much of Windows, is the interface. The default OneDrive app uses the Metro design, which doesn’t work well with a mouse. To enjoy the service on your desktop, you must download another app from Microsoft’s website which operates independently from the one supplied with Windows. If this sounds confusing, that’s because it is.

OneDrive also lacks the wide range of features that iCloud in OS X makes available. There’s no equivalent to iTunes Match, iCloud KeyChain, Photo Stream, or iCloud’s backup and restore features. Microsoft simply lacks the infrastructure and experience necessary to replicate any of this functionality in OneDrive or Windows.

Apple’s iCloud integration has become so important, in fact, that it’s starting to look like a pseudo operating system. You can’t use it to run apps, but you can use it to store data, exchange data, and communicate with others. The fact that Apple controls iCloud, OS X and iOS provides a level of integration no other operating system can match, and allows all three platforms to work together as if they really were a single OS.

The desktop is still the desktop

WWDC 2014 made it clear that OS X 10.10 is a major update which will provide a wide array of new features. Yet, it also made it clear that, for Apple, the desktop is still exactly that. The core user experience remains largely the same.

This approach stands in stark contrast to Windows, which has drastically altered the user experience over the last year and a half or so. Many desktop owners (and some laptop users, too) have protested against the disappearance of the Start Menu, and the need to enter the Metro interface to perform some tasks. While these complaints haven’t fallen on deaf ears, the subsequent updates to Windows 8 have restored features at a lazy pace.

Apple’s approach treats the desktop as the primary workspace, and utilizes it to maximum effect.

Consider, for example, a comparison between Windows Search and Spotlight. As of OS X Yosemite, these two features will do many of the same things. Both will pull search results from the Internet, both can find files or apps, and both can pull in location data when needed.

Yet, these features are accessed in drastically different ways. Windows Search has bound itself to a swipe-out interface on the right side of the screen, an approach that limits usable space and is jarring to desktop users. The new version of Spotlight, by contrast, will appear front and center, providing far more usable space. Spotlight also takes up only a portion of the desktop, giving users the chance to maneuver other windows and icons around it. Apple’s approach treats the desktop as the primary workspace, and utilizes it to maximum effect; Microsoft’s approach ignores it, and pretends that the PC is an over-sized tablet.

Conclusion

OS X Yosemite looks to be an impressive operating system that manages to blend the convenience and utility of mobile devices, with the productivity of the desktop. Switching between devices will become instantaneous and hassle-free – as long as you have an iPhone or iPad, of course. The level of device integration introduced at WWDC 2014 is unprecedented, and no other company is currently in a position to match it.

Yet, all of the new features added to OS X 10.10 are designed to complement, rather than replace the desktop experience that users have known for over a decade. This creates a perfect match of form and function. The feature set Apple offers is so compelling, that even I, a dedicated Windows user since the days of Windows 95, am considering a switch. Yosemite is every bit as compelling as Windows 8.1 is not.

If you asked me ten years if I thought OS X or Windows would provide a better environment for productivity, I’d have said Windows without question. But Microsoft’s strange path has reversed each company’s role. Now it’s Apple, not Microsoft, which treats the desktop with reverence.

Matthew S. Smith
Matthew S. Smith is the former Lead Editor, Reviews at Digital Trends. He previously guided the Products Team, which dives…
Mail app for macOS will soon get an overdue AI upgrade
Mail app with categories in macOS.

Apple delivered a notable upgrade to the Mail app a few weeks ago, introducing intelligent categories to keep the inbox uncluttered and make discovery of relevant content easier. The trick, however, was limited to the mobile platform, and never appeared on Macs.

That is about to change soon. In the latest edition of his PowerOn newsletter, Bloomberg’s Mark Gurman claims that Mail categories will finally make an appearance in the desktop client this April.

Read more
I found an app that fixes macOS Sequoia’s annoying pop-ups
macOS Sequoia being introduced by Apple's Craig Federighi at the Worldwide Developers Conference (WWDC) 2024.

Years ago, back when I used Windows Vista, I got so annoyed by the constant User Account Control (UAC) pop-ups asking for permission seemingly every time I did anything that I downloaded an app that could silence them for good. Perhaps not the most sensible thing to do from a security perspective -- OK, definitely not the most sensible thing to do -- but I was a desperate man. These days, I’m getting similar vibes from macOS Sequoia.

That’s because Apple’s latest operating system will nag you about permissions on a monthly basis for anything that records your screen. Granted, it’s not as frequent as what I’d get in Windows Vista -- and these prompts were actually weekly in the macOS Sequoia beta, which caused such a blowback from users that Apple changed the frequency -- but it still feels like it’s going to be a real pain for me and a lot of users. Sure, macOS Sequoia hasn’t actually been out long enough for me to be bugged by these alerts every month yet, but I don’t want to hang around until I start pulling my hair out. I need to take action now.

Read more
macOS Sequoia fixes a problem that’s bugged me for years
The iPhone Mirroring feature from macOS Sequoia being demonstrated at the Worldwide Developers Conference (WWDC) 2024.

Sometimes, people think it’s the big, headline features -- like Apple Intelligence -- that make an operating system great. But there’s one new feature in macOS Sequoia that shows the opposite is true -- that a collection of less glamorous, yet meaningful changes can have a much bigger impact.

I’m talking about Apple’s new iPhone Mirroring feature. Or rather, one particular element of iPhone Mirroring: its new drag-and-drop ability. Even in the few short days it’s been available, it’s managed to improve my daily workflow and fix an issue that’s been bugging me for years.

Read more